ruthenium wrote:
The bottom line, we shouldn't be responding to original question "which lens has the most 3D POP?" The right question might be, for example "what are the photographic techniques that help create the illusion of three-dimentionality in an image?"
You could ask that, but that would completely miss the original intention of the OP. In my opinion, the question should be rephrased to ask about the lens that best supports the 3D effect. But that formulation would also result in exactly the same endless and fruitless discussion, simply because you are asking about something that is not clearly defined or whose definition cannot be agreed upon. One person understands 3D pop as this, another as that. One person sees it in a certain image, another doesn't. How are you supposed to come to a common denominator? That is IMPOSSIBLE. Therefore, this thread is 100% a pastime or a waste of time, depending on your personal point of view. It will definitely never reach a conclusion, not even in 100 years.