bshamilton Offline Image Upload: On
|
p.2 #8 · Cypress, boardwalk & Hugh | |
MarcR wrote:
They're pretty small, aren't they? #2 rocks, what with the view so nicely
framed. Great contrast between the straight lines made by man and the ragged
textures of nature.
The dwarf cypress is a small, and quite cute I might add, variety of tree that is often seen to be giants! Thanks for dropping by, Marc!
Barry
Chris Tylko wrote:
Hi Barry,
Ok, well I'm going to disagree with everyone. Yes the exposures, light, contrast, color and sharpness are very good, and yes there is a very nice mood, but I'm afraid I don't like the compositions.
For No. 1 I would have preferred a pan of about 5 degrees to the right to include more of the boardwalk as I feel its crop is awkward.
For No. 2 the trees are too centered, now (assuming it was possible) I would have walked more the left to try to get a little more open space in the center, keeping the platform where it is but getting the trees more to the right. I find there's a conflict between the platform and the trees...maybe it would have been a better shot without one or the other.
No. 4 simply doesn't do anything for me. The tree line on the left is distracting and the lines of the boardwalk aren't as interesting as in no's 1 and 2.
Please do post more if you have some.
Hi Chris. I really appreciate your thoughts on composition, and also the mood and technical aspects.
In #1 I agree with you about the boardwalk....Tried to get it and the larger pink cloud in the opposite corner and didn't have my wider lens, and wasn't set up for a pano.
In #2, I kinda agree, too. The little extension of walkway offered limited choices for my position to get them all in, which I wanted, and I didn't want to cut off any of the righthand tree.
On #4, OK! Just showing a different perspective. I realize these all won't be for everybody
Thanks for your comments, really. I do take 'em to heart, and will just have to return to Apalatchicola and try again
Barry
|