mudlake wrote:
evanhanded wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
Will this awful thread NEVER die? Mea culpa. I did not notice that the thread had no comments in a whole week. I picked up on page 90 where I last viewed this travesty and wrote my comment before digging my way to the end.
However, now that I have your attention...I have a book filled with "3D" images. "Hyper Nature" by Philippe Martin. He practices extreme focus stacking. The detail is so fine and the perspective is so right-on-top-of-you close, that the viewer is left with the impression that the items displayed are more than 2D.
However, here's where I would quibble with Philippe. On some of his images, there is background blur. The way our eyes work in the real world, we don't get background blur unless we're near-sighted. The blur tells you it's a picture. I’m not sure I understand when you say we don’t get background blur unless we are nearsighted. I’m looking at my phone right now typing this and the entire background is blurred because my eyes are focused on my phone. I’m not nearsighted. It’s simply physics. Cameras can exaggerate the out of focus, but whatever our eyes are not focused on is blurred to some extent.
Marksman training 101 includes focusing on the sights and learning to accept the distant target being blurred. The physics involved of optics ... human lens (eye) or camera lens, the physics remain the physics.
The "amount" of blur transitions at a rate that is slower, nearly same or more rapid provides psychological / physiological response that suggest perspective (distances) involvement. I wouldn't universally suggest that the blur tells its a picture, but when the blur is incongruous with the perspective we are accustomed to per our human vision (I'm heavily near sighted), we can have different transition rates for corrected vs. uncorrected. Some aspects of this varying level of correction are incorporated by lens designers ... all to varying degrees. That, and is coupled to our choices in perspective and aperture.
That said, massive amounts of blur doesn't automatically convey "3D-ish" for me. It might still, readily convey close perspective, though.