You might wonder: why the talk about bokeh in a 3D thread? Because technically, the image is arguably all bokeh, once the viewing eye leaves the focal plane. The literature refers to a simple dichotomy in the images: in-focus and out-of-focus content.
The problem with this schema is that it is not technically correct (at all) nor can it even be universally agreed upon. Bokeh is a gradient of focus fade, the degree of blur increases steadily (more or less) from near to the best the lens can deliver – adjacent to the focal plane – to eventually reach its zenith, given the configuration that led to the image composition.
Photographers freely use the term ‘bokeh’ as if all there is perfect understanding of what is meant by it. While highly imperfect for the job, the slanting fence images above show the journey image content makes on its way out of focus, as it gradually escapes the orbit of visible content. The effect is minimized when using small aperture settings like f8, or f11, with few of us using f16 these days.
The important point to realise here is that most images consist largely of bokeh, in a technical sense at least. But we can be more descriptive and more aware by breaking down the ex-plane content: there is a transition zone that starts immediately upon departure from the focal plane.
The end of the transition zone is reached when each viewer decides the fade effect has reached the state of what is currently called ‘bokeh’ – this is the beginning of the ‘bokeh field’. We might even divide the bokeh field into two sections: entry or light bokeh, and deep bokeh. So that would give us a conceptually useful schema of three separate sections of ‘bokeh’.
The little mentioned transition zone has serious implications for image appearance. Because the range from the focal plane to the deepest bokeh is a *fixed quantum* in any given composition and hardware, if you shorten one section, you extend the adjacent section – like robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Despite what you read in some places, lenses vary considerably in their rate of fade, and this is consequential for the presentation of DOF – which brings bokeh into the discussion of 3D dimensionality as a major determinant of image depth. If you like, the transition zone trains the viewing eye to adjust from seeing sharp content to a kind of grey zone before all content becomes indisputably blurry.
In other words, the transition zone sets the stage for bokeh to fill the rest of image in longitudinal space. It also starts the process of shape recognition and the style of ‘drawing’ of content.
Each lens has its own ‘signature’ as to how and what it delivers from the image to the sensor. All lens makers are trying to develop and popularize their lenses ‘look’ as something different from the others.
At the heart of the topic is the fact that ‘bokeh’ is a construct that is alien to natural human vision. We cannot see out-of-focus content in our visual field, except as a part of the field that is ‘not being looked at’ - it now resides inside the shadowy world of peripheral vision, which is sensed as much as it is ‘seen’.
A lot of brain processing takes place in producing our vision, and this happens before we consciously know we have seen something – it is subliminal. Instantly, the brain strives to ‘make sense’ of the visual field. This is an adaptive state in which we unconsciously accept what we ‘see’ and we seem to do this uncritically. Our tolerance is very high for departures from expectations.
The issues surrounding 3D are made more urgent thanks to the very large number of fast lenses on the market, now well within reach of most consumers. We have f2 and even f1.8 zooms, and lens producers rush their superfast lenses to market ahead of their more regular lenses. Many users use their f1.2/f1.4 lenses wide open all, or most, of the time, so 3D is now far from what it was 20 years ago when most of us wanted the effect in deep images shot at mid-to-small apertures.