PESCADOMAN Offline Image Upload: Off
|
p.1 #7 · Inkjet cost per print rundowns? | |
mmurph wrote:
I just bought an Epson 7880. I have been looking around at 3rd party inks for my 7600.
First, download a copy of the ICC profile for each ink on a standard paper, like Epson Premium Luster. There are tools online that will let you compare two profiles.
Compare the profile for the 3rd party ink to the same profile for the Epson 7880, 7800, and 7600.
I have yet to find a 3rd party, 7 or 8 color ink set for the 7600 that is more than marginabally better than the older Ultrachrome inks in the 7600. None even approach the gamut of the 7800, much less the 7880.
Then do a breakeven analysis. Figure in the cost for replacement carts, cleaning system (if required), new profiles, etc. For one manufacturer the breakeven was 4.5 sets of 220ML carts - 32+ carts. More ink than I will use in the 7600 in 1.5 years, so 1.5 years just to breakeven. For poorer gamut, unknown and totally unproven longevity, no standard profiles when trying new papers, no AStkinson profiles, etc.
Don't accept the manufacturers claims of $$ savings over Epson. For the 220 carts, for example, they use the list price of $112. I can buy Epson ink for $82 per cart, shipped (www.mpex.com) Pantone ink costs $76 for a 220ml cart, so does Cave Paint! (Cheaper in bulk though. Still, compare the per liter cost.)
I am either going to upgrade my 7600 to the K3 Vivid inks, or install cheap dye inks and use it purely as a proofing system. But I have not found a 7 color pigment ink set that is worth bothering with just to save $200 or $300.
The 12 ink systems may be another story. I'd like to hear how you fare with the Symphony inks! Good luck.
best,
Michael
You don't have to take my word for it. Call Scott and he will be more than happy to send you some print samples to compare.
I didn't think any of the inks were backward compatible.... I know the x880's won't work in earlier printers...
Your math seems pretty accurate, but I've already gone through quite a bit of ink just printing a few 16x24's and 24x36's.
The inkjetcolorsystems set includes patches for custom profiles, which they will do at no charge and it comes with Epson profiles.
Unless you speak to a company and get a few facts straight, it would seem inappropriate to make blanket statements such as: ink won't last, colors are weak...ect.
In 75-100 years, maybe we will see that Epson was lying about their archival ability..... . How difficult would it be to test that anyway? I would bet it is eiter a simple chemical test or some special light.
Anyway, I am not pimping this or any bulk system. I was just trying to provide the poster with some help.
|