Holy duck, Batman!
That there is no difference optically between the 100/2.8 and the 100L surprises me. I am sure I have read more than one account of something improved there. Anyway, it is of course entirely possible.
I didn't realize that the 100/2.8 Macro had such fast AF, since I never used mine that way. I recall it being sharp, but that I felt that something was missing in the shots. At the time I didn't have the knowledge or vocabulary to say what it was, but in hindsight I think it was primarily the higher micro-contrast of the ZF/ZE lenses, as well as possibly a bit more punch in the colours. It is quite possible that the lacking micro-contrast translated in my mind to a softness, but this is just conjecture. I just wasn't really thrilled with it.