asiostygius Offline Upload & Sell: Off
|
Leighton, I repost to you the only direct comparison at f/2 (not scientific, casual one - hand held) between the 85/1.4 and "Nikki's daughter" (85/1.8 K ai'd, supposedly the same optics of the H).

Bokeh at f/2 - Guess which is the lens (85mm/1.4 ais or 85mm/1.8K aid)? by labecoaves, on Flickr
Bokeh at f/2 of Nikkor 85mm f/1.4 ais
D7000 at ISO 100, hand held.

Bokeh at f/2 - Guess which is the lens (85mm/1.4 ais or 85mm/1.8K aid)? by labecoaves, on Flickr
Bokeh at f/2 of Nikkor 85mm f/1.8 K ai'd
D7000 at ISO 100, hand held.
Perhaps the 1.4 has a little bit smoother bokeh, but for me both lenses are sharp and the 1.8 size and handling is a joy to use.
And a bokeh playing with the 85/1.8 K only:

Nikkor 85mm f/1,8 K ai'd bokeh study by labecoaves, on Flickr
Just playing bokeh of this old Nikkor at the MFD (85 cm).
f/1.8 is good for dreamy effects, best bokeh; at f/5.6 there is a compromise between flower detail and a reasonable bokeh; f/11 has maximum flower detail, but the bokeh is distracting. D7000 + tripod, ISO 200.
|