This is Camden Hills State Park in Maine. We weren't expecting any clouds that evening, so we were very happy to see these. I took this shot as the sun touched the horizon. I wanted to capture the light shining through the leaves, the soft color in the sky, and the flare from the sun.
I used a 3 stop GND filter to reduce the dynamic range as much as possible - but it was necessary to use bracketed exposures as well. I knew I would need to combine at least two shots in Photoshop. I also shot with a very small aperture in order to produce the flare you see here.
All comments and critiques are welcome! Thanks very much for looking!
To me, this comp isn't up to your usual standards, Varina. It lacks the vibrant composition I usually associate with your work and I don't find any of the content to be particularly interesting. Your pine tree at Bryce Canyon covered in snow is my favorite of any photo I've ever seen on Fred Miranda, so I am a big fan of yours.
I have to agree. This is a beautiful photograph, but you set a pretty high standard. To me it lacks a strong point of interest. With that said, the technical details regarding the exposure and such are fantastic.
The photo it self is very vibrant and beautiful. love the way the colorful foliage in the foreground stands apart from the rock formation behind, the red/pink hues on the clouds stand out from the sky and ofcourse the sunrays adds to the composition. I feel a photo should be judged by the way it looks and conveys to the person looking at it, not from what a photographer has achived in the past. just my opinion
Ashish Aleti wrote:
I feel a photo should be judged by the way it looks and conveys to the person looking at it, not from what a photographer has achived in the past. just my opinion
Well said!!
I couldnt agree with you more. Landscape photography relies on number of elements coming together at the right time and at the right place. Each situation is unique and sometimes you get the shot and sometimes you take what you get.
Beautiful shot, Varina! I am not familiar with your others, but after seeing this I am going to have to take a peek to see what I've been missing. Splendid mood on this - it projects that tipping point of the day when you know there's no getting it back. I love this! Don
This is both a well thought out image and equally engaging. I how you captured the flare of the sun with the smaller aperture and how it compliments the comp. Superb work as usual.
Sweet! This is a very good work of art, the elements you captured are very appealing to the eye. And yes, I agree each work is individual, and just because it isn't the same as some past work doesn't mean that it isn't still a great work of art, it's just different.
I think my comment was misunderstood. I wasn't comparing this picture to Varina's pine tree picture. I hold Varina's work in very high regard. I think it is some of the very best I see on this board and I have looked at thousands and thousands of photographs here.
Lovely scene, great combination of all sorts of delicious light and fall colors. I'm always satisfied with myself if I've captured a certain place at a certain time of year the best it can look, and you've done a fine job of that. Some places are inherently more dramatic than others, but that doesn't mean the others aren't beautiful
I like this shot! It’s different in a good way. I’d love to have it my portfolio.
I wonder if a 4x5 crop would bring the scene to the fore more. I don’t know, maybe trim a bit from the sky as well as the foreground to avoid having the horizon in the center.
I think the photo is beautiful, both the execution as well as the idea. I have no doubt it wasn't easy to make.
As for whether it's up to your usual standard or not - I don't know. I like the photo and all I can say is that it's above most of what's being posted here. If people have the history with you and can make such comments, I think it's appropriate because you can only get better by being compared to yourself and those who are better. And then indeed it can get tough, because you are at the top
Thanks so much to all of you for taking the time to comment. This is an interesting discussion. I compare my own images all the time - each must meet my own requirements for an acceptable finished product... but at the same time, each must stand on it's own. If I create an image that sticks in the mind of the viewer long enough for them to remember it almost a year later (I took that Bryce photograph last November), that's an accomplishment in itself. To me, that is the highest compliment.
Of course, I would never expect someone to like every single on of my photographs. If this one doesn't appeal to everyone, that's quite all right. I love the light in this shot - the color in the foreground leaves, and the flare in the sun. Is the composition "up to my usual standards"? Well - I don't know. That's why I post my photos here - for critiques. So thanks - once again - to all of you for giving me your honest opinion.
When I looked at this again on my other "better" computer monitor at home (as compared to this work monitor) I thought it was great! It seems to sparkle with many little colors.
