I'm sure my opinion will not be the popular one, but I get the feeling that the people who do not like any mention of competitors' prices want this to become a sellers' forum. Essentially, to be blunt, the seller posts his price, and no one should dare (or have the opportunity to) say anything about it (except to say what a good price it is). On the other hand, I'm coming at these ads from the point of view of a buyer (which I am 99% of the time). Things on this forum get put on the market and get sold in a remarkably short time. To do research as to the appropriate price often means not getting the item. And the reality is that unlike the veterans on this forum, there are a lot of us who don't know by heart the average selling price of Canon dotthingy EW-32 dash 8 or Nikon thingamajig FXXD. From this point of view, I appreciate having people post BOTH "that's a great price" AND "Canon is now offering a rebate on this". I've made a couple of purchases on the spot because of these latter comments.
In my opinion, the seller, who presumably has done research on the value of their item, should be able, in good faith, to defend their price compared to the competition, provided the competition comes from a reliable source (B&H, ADorama, etc.). I.e. "my item comes with a filter and a hood" or "I've sold 600 items on here, and my reputation as an honest seller is worth an extra 10%". It is then up to the free market (i.e. the buyers) to decide whether that is a fair deal.
A seller who does not like to be compared to the competition implies that he's got something to hide... they're hoping that people won't know that B&H is selling the same item for $20 more, and should someone tell them about that, they won't buy the item at FM. They're essentially preying on people's ignorance. On Ebay, I have no problem with that. That's an auction place and for the large part, the buyer does not set the price. But on FM, which is a community forum composed of photographers, I would hope we are above that. I would certainly hope that if someone posted that EF-S lens for $275 and as a newbie, I was interested in buying it, that someone would have the decency to inform me of my mistake. Should I then decide that the lens is worth $275 to me, for whatever reason, then I take the responsibility onto myself, and have no right to bitch in the future.
I have seen so many generous people here on FM... the freebie post, the donations to help someone who's been ripped off, that I think I've become spoiled as to what I should expect here. When I then see posts that are clearly meant to promote taking advantage of people because of their lack of knowlege of the latest prices, I guess I get a little frustrated.
In the end, it comes down to whether you see this as a buyer's, or a seller's forum. Until we get some guidance from above (Fred), I don' t think the practice of comparing prices will end. I, for one, would hate to see it go. In the meantime, instead of bickering back and forth endlessly and calling people thieves, maybe sellers can simply get used to, as part of their sales pitch, convincing people why they should buy it from them instead of elsewhere. After all, it's common enough to see in ads that "B&H is selling it for $X, but I'm selling it for $Y." I don't see many of these kinds of posts "hijacked".