Robin Smith wrote:
It would indeed be a brave person to say that the lens makes no contribution to “pop.”
In fact, the “no contribution” point is a straw man argument. I don’t think that anyone is saying that all lenses perform identically.
What we are saying, consistently and repeatedly, is that the production of a sense of depth in two-dimensional visual media comes from other things that are well-understood and obvious, that there is no particular lens that produces so-called “3D POP,” and that throw who wish to produce the effect (or range of effects) should focus on understand the visual elements that create the effect, not on buying some particular lens.
The point, as demonstrated I think by the 70 pages of this discussion, is that there is no satisfactory, commonly held view, of which lenses show unequivocally lots of pop. Nor even whether shots that are meant to demonstrate actual pop actually show it. I’m not sure where it gets us.
Indeed.
- - -
tsdevine wrote:
There is no one ingredient that makes a great stew, but each ingredient can be important in a recipe for a great stew. That's what I think.....not that it matters.
To expand on your stew analogy, to many of us this notion that some mystical perfect lens is the thing that makes the “3D POP” effect is sort of like imagining that the World’s Best Stew is the result of using the Best STew brand of salt, while ignoring the contribution of all of the other ingredients and the chef’s skill in assembling and preparing them. (It also seems to ignore the reality that there is no one best stew, but I digress… ;-) )