fredmiranda.com
Login

Moderated by: Fred Miranda
FM Forum Rules
Wedding Resource List
  

FM Forums | Wedding Photographer | Join Upload & Sell

1       2       3              8              10       11       12       end
  

Archive 2011 · Giving Discounts

  
 
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #1 · Giving Discounts


monoatomic72 wrote:
In my current situation, it would be a BIG stretch, but I could probably pull it off. That figure was for when I first started. I had a smaller, cheaper apartment. I didn't have the meeting space with clients. I didn't have some other bills that I do now. I also didn't run the business as well as I should and probably dumped a bunch of unnecessary money trying to chase other photographers.

With that said, my personal lifestyle didn't change much. I still do the same things I do now for enjoyment. I still took vacations, saved money, had
...Show more

Ok, sorry. I thought we were talking about your current situation. So, how many $2K weddings would you need to make a living? I'm guessing more than 17 now, right?

If you could earn more per wedding, would you? If you could earn more and work less, would you?

If your current situation required you to shoot thirty $2K weddings or twenty $3K weddings, which would you choose? If your work was so freaking awesome that you had 70 brides booked at $2K each, would you do it? What would you do so you wouldn't have to shoot 70 weddings per year?



Mar 24, 2011 at 10:04 PM
emandavi
Offline
• • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #2 · Giving Discounts


David Ziser says you shouldn't even think of going full-time into this business unless you're making 50,000.00 a year as a photographer (and even then, you may want to wait until you're making more)!!!! That's why we have a lot of professional photographers who also have full-time jobs... and so they can afford to discount. I don't think they should be frowned on because they made the "better(?)" or conservative decision, and can afford to discount. If you're not making ends meet, go get another job to supplement your photography income. It's what they're doing, and they're not complaining!


Mar 24, 2011 at 10:31 PM
Jed Eltom
Offline
• • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #3 · Giving Discounts


jcolman wrote:
I know that there is a cabal of dark, mysterious people that control this industry and keep the rest of us in the dark, scratching out a meager living while they sit on their thrones, laughing at us.


Here's the secret cabal plan exposed:

Step 1: Go to model mayhem and find a great looking guy and a hot looking girl as models pay whatever they ask if needed.
Step 2: Rent a wedding dress and tux in their size.
Step 3: Rent whatever equipment you need, and get a permit to the best location in town. Shoot the models in the hottest poses you can think of.
Step 4: Make luxury albums using the photos.
Step 5: Repeat steps 1-4 a few times.
Step 5: Get the fanciest business cards and have your brand and website re-done by specialized graphic designers.
Step 6: Make sure you are at every wedding show in town with a fancy large booth.
Step 7: Have a full page ad in bridal magazines run on a regular basis.
Step 8: Befriend a journalist at any local newspaper, and get him/her (using bribe if you have to) to get them to write an article about your business. (Repeat once a year)
Step 9: Set your prices at 5K and up. Never discount. Talk the talk. Walk the walk.
Step 10: Enjoy!

No need for lamb covered albums, gifts, or expensive client dinners. It won't event
matter what your deliverables are or how you deliver them. You also have to have some
common sense regarding how you decorate your office and how you treat your clients.

It's pretty obvious, the more money you put into your image and marketing, the more
profit you will get back. Now if you do this right, what you deliver won't really matter.

I am convinced that to do what I mentioned above works, but I also believe that it takes
someone who has has the skills, courage, and money to get this going.

I personally have the skills and money, but I'm lacking the courage to do this.



Mar 24, 2011 at 10:48 PM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #4 · Giving Discounts


Jed Eltom wrote:
Here's the secret cabal plan exposed:

Step 1: Go to model mayhem and find a great looking guy and a hot looking girl as models pay whatever they ask if needed.
Step 2: Rent a wedding dress and tux in their size.
Step 3: Rent whatever equipment you need, and get a permit to the best location in town. Shoot the models in the hottest poses you can think of.
Step 4: Make luxury albums using the photos.
Step 5: Repeat steps 1-4 a few times.
Step 5: Get the fanciest business cards and have your brand and website re-done by specialized graphic designers.
Step 6:
...Show more

There's one more step you forgot - to actually have the photography skills to back it all up. Seriously, with that you've got yourself a fool proof plan.

/edit - ok you mentioned it at the end, but that's actually a crucial step that needs to be part of the list. Hahah.



Mar 24, 2011 at 11:00 PM
monoatomic72
Offline
• •
[X]
p.9 #5 · Giving Discounts


Inku Yo wrote:
Ok, sorry. I thought we were talking about your current situation. So, how many $2K weddings would you need to make a living? I'm guessing more than 17 now, right?

If you could earn more per wedding, would you? If you could earn more and work less, would you?

If your current situation required you to shoot thirty $2K weddings or twenty $3K weddings, which would you choose? If your work was so freaking awesome that you had 70 brides booked at $2K each, would you do it? What would you do so you wouldn't have to shoot 70 weddings per
...Show more

That's an interesting set of questions.
Yes it does take more than 17 2k weddings for me right now. I'd say, realistically, I'd have to do about 35 2k weddings. Maybe I could get by with 30. That would be being able to take care of my business needs and also take care of my living expenses with a little gravy on top.

Honestly, and this isn't just pandering, I love doing weddings. I'd happily do 30 2k. I'd happily do 20 3k weddings. If I could make an equal amount of profit in either scenario, adding an extra 10 shooting days to my schedule, it really wouldn't be that big of a deal for me. I'm also coming from a different working background. I'm coming from having to slave away for 60 hours a week for 60 grand a year. Taking work home with me. Having almost no free time to do anything but work, eat and sleep. That life wasn't entertaining. Working for 30 weekend days and a few days during the week. Having 3-4 months of free time to do as I please. I can't really be upset about that.

Before anyone says something about all the extra time needed for marketing and editing and meetings, yes that's factored in. Overall, you can run your business and still have time for yourself. Especially in this business where you are your own boss, you set your rules. You set your hours. If you're miserable and consumed with your business all day every day, what's really the point? If you can't enjoy your free time, enjoy the time away from the job, to me, why do it?

If I could book 70 brides at 2k a pop. I'd do it in a heartbeat. As a one man show however, I don't think I could handle that amount of work without some help. Not so much the shooting or editing schedule, but the majority of the back end work. Client meetings, paperwork, emails marketing etc. If I wanted to do that, I'd obviously have to charge more to offset the costs of having to hire an employee. It's actually what I'm working towards. I'd love to have every weekend booked from April 1st to November 1st. Just go out and shoot, come home edit and design. Pay someone else to take care of the back of the house work. That would be my ideal.

When I'm able to do that, I'd shoot for about 7-8 years and then retire into my gutted and redesigned 1960's Airstream, and enjoy roaming around the country for the remainder of my life.
If it takes 70 2k weddings to get there, so be it. If I can do it shooting 30 5k weddings, that's what I'll do. However, I won't sacrifice all of my free time chasing the elusive golden goose of 5k+ brides just so I don't have to book an extra 10 weddings a year. Ask TRR, he'll tell you the amount of work that needs to be done to book the weddings he books. I'm not at his dollar levels, but I can imagine it's terrifying knowing the pool of brides is so small to book from and even more terrifying knowing that slipping even a little bit might mean the difference between his business succeeding and failing. I envy him, but at the same time, I have no problem letting him live in the clouds of this business.



Mar 25, 2011 at 12:27 AM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #6 · Giving Discounts


monoatomic72 wrote:
That's an interesting set of questions.
Yes it does take more than 17 2k weddings for me right now. I'd say, realistically, I'd have to do about 35 2k weddings. Maybe I could get by with 30. That would be being able to take care of my business needs and also take care of my living expenses with a little gravy on top.

Honestly, and this isn't just pandering, I love doing weddings. I'd happily do 30 2k. I'd happily do 20 3k weddings. If I could make an equal amount of profit in either scenario, adding an extra 10 shooting days
...Show more

Thanks for clearing all that up. Yeah, we definitely have different lifestyles. From what you've written, I'm probably at least 15 years older than you. I have a wife, son, mortgage, and 2 cars. I most definitely am not looking to retire in an Airstream.

That being said, there's enough business out there for both of us to coexist. There are brides that will book you at $2K and there are brides that will pay more to book me.

$5K brides are not elusive. I just booked a bride today for 5700. COGS - a 10x10 album w/30 pages. Anyone that knows the cost of albums can do the math.

If I shoot 40 of these weddings, I'm in pretty good shape. If I shoot 20 weddings at 10K, even better. It gives me more time to pamper my clients.



Mar 25, 2011 at 10:13 AM
Ghost
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #7 · Giving Discounts


How much should I charge in order to maintain my current lifestyle of a having:

- Family of 4
- 1 SUV & 1 sporty car and (maybe a motorcycle)
- Annual vacation off (ok can be CONUS)
- 1 estate home in the 'burbs and 1 cottage cabin (not detroit!)
- 1-2 Weekly dinner outs
- $ for kids college, insurance & retirement nest egg equivalent to 60% of today's lifestyle cost

Ahh.... to live the American dream.



Mar 25, 2011 at 10:32 AM
campyone
Offline
• •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #8 · Giving Discounts


The theory/example sound good but they ignore the difference between incremental or direct costs and fixed or indirect costs. Most of the costs you've outlined in the example are fixed or indirect, i.e. they won't increase because you took on a discounted job. Taxes might be an exception since the job increases your profits and maybe (not necessarily) your taxes, possibly office supplies go up a smidgen because of that one more job but that's about it. Everything else on the list isn't going to change because you took on a discounted job. .

So if it's a question of sitting home watching TV or taking on a discounted job, you're much better off financially (at least in the short term) by taking the job. Discounting may be a bad business practice in the long term but not for the reason given here. Of course your basic point - that there's a lot of overhead associated with running a business - is certainly correct but anyone running a business who doesn't know that won't be in business very long.



Mar 25, 2011 at 10:48 AM
jcolman
Offline
• • • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #9 · Giving Discounts


Ghost wrote:
How much should I charge in order to maintain my current lifestyle of a having:

- Family of 4
- 1 SUV & 1 sporty car and (maybe a motorcycle)
- Annual vacation off (ok can be CONUS)
- 1 estate home in the 'burbs and 1 cottage cabin (not detroit!)
- 1-2 Weekly dinner outs
- $ for kids college, insurance & retirement nest egg equivalent to 60% of today's lifestyle cost

Ahh.... to live the American dream.


Don't know how much you should charge but you probably need to be brining in over $150k/yr depending on your age.













Oh wait.....you're in Canada. Make that $7.25/hr






Mar 25, 2011 at 10:57 AM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #10 · Giving Discounts


campyone wrote:
The theory/example sound good but they ignore the difference between incremental or direct costs and fixed or indirect costs. Most of the costs you've outlined in the example are fixed or indirect, i.e. they won't increase because you took on a discounted job. Taxes might be an exception since the job increases your profits and maybe (not necessarily) your taxes, possibly office supplies go up a smidgen because of that one more job but that's about it. Everything else on the list isn't going to change because you took on a discounted job. .

So if it's a question of sitting
...Show more

I see what you're saying. But it also depends on how many jobs one already has booked. If I had only 10 for this year at my current rates, then 1) i'm overpriced or 2) i'm not reaching my 'ideal' client or 3) my work sucks or 4) all of the above. If so, I might be inclined to discount my rates.

I don't think there's any one right answer for everyone. As mentioned, it depends on individual needs. At this point, I can afford to sit at home and watch TV or take my family on a day trip or weekend away instead of taking on a discounted job.

Shooting 1 wedding and over-delivering to you client is difficult enough. I can't imagine shooting like 80.



Mar 25, 2011 at 11:00 AM
TRReichman
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #11 · Giving Discounts


I checked in with the PPA/SMS people that I know and asked if in their experience any $2K wedding photography studios were making it. They laughed at the notion. I mean, I know that everyone here thinks they know better, but these people manage photography businesses as their core competency and have been doing so for longer than most of us have been photographers. All I can say, and I do this with as much support as I can offer, is that there is really no reason to be a $2K wedding photographer. As I tried to suggest to jcolman yesterday, simply readjusting your price list can add $1000-2500 to every wedding without shifting anything else.

I know if feels like a few more weddings are no big deal, but over time you reach a tipping point. Last year I made more money than any year previously, and I damn nearly quit after it. We just kept taking more and more weddings, thinking about the bottom line and not about the sustainable workload. More money = the worst year of my life. Each business has some number that it hums at, anything under and you get restless, anything over and you go all out of control. It usually takes a few years to figure it out. Every business coach I've talked to agrees that more volume, particularly for personal service businesses, can never be the only answer for hitting a desired income goal. At some point you have to stop selling out on yourself and charge more than you might be comfortable with to make your business support you. Being an entrepreneur is not about making comfortable decisions, its about finding comfort in difficult choices.

monoatomic72 wrote:
If it takes 70 2k weddings to get there, so be it. If I can do it shooting 30 5k weddings, that's what I'll do. However, I won't sacrifice all of my free time chasing the elusive golden goose of 5k+ brides just so I don't have to book an extra 10 weddings a year.


You either sacrifice "free time" improving the business or you sacrifice it photographing other people living their lives. Once you put in the initial work to get to a certain level that work is done - you still have to shoot the 70 weddings every year - who is losing more "free time?"

And I will keep beating this dead horse until I'm confident the point has gotten across - $5K is not a large amount. I am not balling at $5K per wedding. No Rolls in the driveway, and my grill is suspiciously bereft of gold teeth. $5K is the MINIMUM amount it takes to shoot a wedding profitably (for me). $5K should be average, not high.

Ask TRR, he'll tell you the amount of work that needs to be done to book the weddings he books.

Since you asked...

Booking the weddings that I do is probably just as easy or easier than the ones you book. No special work involved. Sorry to burst the bubble, or destroy the argument against me that I must work SO much harder to book what I do, but it just isn't true. People hear about me from someone who knows. They email, we talk, a week later they send me a check. Does this sound harder than what you are doing?

I'll go ahead and make an assumption about your clients (based on my own experience at that level of the market) - my clients are far easier to work with and less-demanding than yours.

I'm not at his dollar levels, but I can imagine it's terrifying knowing the pool of brides is so small to book from...

I see this assumption a lot, I think it is a fallacy. The pool may be smaller than some lower-dollar pools, but there are WAY fewer sharks swimming in it. I would venture to guess that there are more clients at my level than there are photographers to service them. I know there are thousands more $2-4K photographers fighting it out than there are brides who want to hire them. Think about that and tell me which is more terrifying.

Having said that, I will admit that on some survival level, in the reptilian part of my brain, every day spent as an entrepreneur is terrifying. Goes with the territory. I personally found it to be more terrifying when the checks coming in were in hundreds and overall job amounts were a couple thousand than I do now.

...and even more terrifying knowing that slipping even a little bit might mean the difference between his business succeeding and failing.

Why should anyone be afraid of slipping? This is amateur talk. A business does not fail from a "slip." A business fails after a series of mistakes and poor performance that it refuses to adapt to. No one goes out of business overnight without some catastrophic, stupid move. Any good business is tracking their performance and can tell when they go astray. If you choose to not address the problems before they take you down, you weren't really all that successful in the first place. People get to a "successful" level by tracking/managing/adjusting what they are doing constantly. Once you get to the "success" point (whatever that means) you don't stop doing all that self-analysis - it becomes second nature. So all I can say to those of you worrying about reaching a peak and falling from it is that reaching the peak teaches you how to balance there. For the record I don't feel that I've reached a level of success or a "peak" personally, I'm still working towards that.

I envy him, but at the same time, I have no problem letting him live in the clouds of this business.

Once again, cue broken record. I am not in the clouds in this industry. I am in what ought to be the middle. If I am in the clouds, then this is a very sad industry to be in. It only looks like the clouds from below, where people are settling for so much less than they are worth/than they deserve. I am only in the clouds (relatively) by virtue of the fact that so many photographers are selling themselves short. If I were in the clouds I should have far more money, live far more comfortably, and be far more famous and in demand. I'm a small time player. I have said it before - everyone on this board good reach and surpass me.

Look. I like you guys. I am you guys. I just stopped envying the people making a living at this and figured out how to do it. To take it back to the core of the OP - giving discounts never seemed to be the source for becoming a success. That's because, at its core, discounting is compromising your value proposition to make a lower-price your selling point. I haven't seen this be a sustainable path to success yet. The path is pretty clear - managerial accounting, branding, and a solid work/workflow/client management approach. I know that everyone keeps wanting to focus on the work/workflow/relationship aspect, but the managerial accounting and the branding work are what separates the real players from the weekend warriors.

I'd love to see the photography community stop saying, "yeah, it worked for the other guy but I won't try it" and just believe that it could be the same story for them.

- trr



Edited on Mar 25, 2011 at 11:43 AM · View previous versions



Mar 25, 2011 at 11:25 AM
monoatomic72
Offline
• •
[X]
p.9 #12 · Giving Discounts


Inku Yo wrote:
[Thanks for clearing all that up. Yeah, we definitely have different lifestyles. From what you've written, I'm probably at least 15 years older than you. I have a wife, son, mortgage, and 2 cars. I most definitely am not looking to retire in an Airstream.

That being said, there's enough business out there for both of us to coexist. There are brides that will book you at $2K and there are brides that will pay more to book me.

$5K brides are not elusive. I just booked a bride today for 5700. COGS - a 10x10 album w/30 pages. Anyone
...Show more

I agree we probably are at complete opposite ends of how we both live on a daily basis. Having a family, a house, 2 cars, those things just aren't on my radar so I just can't factor them into my life at the moment. I know one day I probably will, but in the present, it just doesn't come into play for me.

I'll also agree that there are enough clients for both of us to exist quite happily. I was looking through some census data and some public records from the state. In 2008 there were over 19,000 marriage licenses given out in my state. There were over 126,000 given out in New York. If I book even a .25% of those available brides in my state, I can run a successful business for myself. If I pool from a few other states as well, there's really no excuse.

Question for you if you don't mind answering. What did you have to change about your business strategy to get from a booking lower range brides into the range you do now? Nothing specific, but in general. Do you think if you dropped your prices down by say 1k, would your bookings dramatically rise? Being that you now are booking in that upper tier, if your bookings started to dry up and you needed money to make ends meet, what would you do?

By the way if anyone wants those figures it's off census data you can find here. It's the last PDF file if you scroll all the way down. Census data is REALLY good if you are into statistics. A lot of available economical and other information right at your finger tips.

http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/births_deaths_marriages_divorces.html




Mar 25, 2011 at 11:35 AM
Scott Mosher
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #13 · Giving Discounts


jcolman wrote:
Oh wait.....you're in Canada. Make that $7.25/hr



I thought Canadians were not allowed to live the American dream. What has Canada brought us besides snow, hockey, Celine Dion, and canadian bacon?



Mar 25, 2011 at 11:46 AM
Ghost
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #14 · Giving Discounts


I guess no one picked up on the satire of my post considering the over-extention of Americans that have now led to the economic meltdown and financial debts....

Oh Canadians live within their means. That's why we don't have the same economic problems like the 'muhricans.
In fact many Canucks have been visiting US to help bail you guys out.




Mar 25, 2011 at 12:19 PM
monoatomic72
Offline
• •
[X]
p.9 #15 · Giving Discounts


First off just to throw it out there, I don't charge 2k a wedding. Don't let that cloud the issue. I was simply advocating that it's possible to do so and still be a successfully run business. Nix that from your memory banks.

Now to reply to Todd,

I want to write a lot about some of the things you said, but any way I present it, it's going to turn into me putting a lot of time into debating the merits of my position and countering your position. I enjoy a good debate, especially about the things I think I'm right about , I just don't have an adequate amount of time to do so. Maybe one day we will meet up at a conference or something and we can discuss it in person.

What I can say, I don't think attaching a dollar amount to weddings make you famous or rich or anything of the sort. I don't expect anyone to be a millionaire in this business unless you have a multi-faceted studio with a lot of shooters and a lot of work. I do think you can make a living for yourself, even if it is a 50-60k profit based a year living, in this industry. I don't believe you have to be charging 5k+ a wedding to achieve that. Would you have to book a smaller amount of weddings, of course, bump up your starting rate and change nothing else about your business and your profits will be bumped up as well. Is that the only route you can take? To simplify it, no.

I haven't had demanding clients or mean spirited clients. It may just be my demeanor, how I interact with people. Who knows. I read some of the horror stories on here and I just haven't experienced that. I've had people ask me for discounts, ask me why things cost what they do, but I'd never classify any of my clients as any less than cordial.

When I said slipping, I didn't mean it as one day you make one mistake and your business falls down the tubes. I actually meant what you later said about slowing down, letting your branding become stagnant, not challenging yourself in business, not growing your business. All of that takes constant work. A lot of people aren't at the level of business knowledge to be able to put that much constant work into it or even to know what kind of constant work they should be doing. I'd venture to guess that a good ruling majority of photographers are REALLY not good businessmen.

I think you are in the upper echelon of the business as it currently stands. You can wish as much as you like that the level you are on SHOULD be the middle ground, but it's not. Are there people higher than you? Of course. Are there a lot more people lower than you. Most definitely. Although you may not be rich by your standards, I'd venture to guess you run circles, business and profit wise, by more than 80% of the studios in operation right now. Maybe even a higher percentage.
Is that to say we shouldn't strive to be at the level you are at. No, I think people should strive to always be pushing their business to the limits. Does that mean we should all start pushing our way up the ladder as a starting price to get there? I guess that's part of the issue.

Let me ask you this. If you had to choose one of the two options, which would it be?
1. All of the lower end price point photographers raised their rates in unison to your level, but continued to run their businesses as they do now.
2. All of the lower end price point photographers kept their rates as they are now, but instead learned how to run their businesses at the efficiency and profit percentages you run presently.



Mar 25, 2011 at 12:47 PM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #16 · Giving Discounts


monoatomic72 wrote:
Question for you if you don't mind answering. What did you have to change about your business strategy to get from a booking lower range brides into the range you do now? Nothing specific, but in general. Do you think if you dropped your prices down by say 1k, would your bookings dramatically rise? Being that you now are booking in that upper tier, if your bookings started to dry up and you needed money to make ends meet, what would you do?


Before I answer your questions, I have a couple questions for you. You say that it's possible to run a profitable wedding photography business at $2K a pop, but you're not charging that (anymore?). What made you start charging more money? Why are you not booking 70 weddings at $2K each?

What did I change to start charging more? A couple things.

1. I upped my game. I invested in a couple of workshops that took me to another level. My photography now compared to when I was charging $1800 for shoot/burns is just plain out of this world. I'm not saying I'm great. I think I'm an ok photographer, but I want to be the best and I will continue to invest in my art.

2. I raised my rates. Not arbitrarily. Anyone can buy a DSLR and charge $5K per wedding. Will they get it? Maybe 1 or 2, but not enough to sustain a profitable business. I raised my rates slowly. People kept booking. As my body of work improved, I raised my rates more, and people still kept booking.

People (TRR) might disagree with me, but you can't consistently charge "big" money if you don't have the skills to support it. I see a lot of advice being given out - "raise your rates" without knowing anything about the other person's situation.

When would I say to raise your rates? When everyone you meet is booking you and you're so busy, you need to slow down the booking rate. If you're struggling to get bookings from the "ideal" client, then I would take a look at other things - meaning your presentation, your portfolio.

Again, TRR might disagree with me, but you can't decide to charge more money, wait, and expect people to book you at the higher rate if your work and your brand and your client experience doesn't support it.

Toyota can't raise the prices of their cars and expect people to consider them a "luxury" brand - unless they actually make a luxury brand and provide the product, service, and experience that goes along with it.




Mar 25, 2011 at 02:28 PM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #17 · Giving Discounts


monoatomic72 wrote:
First off just to throw it out there, I don't charge 2k a wedding. Don't let that cloud the issue. I was simply advocating that it's possible to do so and still be a successfully run business.


If it's possible, why aren't you doing it?

monoatomic72 wrote:
Let me ask you this. If you had to choose one of the two options, which would it be?
1. All of the lower end price point photographers raised their rates in unison to your level, but continued to run their businesses as they do now.
2. All of the lower end price point photographers kept their rates as they are now, but instead learned how to run their businesses at the efficiency and profit percentages you run presently.


1. they'd all go out of business because they don't have the service/product to support that price point.

2. they'd be so damn busy, they'd either raise their rates to curb the bookings or they'd go out of business because they can't keep up with the demand... things will slip here and there, fall through the cracks, negative word of mouth. They'd also be burnt out from shooting so many weddings.



Mar 25, 2011 at 02:32 PM
hextor
Offline
• • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #18 · Giving Discounts


Sorry but there are some flaws in the analysis.

The point that your income has to cover for all costs, variable and fixed is right. But to inferr from that that discounting is bad fails to account for basic topics, which is that of demand elasticity, available capacity and cost of opportunity.

for example, lets say you have a 1000 USD per unit business. Out of this, 800 USD are fixed costs and 100 USD variable, 100 USD profit.

Basically if you lower the price by 50 USD you would think you need to do 2 units to get back to where you were.

but reality would be that if you do the 2 gigs...

gig 1+gig 2= 950*2-100*2-800= 700!

so all of a sudden you have 700 profit vs. the 200 (or 100 if you even didnt get the previous contract) you had before.

That is 7 times more!

If your costs are really fixed, having a greater volume DOES increase profitability significantly. This is why the SW or Music industry is so keen to get into the millions of units sold.

That holds true of course, until you have a limiting factor. Say for example you can only shoot 8 gigs a month. Then if you are already at that limit, discounting doesnt make sense. But if you can shoot one more, it would...as long as you dont hurt of course the pricing of future gigs.

Fixed costs are fixed, and therefore you have to make your calculation on the variable contribution margin. In other words, how many gigs do I have to make in order to cover my fixed costs and make up the earnings you wish for your living standard.



Mar 25, 2011 at 02:53 PM
monoatomic72
Offline
• •
[X]
p.9 #19 · Giving Discounts


I'm not booking 70 weddings at 2k a pop simply because for one person, that would be just too much work. I'd have to spend money in some area to offload the work and that would make a 2k starting point unprofitable. Could it be done? I suppose it's possible to do it with one person, but something about your business is probably going to suffer. Maybe it's on your end, being too busy, being burnt out, losing your free time. Maybe it's on the client end. You start producing bad work, the quality of time per client diminishes. I've never booked even close to 70 so I just wouldn't know how I'd be able to handle it. 70 2k weddings however would be 140k gross and a lot of that would be profit, especially if you ran a tight ship, business wise. Something like 40 2k weddings, which to me seems like it is on the high end of bookings, but still manageable, would net someone in the 40-50k range, which to a lot of people is an acceptable living wage.

What made me start charging more was two fold. First, it was a lot of people on here originally just harping over and over about raising prices, raising prices. It's a bad reason though and I'm pretty lucky I had the business side of things in order or it could have been pretty disastrous.
What caused me to continue to raise after that was a combination of things. First and foremost, I started to offer a few different products that I hadn't before. By doing so, it raised in my mind the value of what I was offering and therefore I raised my prices to fall in line with that.
Secondly, I wanted to make a bigger profit off of what I was doing. This doesn't mean I jumped 3k overnight in my price list, but it does mean I was searching through my business to find ways to squeeze out more profit and I couldn't find much else I could work on without raising my prices.
Finally, it gave me a starting point to work towards my main goal, which is to be running a full blown studio, not just a one man wedding business. I'm looking at expansion. I'm looking at hiring another couple photographers, having a retail location/built in studio, expanding the business base into more than just weddings. I can't work towards these things if I don't make above the money I need to live off of.
If I run a very lean business and make a livable profit for myself and that was all I was looking for, I could have easily stayed at the level I was at. I don't want that though. I want to go on a bigger scale, but to get there by myself first, there's really only one thing to do and that's charge more.



Mar 25, 2011 at 03:04 PM
Inku Yo
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.9 #20 · Giving Discounts


monoatomic72 wrote:
I'm not booking 70 weddings at 2k a pop simply because for one person, that would be just too much work. I'd have to spend money in some area to offload the work and that would make a 2k starting point unprofitable. Could it be done? I suppose it's possible to do it with one person, but something about your business is probably going to suffer. Maybe it's on your end, being too busy, being burnt out, losing your free time. Maybe it's on the client end. You start producing bad work, the quality of time per client diminishes. I've
...Show more

Well, if you're looking to run a studio that bases income on volume with multiple shooters and selling products, then yes, you're on the right track. Bella, The Pros, Lamar Wedding Center... ever hear of them? There are other ones all of the state of NJ just like them.

That's not my goal. In fact, I tell people that I'm the "anti-those studios." I'm a boutique studio that provides a service. Any photographer can add any product to their offering. Once everyone starts offering what you're offering, you're no longer unique.

I offer a couple of unique products, but I try not to sell clients on those. I sell them on me and what I'm doing and my photography. I probably do a few things differently during the initial consultation and after their wedding than you do.

The personal experience is what is going to make me more desirable than you, in the end.

All, IMO, of course.

/edit - oh and by the way, you answered the question of why no one should charge $2K per wedding, even though it may be possible.



Mar 25, 2011 at 03:13 PM
1       2       3              8              10       11       12       end




FM Forums | Wedding Photographer | Join Upload & Sell

1       2       3              8              10       11       12       end
    
 

Welcome back
Log in to your account