There are not many black and white movies made, so cine lens producers can be expected to know something about color. Their lenses get used across many different camera platforms, so color must be not just very acceptable but versatile enough to make these transitions, and to tolerate heavy post work. There are probably people who think you will get better color from the camera maker’s own lenses in the photography world.
Color tonality – the range of hue differences, large and small – works in conjunction with brightness tonality to project a powerful influence on stopped down compositions of natural scenery, because DOF extends to largely remove focus fade (let alone bokeh) from consideration. These factors exert a stronger impact on perceived 3D than accepted metrics of quality such as ‘sharpness’, in real life as in our photographs.
It’s so sad seeing the western world’s residential and office architecture turn into a dull array of monochrome boxes, devoid of even accents of color in many cases. The same is happening with motor vehicles. So, it’s no surprise people have turned to ever sharper lenses in a futile bid to inject life into their images. And old established lens makers stoke this fire for all its worth. Not surprisingly, color perception is now much worse in contemporary human populations than their grandparents’ generations.
As with so much else, ‘use it or lose it’ seems to apply here.
Where the technician photographer craves great acutance across the entire frame, 3D advocates of true-to-life photography look closely at color handling and what might be called local contrast, the effect that provides spark to otherwise flat scenes. ‘Color’ cannot be adequately judged by swatches any more than distance can be gauged by mile markers. You just need a good variety of hues and varying levels of brightness to see what lenses can do. You need to see the shaping of image motifs as illumination rolls off them.
But you will be very lucky to see any meaningful comparisons of deep DOF images, needed to let the lens deliver what it has over an extended scene. In these compositions, the assembly of distinctly colored objects act as ‘distance markers’ that enable our vision to build a coherent picture of the scene. That’s the ideal circumstance, but it can be easily thwarted by lenses that do not sufficiently distinguish hue and enough local contrast to add the brightness dimension to the mix.
The way varying illumination of green motifs is particularly important. Greens are 70% of what we see as brightness, followed by reds at 20%. So, the real tragedy is this: ‘Red-green color blindness is the most common type of color vision deficiency, making it difficult to distinguish between colors with red and green hues’.
That being said, here are two images, shot with different focal lengths, of the same deep scene. They were shot eight years apart, so we see changes in the built structures and ground cover, but these images were taken one week apart in the monsoon season, both in near constant rain.