In a fast lens environment, bokeh is going to be a huge part of dimensionality. We already know these established lens makers do not design for bokeh as part of lens development:
‘Our predominant purpose in designing fast lenses is to give photographers the ability to achieve distinctive compositional effects with the aid of a shallow depth of field.’
‘..there is no need to stop down in order to increase the imaging quality: our lenses are essentially designed to offer maximum performance at fully open aperture.’
‘..the bokeh is not an inherent aspect of the optical correction procedure, but rather a welcome by-product of our design approach.’
‘The ZEISS Otus ML series is characterized by an extraordinary shallow depth of field that directs the viewer's gaze precisely to what matters.’
It seems clear the industry leaders not only want you to use the wide open aperture setting, they are using their lenses' bokeh fields as a means to redirect your gaze back to the focal plane data that, for near focus portraits, is measured in centimetres (or millimetres). That is the essence of their 3D model. It also plays into ever-faster, ever more accurate eye focus algorithms, for mirrorless OEM lenses. It's a win-win-lose scenario for lenses, cameras and us consumers.
Bokeh - A Literature Review
In our literature review, these bokeh descriptions with (often profound) design implications include:
‘point sources of light in backgrounds should be rendered as soft, round circles’
‘bokeh helps to isolate the subject by blurring the background, making it stand out more prominently’
‘this separation creates a sense of depth and dimensionality in the image’
‘it should not draw attention away from the intended focus’
‘blurring the background of your photos is a stylistic effect than can produce professional looking images, making the emphasis of your photo strikingly clear’
‘as a photographer and an artist, you want to have a message’
‘it lets us dissolve clutter, draws attention to the important parts of the image and transforms unnecessary details into delightfully creamy colours and tones’
‘bokeh has long been one of the most potent visual tricks in the photographer’s arsenal’
‘to capture attractive bokeh, you need a fast lens’
‘seven (aperture) blades is great for attractive bokeh, but nine is even better’
‘you’ll typically want to give all the visual attention to the subject you’re photographing. Creating a blurry, defocused backdrop is the perfect way of isolating them in the scene, by removing any distracting background clutter and replacing it with beautiful bokeh’
‘a picture look is created that appears almost three-dimensional – the characteristic ZEISS 3D Pop’
‘bokeh makes photographs visually appealing, forcing us to focus our attention on a particular area of the image’
‘the circles are round and soft with beautiful transitions between the blurry areas. That’s exactly what you call good bokeh’
‘characterized by an extraordinary shallow depth of field that directs the viewer’s gaze precisely to what matters. At the same time, the wonderfully harmonious bokeh – shaped by ten aperture blades – creates smooth transitions, elegantly showcasing the story’s subjects’
Analysis
These fifteen quotes all originated from major industry sources, either lens producers or photographic journals. They were chosen at random, as encountered in the research phase. Much of it is tendentious and might be best seen as attempting a forced consensus on photographic consumers.
They all describe the current idealised presentation of bokeh in an extraordinary consistency of opinion – a universal industry agenda. None attempt to provide insight of any kind on the finer points of the shapes or abstraction levels located in any part of the bokeh field - the trasnsition zone, the entry into the blur field and what we might call 'deep bokeh'.
Little wonder, therefore, that photographers have fallen in line with this manufactured schema and bought into this form of fast lens mentality with vigorous enthusiasm, and open wallets. Not that they have much in the way of alternatives they could turn to, until very recently.
They have had no access to any knowledge of discussion of the obvious options available to them. With each passing year, fewer of them can remember the elegance of vintage lenses, many of which provided greater image depth back in the film era. The state of photography - 2025 edition.