Nifty Fifty wrote:
OregonSun wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
OregonSun wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
OregonSun wrote
I'm guessing most of the naysayers won't have anything to say about my examples, since that would require a reassessment of their loudly proclaimed belief that lenses have a negligable effect on 3D POP. What can you say? Just take photos with any lens, open them in any image editing program, add a blur vignette to taste, and voila! Sure, 3D POP can be created/enhanced in post, but the differences in my examples are entirely due to the lenses. No blur or vignette added in post. You've been asking for an A B example for ages, now that one has been provided you could at least have the courtesy to engage with it constructively. Sure. In your example images, there's no difference in the spatial effect whatsoever, only a noticeably blurry edge area that suggests a kind of tunnel vision. It strongly resembles effect lenses like Lensbaby or similar. So you can see the lens differences in the examples, but you don't think those differences make one image look more 3D than the other?
I don't agree, but I'm not going to argue the point. Visual perception is a very subjective thing, if you don't see it, you don't see it. At first glance, it suggests something like spatial depth, but in a way that quickly becomes boring, as it's an extreme, repetitive, and immediately obvious effect that quickly loses its impact. It also only works in conjunction with appropriate image composition. In the last example (Bully), it already fails.
It's like with the Holga. It can be a lot of fun and produce great results. But in my opinion, it's better suited to a cohesive series that conveys a specific, consistent style and for which specially chosen subjects are selected. I find it rather unsuitable for general photography.
Hmm, now it seems like you are saying the examples do convey some 3D effect, but you just don't like it.
The point of my examples was only to illustrate that some lenses can produce a stronger 3D effect/pop/spatiality than others.
I agree that how the effect is used in conjunction with subject choice, composition, etc. is critical to the success of the final image. And, of course, everyone has different tastes as far as that goes.