fredmiranda.com Login
Trade safely
Please use protected, insured payment methods for all transactions
This topic is in the 2004 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2004some EBAY weirdness...

  
 
jtgray
Offline

p.2 #1some EBAY weirdness...
I have a toenail for sale only 50.00
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:14 PM
JFB318
Offline

p.2 #2some EBAY weirdness...
What was dishonest was the statement at the bottom proclaiming it to be "a hell of a deal"
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:37 PM
Isca
Offline

p.2 #3some EBAY weirdness...
Do a search on ebay, there are more listings for kit lenses there than there have ever been!!!!!

GC
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:43 PM
JMankos
Offline

p.2 #4some EBAY weirdness...
wow....

there's a sucker born every minute.....I guess Ebay is living proof of that. If someone bids almost $300 on something and a) doesn't realize it only works on the Digital Rebel (unless modified) and b) doesn't realize it's only worth about $100 brand spankin new.....then I guess the old saying 'a fool and his money are soon parted' applies here....
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:47 PM
Zoomer
Offline

p.2 #5some EBAY weirdness...
jtgray wrote:
I have a toenail for sale only 50.00


Is it the "L" version?!!!!
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:47 PM
Spydweb
Offline

p.2 #6some EBAY weirdness...
Let's see toenail $50 bucks, sell on E-bay $300= SCORE
Jun 01, 2004 at 09:50 PM
Scott Sewell
Offline

p.2 #7some EBAY weirdness...
Zoomer wrote:
jtgray wroteI have a toenail for sale only 50.00
Is it the "L" version?!!!!


If it's been painted white with a white line on it!!

Edited by Scott Sewell on Jun 02, 2004 at 07:52 AM GMT
Jun 01, 2004 at 10:38 PM
visch1
Offline

p.2 #8some EBAY weirdness...
Think of this. I buy estates or purchase some lenses at a yard sale and know nothing about the large number of Canon Lenses ever made. I then put them up for auction and describe them as I see them with pics etc.
Kindly explain why I’m a sleeze.
A few months ago I bid on a 70-200mm 2.8 for ALMOST the price of a new one thinking it had is. It didn’t and I paid for my mistake. Should I call the seller a sleeze for my not seeing that it was a non is? Think not!
BE WELL
Jun 01, 2004 at 11:22 PM
winstontravels
Offline

p.2 #9some EBAY weirdness...
Heck anyone like to buy mine for that?!... a nice little starter fund for the 17-40mm
Jun 01, 2004 at 11:38 PM
harveyc
Offline

p.2 #10some EBAY weirdness...
JFB318 wrote:
What was dishonest was the statement at the bottom proclaiming it to be "a hell of a deal"


The auction had a starting price of $100 (though the first bid was $214.95). This is a good lens for $100 and there isn't anything dishonest about the statement by the seller.

I'm amazed that there were three different bidders that placed bids for more than $200. There are plenty of foolish people to go around and there's no need to blame the seller for their craziness.
Jun 01, 2004 at 11:59 PM
Isca
Offline

p.2 #11some EBAY weirdness...
You can't blame the seller, he did everything he was supposed to. That's the nature of the market, what was he supposed to do? Maybe at 150 bucks he should have closed the auction and said "Look, no more bids, I'm nto going to sell it to you as it's too much"

I'll buy that toenail.

GC
Jun 02, 2004 at 07:02 AM
Sjhugoose
Offline

p.2 #12some EBAY weirdness...
Jun 02, 2004 at 07:45 AM
UFO™
Offline

p.2 #13some EBAY weirdness...
Sjhugoose wrote:
This is just as absurd, Hope no one buys it

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=30066&item=3819354693&rd=1

Scott


Unreal.....
Jun 02, 2004 at 08:34 AM
RCW99
Offline

p.2 #14some EBAY weirdness...
Did anyone notice that the wording for the two lenses is identical? Hmmm.
Jun 02, 2004 at 09:11 AM
Phil McNeil
Offline

p.2 #15some EBAY weirdness...
In my mind there is a great difference between FM and Flea-Bay. If I buy on FM I expect a fair transaction with an honest person. My base assumption is that I am going to get what I pay for. I still do my homework and make sure that I am satisfied that the person is who they claim to be.

On Flea-Bay on the other hand I go in with the assumption that the other person is a total scam artist and I will only biy if I can prove otherwise. I have bought several lenses on Flea-Bay and had good results with all. But, they have always been from people with lots of positive feedback and prior photo equipment sales/purcahses. The descriptions must include a claim about lens condition, it is crazy how high the bids go on lens described as in "good condition," does that mean scratched as heck with only a little fungus?

visch makes a good point about sales by sellers who know little. I sold some really old Olympus and Pentax MF bodies and lenses a while back. I knew very little about them, but did as honest a job as I could describing them. I ended up being really shocked how high some of the bids went, I was very happy. I don't think I had a responsibility to research the used market and warn people off biding too much.
Jun 02, 2004 at 09:25 AM
DSeelig
Offline
[X]

p.2 #16some EBAY weirdness...
I warned Rachel I was told she got out of the deal legally she had 4 ohter warnings . David
Jun 02, 2004 at 09:30 AM
gooch
Offline

p.2 #17some EBAY weirdness...
I don't know, I'm kind of torn about the whole thing. The ad doesn't appear deceptive to me.The lens is exactly what the seller says it is. It just has an outrageous price.

Sure you could get that lens for 1/3 of the final price but who's fault is that?

If someone is ..... having a yardsale let's say. At this yardsale there is a used XYZ brand vacume cleaner (EF-S lens).

The vacume isn't in production anymore so you can't buy one new from XYZ corp.
(as far as I know you cannot buy an EF-S lens from Canon by itself)

The owner is asking $100.00 and you buy it.

If you go around the corner to another yardsale and you see the same vacume in the same condition for $20.00.

Did you get ripped off?

Let's face it, people who do their legwork will find the best deal for themselves. Although I don't have a problem with sending someone an email (or PM) telling them that they are paying too much for something where do you draw the line?

I've bought 3 lenses from FM and they have all been great transactions but I knew
a) how much I was willing to pay.
b) how much I'd have to pay if I bought new (B&H, Amazon, Dell, 47th street ... whatever.)

It's just humorous sometimes when I look at the many FS posts with at least 1-2 posts telling prospective buyers that basically ..... this deal sucks .... go here and get it cheaper.

We are all adults and can negotiate if we think a price is a little steep.

No one puts a gun to anyones head and forces him/her to buy a used 10D or 1D or CF card for $10,000.00.

Like I said before, I don't have a problem with sending PM's to sellers/buyers about potential price descrepancies but lets face it ...

...yesterday a FM member was selling a 70-200 2.8 L IS, 24-70 2.8 L and a D60 with a price that was incredibly below market value. I'm sure many of you saw those threads.

How many people posted in his thread that his asking prices were too low and he should really bump them up 15%?

I didn't see any.

Patrick
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:10 AM
will_m
Offline

p.2 #18some EBAY weirdness...
Patrick
Very well put. I didn't see any body tell him to raise his price. If you do you homework and check things out then stuff like this would not happen. Somebody once said that things are only worth what somebody is willing to pay for it.

Will
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:31 AM
DSeelig
Offline
[X]

p.2 #19some EBAY weirdness...
There is someone on sportsshoot I just told that there 120-300 f2.8 is below market he wants 1200. David to go 18o bucks over a 100 dollars lens is being a cion artist What was wrong with the ad is the omissions of what the lens is about.No mention this is a digital rebel lens . David
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:36 AM
Scott Sewell
Offline

p.2 #20some EBAY weirdness...
This thread is getting very interesting...and telling. Patrick, I agree with about 99% of waht you said in your post except the part about PMing or emailing people to tell them they paid too much.

I'm curious who makes who the buy/sell police? Or, to carry your yard sale example a bit further, what would give someone the right to hang around the neighborhood and make sure everyone is buying/selling at the "right" price?

DSeelig, I'd be interested to know when or where you "deputized" to inform buyers/sellers they're off base? And what information did you get at photo deputy school to base your judgements? Hey, I don't know you other than on this forum, so I hope you don't take this personally...I'm just trying to make my point and help understand this who thing. But the "telling" part of this and a couple of other threads is that you appear to be getting involved in several buy/sell transactions on this forum, ebay and on sportsshooter.com. In fact, I email the seller of the Sigma lens on SS and haven't heard back...maybe he's going to jack up the price another $300-$400 since you enlightened him? Or maybe he actually wanted to sell the item at the $1,200 he originally listed. I haven't heard from him yet, so I don't know. Either way, is there something or somewhere where one can have this kind of authority? Or is it self-made?

I agree that Rachel paid too much for the 18-55mm lens, but wasn't it her responsibility to do her homework (like Patrick mentioned)? Just like it's the responsbility of the Sigma lens on SS to do his homework. Maybe he WANTS to sell the lens for $1,200...maybe he doesn't know any better. Again, I think it's his responsibility to know what to do. I know one thing, if I were the seller of the lens on eBay, I'd be a little ticked (to put it mildly) if I found out someone got involved in a transaction they have no business being involved in and the buyer backed out because of it.

I like Patrick's analogy of the yard sale, but something about this whole issue is reminding me of church/religion and people who live by example and others who feel like they have to tell people what they should/shouldn't be doing.

I'm out... (now I feel like I'm posting on Jim Rome's web site! Ha! ).



Edited by Scott Sewell on Jun 02, 2004 at 11:01 AM GMT
Jun 02, 2004 at 10:56 AM
FM ForumsBuy & Sell Photo-GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister