Jonas B wrote:
But, to me there is depth in the image and I posted it supporting my belief that you can follow the guidelines posted earlier in this thread and make an image with some depth in it. Now you say the image is, in short, a typical example of no sense of depth. That's OK. I say I get a sense of depth when looking at it. Perhaps that is OK to you?
Of course that's OK with me, very OK in fact, because it illustrates how little prospect of consensus a discussion like the one we're having here has.
Jonas B wrote:
We can however agree that it basically is not about the lens, right?
Yes and no. Of course I believe that there are various ways of creating a sense of depth using image composition. The type of fall-off in sharpness is one of them for suitable subjects, and in my opinion this also depends on the lens used, which is why the lens does have an influence (otherwise I certainly wouldn't be lugging around a stovepipe like the 1.2 GM). However, this can also be overestimated, which is often done here. And as I said, there is simply a personal point of view, which is not up for debate. What is 3D pop for one person and therefore appears three-dimensional to them, for example, seems to me like it has been cut out and pasted on and devoid of any spatiality (there have been various such examples here; I will cite post #5 on page 64 as an example). What is the point of arguing about it? One person perceives this, another that.