fredmiranda.com Login
Trade safely
Please use protected, insured payment methods for all transactions
This topic is in the 2004 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2004some EBAY weirdness...

  
 
bruyn32
Offline

p.3 #1some EBAY weirdness...
Anyone who emails another in an attempt to convince them to back out of a contract should be careful. "Tortious interference with a contract" is often actionable at law. I doubt anyone would pursue it over a loss of $180 profit, but the principle is the same...
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:57 AM
DSeelig
Offline
[X]

p.3 #2some EBAY weirdness...
Rachel was legally able to back out . the ad was shady . I sent a private message to her on ebay I did not publicly emabarass any one. Nor would i do such a thing. We are not here to rip each other off call names or any other such behaviour.
Jun 02, 2004 at 11:24 AM
fratello25
Offline

p.3 #3some EBAY weirdness...
I'm sure my opinion will not be the popular one, but I get the feeling that the people who do not like any mention of competitors' prices want this to become a sellers' forum. Essentially, to be blunt, the seller posts his price, and no one should dare (or have the opportunity to) say anything about it (except to say what a good price it is). On the other hand, I'm coming at these ads from the point of view of a buyer (which I am 99% of the time). Things on this forum get put on the market and get sold in a remarkably short time. To do research as to the appropriate price often means not getting the item. And the reality is that unlike the veterans on this forum, there are a lot of us who don't know by heart the average selling price of Canon dotthingy EW-32 dash 8 or Nikon thingamajig FXXD. From this point of view, I appreciate having people post BOTH "that's a great price" AND "Canon is now offering a rebate on this". I've made a couple of purchases on the spot because of these latter comments.

In my opinion, the seller, who presumably has done research on the value of their item, should be able, in good faith, to defend their price compared to the competition, provided the competition comes from a reliable source (B&H, ADorama, etc.). I.e. "my item comes with a filter and a hood" or "I've sold 600 items on here, and my reputation as an honest seller is worth an extra 10%". It is then up to the free market (i.e. the buyers) to decide whether that is a fair deal.

A seller who does not like to be compared to the competition implies that he's got something to hide... they're hoping that people won't know that B&H is selling the same item for $20 more, and should someone tell them about that, they won't buy the item at FM. They're essentially preying on people's ignorance. On Ebay, I have no problem with that. That's an auction place and for the large part, the buyer does not set the price. But on FM, which is a community forum composed of photographers, I would hope we are above that. I would certainly hope that if someone posted that EF-S lens for $275 and as a newbie, I was interested in buying it, that someone would have the decency to inform me of my mistake. Should I then decide that the lens is worth $275 to me, for whatever reason, then I take the responsibility onto myself, and have no right to bitch in the future.

I have seen so many generous people here on FM... the freebie post, the donations to help someone who's been ripped off, that I think I've become spoiled as to what I should expect here. When I then see posts that are clearly meant to promote taking advantage of people because of their lack of knowlege of the latest prices, I guess I get a little frustrated.

In the end, it comes down to whether you see this as a buyer's, or a seller's forum. Until we get some guidance from above (Fred), I don' t think the practice of comparing prices will end. I, for one, would hate to see it go. In the meantime, instead of bickering back and forth endlessly and calling people thieves, maybe sellers can simply get used to, as part of their sales pitch, convincing people why they should buy it from them instead of elsewhere. After all, it's common enough to see in ads that "B&H is selling it for $X, but I'm selling it for $Y." I don't see many of these kinds of posts "hijacked".
Jun 02, 2004 at 12:05 PM
gooch
Offline

p.3 #4some EBAY weirdness...
See, I have a problem with that statement David:

". the ad was shady"

I'm assuming you believe that because it did not state that the lens can only be used on a D-Rebel. (If I am wrong about that please let me know) but ...

Bidders can email sellers (here and on the the bay) if they have questions about certain items.

In my opinion even if the winner of that auction only has an EOS 1V I still don't see the deception.

If I buy a Canon 1.4X teleconverter ... but I bought it for my 80-200 2.8 L ... it's my fault that I bought an acessory that wont work with my lens.

IMHO and ad for a Canon 1.4x isnt deceptive if it doesn't explicity state that it will only work on Canon lenses with recessed rear elements.

Continuing the thought, an ad for an EF-S lens isnt deceptive if it doesn't explicitly state that it can only work on a D-Rebel ...

... and an ad for a Canon FD 50mm SSC lens isnt deceptive if it doesnt explicitly state that it wont work on and EOS camera.

People have to be responsible for their actions (i.e. purchases)

Sorry for the ramble everyone.

Patrick
Jun 02, 2004 at 12:21 PM
gooch
Offline

p.3 #5some EBAY weirdness...
fratello25

I agree with a lot of what you have said but this forum is both.

Buyer and Seller just as eBay is Buyer and Seller.

The Buyers on FM do set the price.

They can PM the seller and offer less or more than the sellers initial price.

Thats why you see a good portion of FS threads updated with "PRICE LOWERED"

Because they had no takers at their price and they reduce the price to make it more attractive to people.

Anyway, my point is this forum is both.

One is not necessarily better than the other.

Jun 02, 2004 at 12:28 PM
DSeelig
Offline
[X]

p.3 #6some EBAY weirdness...
I strickly believe in pm ing people . in terms of sportsshooter, most of the members are professional photgraphers , not amatuers in a hobby it is a site you have to pay to be a member of, switching to digital has been a necessity for us. A very expensive one . Young pros upgrading systems are more broke then you can imagine. For all the equipment at the end of my list I make a very low income, according to the us goverment I am poor,and I know that pro sports guys for the most part are in the same boat. Are we here to help each other or not . David
Jun 02, 2004 at 12:39 PM
Jan Brittenson
Offline

p.3 #7some EBAY weirdness...
Then you can also end up doing what I just did yesterday morning: put a few proxy bids before dashing out on items that will end while out. Except on one item I accidentally hit the BIN and Submit button without thinking. Doh. Ended up paying about $65 more than I intended to bid. Saved $200 over new on this mint LNIB item from a dealer, but still...

Perhaps I could have told the seller I bought it by mistake and weasled out of it. Instead I figured live and learn, pay better attention next time. It was my mistake, not theirs. Hey, at least I didn't end up buying a car or house!
Jun 02, 2004 at 12:43 PM
Vivek
Offline

p.3 #8some EBAY weirdness...
I agree with everything that Patrick (gooch) has said above. Thanks Patrick for putting it in such a lucid manner. My thoughts exactly.

Fratello25, I am sorry I do not agree with your assessment of this forum. Like Patrick said, the forum is for both buying and selling. I have personally used it for both buying and selling.

I believe that if you feel you must correct someone, the least you could do is not post a reply saying "XYZ is selling it for a whopping W dollars less". I think one should always use other private methods (PM, Email, phone anything), if one believes s/he must inform the buyer/seller.

I do not think that fraud was committed with the e-bay listing. The buyer is certainly guilty of ignorance, but I find it illogical that this be construed as fraud on the seller's part.

BTW, this is my first and last post on this subject.

-- Vivek
Jun 02, 2004 at 12:45 PM
letjin
Offline

p.3 #9some EBAY weirdness...
Just a side note, another ignorant person purchased the 18-55 lens for $275 with buy it now. On the title it says "EF" not "EF-s" so it may qualify for "deceptive" ad?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=30066&item=3819354693&rd=1
Jun 02, 2004 at 01:19 PM
Scott Sewell
Offline

p.3 #10some EBAY weirdness...
letjin wrote:
Just a side note, another ignorant person purchased the 18-55 lens for $275 with buy it now. On the title it says "EF" not "EF-s" so it may qualify for "deceptive" ad?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=30066&item=3819354693&rd=1


Man, there's one thing I learned in my consulting business early on...you just can't save some people from themselves.

Edited by Scott Sewell on Jun 03, 2004 at 09:58 AM GMT
Jun 02, 2004 at 01:26 PM
Duncan Staples
Offline

p.3 #11some EBAY weirdness...
You can flame me all you want but DSeelig has become a black cloud to this forum and has been completely out of line in two recent posts including one thread that was deleted this morning. I have been an FM member for well over a year and there have been very few people that have pissed as many members off as much as David has in the last few days.

In my opinion David would be much more welcome over on Dpreview - they are more your style of folks... You certainly aren't making many friends here.

Duncan
Jun 02, 2004 at 01:32 PM
Spydweb
Offline

p.3 #12some EBAY weirdness...
OUCH !!!
Jun 02, 2004 at 01:45 PM
mkwhitley
Offline

p.3 #13some EBAY weirdness...
DSeelig wrote:
There is someone on sportsshoot I just told that there 120-300 f2.8 is below market he wants 1200. David to go 18o bucks over a 100 dollars lens is being a cion artist What was wrong with the ad is the omissions of what the lens is about.No mention this is a digital rebel lens . David


You should put some of the effort you put into "warning people" into the grammer of your posts. Punctuation was invented for a reason.
M


Edited by mkwhitley on Jun 02, 2004 at 05:48 PM GMT
Jun 02, 2004 at 03:36 PM
mssports
Offline

p.3 #14some EBAY weirdness...
You can say its now over. I had emailed the person last night. And showed her/him this forum to buy. I also told her people here has hearts! (Well some of us do) but here is the person response!

Thank you for relaying this message, actually someone e-mailed me the same message and I caught it on time. Next time I need to do my research, but I did get a stop payment so I will not be wasting any $!!! I will definetly let ebay know there is a fraud out there.

Rachel2478
Jun 02, 2004 at 04:20 PM
Cubfan
Offline

p.3 #15some EBAY weirdness...
Personally, I think you people ought to mind your own business. I've nosy people email my buyers that I've had cameras I've sold serviced for backfocus issues from forum threads... even though the camera came back perfect. No issues. Was enough to scare away a buyer, though.

Another time, I had another buyer go away because someone told him he paid too much for a lens and supplied a website where it could be found cheaper. My opening bid was set at about $10... how can I help what people bid?

Still another time, I had a buyer go away after someone offered to sell his unsold item cheaper outside of Ebay. The buyer wouldn't tell the name of the seller so I could report the rules violation.

Oh, sure... I could leave bad feedback or force people to buy. Bad feedback always results in retaliation feedback (in my experience, anyway), and it's sure not worth going to all the struggle of trying to force people into buying something they don't want.

Then there's all the scammers from Singapore or Hong Kong or Malaysia who contact my buyers with "deals" of their own. No thanks.

So, from now on, because of my experiences and the actions of the busy-bodies here, I'm doing private auctions for high-price items. Works great, as nobody can see my buyers' identities. You can try to interfere, but you won't be able to. So there.

Some of you folks have WAY too much time on your hands, IMO.
Jun 02, 2004 at 04:41 PM
DSeelig
Offline
[X]

p.3 #16some EBAY weirdness...
I wonder how many rank amatuers who own film rebels will know what an eos s lens is . Very few i bet. This is very new development. Be kind to those who know less then you. Some people have very lttle money for these things. David
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:36 PM
Cubfan
Offline

p.3 #17some EBAY weirdness...
The email back from the uneducated buyer said the ad was fraudulent. Several here have made that claim. The truth is that it's not even close.

The only thing the seller was guilty of was probably being as dumb as the buyer, as it looked like the seller didn't even know that the lens would only work on the DRebel.

He stated what he had, made no fancy claims, posted a reasonable picture of the item, and even provided a link to pictures taken with the lens. He had a respectable opening bid set at $100, and was probably prepared to get that for the lens.

I bought Xenon headlights for my car on Ebay... the ad said they were for my make and model of car. When I got them, I found out I have to take out half the engine (practically) to put them in. Yep, there's that "fraud" again, but maybe I should have checked it out before buying?

The buyer stopped payment, she says, and claims the buyer committed fraud to cover the fact that she didn't know what she was buying. She deserves bad feedback for her trouble, and I hope she gets it.
Jun 03, 2004 at 05:57 AM
BENINMD
Offline

p.3 #18some EBAY weirdness...
Cubfan, I agree with you on the first auction. Clearly the high price was caused by the stupidity of the buyer. I hope she is hold accountable for the contract she entered willingly by mistaken or by ingorance. However, in the case of second EF-S lens auction, seller clearly saw the first auction and copied the exact title and description with the intent to mislead and misguide. He opened his auction at $250 with buy it now of $275 if I remember correctly. I will not call him fraudulent. But he is unethical and immoral to say the least.
Jun 03, 2004 at 07:36 AM
piddlep
Offline

p.3 #19some EBAY weirdness...
first let me say, im sick of people using the freedom of speech as their own personal crutch for all actions said and done. moving on...

you can not make up for other's ignorance, period. i believe if YOU are A) not the buyer or B) not the seller, you hold no bearing over the sale. that means, emails and pms and whatnot should not be sent to either party telling them that it can be had for cheaper, you're asking price is way low, and what have you. on a lesser scale, it's like purchasing an automobile. you do not see car salesmen from dealer X over at dealer Y's lot telling them the pro's of their company and the con's of dealer Y's.

marketing is a cut-throat business and us being consumers should not look at it any differently. we should not have to consider input for 3rd parties to either increase or negate my chances of a successful sale.

someone mentioned earlier that no one would EVER comment in any fashion that the seller's asking price is too low. my guess is that the first reply to such a post would be "sold, i'll take it". now, you stumble in on this and do you go "my my my, i just missed a great deal" or do you go "let me pm, email, whatever the seller and have them retract on the sale because he's not getting market value". im 100% positive it's not the latter. so the seller retracts, how do you think the was at one time buyer feels?

in short, my parents told me when i was young to "mind my own business". it's a shame a few of you didnt receive that talk. if you're not an involved party, dont make yourself one. and yes, dont take it upon yourself to initiate "the right thing". you by no means should see yourself as a savior or promoter of goodwill and rightful doings.
Jun 03, 2004 at 08:22 AM
Isca
Offline

p.3 #20some EBAY weirdness...
"Freedom of speech". Give me a break. Ebay is an auction site, we all know the shortcomings of it. But where does this freedmom of speech nonsense come from? It's a business transaction, it's not a threat to the American way of life (thinking about it, take away those business transactions and maybe the American way of life does disappear!!!).

I'm all in favour of sending a PM to a seller saying that he may be overcharging but leaving it at that. I even did it once and the seller was more than polite in his response with a very valid reason.

But for crying out loud, stay out of it. I value this forum for the ethics and professionalism of almost everybdoy here but I don't feel the need to be an evangelist to some of the people who frequent ebay.

GC
Jun 03, 2004 at 09:43 AM
FM ForumsBuy & Sell Photo-GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister