chiron wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
philip_pj wrote
"The use of modern photography lenses for beautiful cinematography is rare, mostly because many modern photo lenses lack a distinct and artistic character, instead prioritizing sharp images that can feel devoid of life." "The use of modern pianos for beautiful music is rare, mostly because many modern pianos lack a distinct and artistic character, instead prioritizing accurate tuning that can feel devoid of life."
"The use of modern knives for beautiful cooking is rare, mostly because many modern knives lack a distinct and artistic character, instead prioritizing sharpness that can feel devoid of life."
"The use of modern automobiles for auto racing is rare, mostly because many modern automobiles lack a distinct and artistic character, instead prioritizing comfort and performance that can feel devoid of life."
There are two (more, actually, but not relevant here) forms of gear fixation. One is the presumption that only the newest thing is good enough and the other is the presumption that the newest thing is never as good.
;-) Fred Miranda's testing and perhaps even his very successful career on this site is built around the proposition that there are meaningful differences among lenses and sensors. Some people can see the differences and others can't. Some people care about the differences and others don't. But there are differences and some of them run along the dimension of when the lenses were designed and built. I would think this would be obvious and non-controversial.
"there are meaningful differences among lenses and sensors" - agreed!
However, I don't believe that these differences meaningfully impact one's photography in the sense that buying a new lens is a way to improved one's photography and get "better" pictures. One exception is action (including BIF) photography when faster lenses and sensors do make a difference.
My feeling is that the whole obsession with lenses may actually do some harm as it drives the idea that one need some exotic lenses to do better photography.
Investing time in learning and mastering the composition and post-processing skills is way more productive and useful for photography than buying a collection of lenses because of their alleged rendering.