fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.68 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
We have plenty of proof (centuries of it, actually) that dimensionality results from a range of well-known and well-understood techniques and characteristics in visual images. This is no mystery at all at this point. (OK, one remaining mystery is how our minds process visual data and respond to such effects perhaps.)

In the context of painting and related visual arts, lenses play literally zero role in creating these impressions, yet these works are full of examples of extremely effective creation on dimensionality. We can learn from them.

It is impossible to prove that “lenses do not help,” but there is absolutely no real evidence that supposed “best 3D POP” lenses make any significant difference by comparison to the other obvious factors that do make a difference.

If the contribution of a lens alone to the creation of a dimensional quality of photographs were substantial and meaningful, then any photograph made with whatever lens that is would automatically possess the quality. It is plainly obvious that this is not the case, and flat banal images come regularly from such lenses, even the best ones.

(There are other reasons to use good lenses, but “3D” is not one of them. Further, there is no one “best” lens at any of these things — instead there are many excellent lenses that will do the job well.)

In addition, it would be the obvious case that no images made with lenses falling short of this imaginary standard would ever achieve the dimensionality claimed to be the province of these magical lenses. That is also plainly nonsense, given the existence of photographs with the quality that were made with just about every lens imaginable across the almost-200-year history of photography.

It. Is. Not. The. Lens.

It is the application of techniques based on the understanding of how visual perception works.

Anyone who is really interested in creating these effects should direct their attention on understanding visual imagery, not wasting time trying to deduce which specific lens will magically produce it. It does not work that way.

Garmadon wrote:
The fact that you can draw a "dimensional" scene doesn't mean that lenses do not help .

Look at the Vermeer photo I linked , what do you see ?
I see contrast and many 'shades' or tones in her derss or his shirt .
Yes , if you can draw it you can also get it by put some time in post. but does it mean that all lenses will resolve this scene the same ?

gdanmitchell wroteI’m glad you mentioned Vermeer, though you could mention a ton of other painters and their work.

If LENSES were the primary cause of dimensionality in visual images… how is dimensionality produced in a, uh, rather widespread medium in which lenses play no role at all (aside from camera obscura, but I digress) in the creation of the images?*

The answer is painfully obvious and has been well understood for centuries. It is about how the artist uses perspective, foreground/background relationships, color, direction and quality of light, composition, haze, color intensity and tone, subject posture and position, even photograph-like “focus” effects, and more.

I’m am completely serious when I say that looking at and understanding what goes on in paintings will get you 1000x closer to understanding how to produce “depth” and “dimensionality” in photographs than buying some lens.

I know that buying the magical lens is quicker and appeals to the gear-centric nature of photography, but it is a classic example of barking up the wrong tree. I’m not claiming that lens quality is irrelevant or that it doesn’t matter what lenses you use — but I am saying, loudly, that the answer to the questions that this thread asks is not the name of a brand or model of lens.

Go look at some paintings. As yourself HOW they work? What is going on in them? What can you adopt from this in your photoraphy?

Answers are there if you just look in the right place.

* Also, if lenses produced “dimensionality,” how is it that all photographs made with those magical lenses do not have it?

Garmadon wroteHere is a good example from Vermeer :
https://images.app.goo.gl/kmdvN

There is a huge sense of depth here , but why?
It is definitely not sharp , and it is mostly in focus (except the wall ). I will guess 28mm and f/6 ?

There is a lot of information in the textures, and a great variance between lighten and dark parts... micro contrast?

What else do you see?
StoneCrop wroteYeah, I think the super blur cut out look is something that’s become popular because of graphic designers moving towards having text over the blurred out area. In that case, you don’t want definable forms competing with the text, you just want a nice palette that’s continuous with the main image. At least, that’s how I’ve used it before, and it has significant value in that usage. The percentage of people that consume photos purely as art is quite small in comparison to the number of people who consume them as advertising, so the lens design follows the money and usage trends…

It would be interesting to me to see a discussion of those qualities which give a 3d impression in photos and also in paintings. People have been chasing that objective in painting for a lot longer than in photography, and they have also been using optics since the baroque era to help in that quest.

I’m personally of the opinion that most images made with a single exposure and single lens don’t actually reproduce the way I see the world, though some images do convey a certain feeling of depth in the picture plane. Compare to painters like Vermeer or Lucian Freud’s later work. A larger format of sensor (or the use of panorama technique) can help to create an image with a wide enough field of view without introducing the distance distortion that makes things feel unnatural. Vermeer’s style encapsulates the very large format type of look, Lucian Freud’s has more of a panorama (/curved sensor) type quality.


Jun 18, 2025 at 10:50 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.68 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
To provide evidence that dimensionality is indeed very real (because many do not believe it is real), I want to list a set of comments from the lens producers themselves.

But first, you might like to see just how far the cine lens industry has departed from the regular stills lens review protocols in search of great image depth in their output. Below is from the Leitz Thalia descriptive material - it pertains to Leitz's very (very) expensive cine lens ranges. Note the common themes across their portfolio. They have 15 'performance' lenses, and 45 'character' or 'legacy' lenses.









Jun 20, 2025 at 10:15 PM
old-gregg
Offline
Details
p.68 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
@philip_pj that's just a text version of an MTF chart, where we're dealing with mundane soup of transfer values for various frequencies. Slightly less boring than lp/mm numbers but far from a mystical "3D pop".
Jun 21, 2025 at 12:08 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?

old-gregg wrote:
@philip_pj@@ that's just a text version of an MTF chart, where we're dealing with mundane soup of transfer values for various frequencies. Slightly less boring than lp/mm numbers but far from a mystical "3D pop".

Since I stopped taking the posts in this thread seriously and just read them for amusement, my blood pressure has stabilized and I can even enjoy this real-life satire.

Jun 21, 2025 at 12:52 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.68 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
I have found that the only lens worthy of the title "3D-popper king" is the cheapo Sirui 85/1.4:





It's all very satisfying as it means more traveling and less Otus thinking.
Jun 21, 2025 at 02:15 AM
StoneCrop
Offline
Details
p.68 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
For those interested in Vermeer, I highly recommend watching the film Tim’s Vermeer, in which a curious DIYer with no training in painting sets about painting a Vermeer by first building the optics that Vermeer used. It included hand grinding a large lens, because modern lenses were too perfect and he couldn’t get one that would be like what would have been available to Vermeer. But also consider that the size of his ‘sensor’ was larger than a large format camera.

The notion of human perceived depth vs pure optical qualities reminds me of how the Santa Cruz guitar company voices their guitars - they try to make a balanced perceived tone from low to high, taking into account how humans hearing is in fact not balanced but withered more heavily towards certain frequencies. So they have to make it literally, objectively unequal and unbalanced in order to appear balanced to humans. And their guitars sound GREAT!
Jun 21, 2025 at 02:29 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
If you want 3D, use a Rolleidoscope. THAT is three-dimensionality, and above all, it's real - it's analog, not bloodless digital file stuff.
Jun 21, 2025 at 02:39 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?

Jonas B wrote:
I have found that the only lens worthy of the title "3D-popper king" is the cheapo Sirui 85/1.4:
https://photos.imageevent.com/jonas_b/fmforumssirui8514/h883_varvet_01_Vilma.jpg
It's all very satisfying as it means more traveling and less Otus thinking.

For me, this image is a prime example of how sharpness versus blur alone doesn't create a sense of depth. The image seems rather flat to me.
Jun 21, 2025 at 03:30 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
What do you think about this?

DSC04450 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr
Jun 21, 2025 at 03:36 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
You can create spatiality without any Chinese wonder lenses or other pop kings, even with the much-maligned FE 1.8 50 and its complete absence of microcontrast. ;-)

DSC05968 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr
Jun 21, 2025 at 03:46 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Garmadon
Online
Details
p.68 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Yes . The green truck with the viltrox is better.

Nifty Fifty wrote:
What do you think about this?

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54603867714_dbc9db42be_b.jpgDSC04450 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr

Jun 21, 2025 at 04:47 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?


Garmadon wrote:
Yes . The green truck with the viltrox is better.


Jun 21, 2025 at 05:29 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.68 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
For me, this image is a prime example of how sharpness versus blur alone doesn't create a sense of depth. The image seems rather flat to me.


Fair enough.
Let me be clear about some basics: I don't believe in wonder lenses. I think that is clear to anyone having followed my posts (which I don't know why anyone would do but that's another topic). Calling the Sirui a 3D popper king was a joke. But, to me there is depth in the image and I posted it supporting my belief that you can follow the guidelines posted earlier in this thread and make an image with some depth in it.

Now you say the image is, in short, a typical example of no sense of depth. That's OK. I say I get a sense of depth when looking at it. Perhaps that is OK to you?
The conclusion is that we speak differently about the same sight. Maybe we are looking for different things? Maybe your world of images are verbally "flatter" than mine?

---------------------------------------------

Nifty Fifty wrote:
What do you think about this?

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54603867714_dbc9db42be_b.jpgDSC04450 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr


Yes, there is some sense of depth if looking at it big enough (that's a factor as well?). You don't have to look for the "depth" in the image, it strikes you at once. I like that.
In this case we have a green portal or entrance in focus, a layer that is out of focus but not totally blurred and then a third background layer where everything is blurred. The front greenary are on the border to look as it is pasted onto the background. Saved by context. All in all the image is taken following the mentioned guidelines.
We also have some disturbing greenary to the right and details making the focus distribution a little unnatural. Most people are probably not disturbed by that.

All this is a waste of time and interesting at the same time. We can however agree that it basically is not about the lens, right?
Jun 21, 2025 at 05:37 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.68 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
old-gregg wrote:
@philip_pj@ that's just a text version of an MTF chart, where we're dealing with mundane soup of transfer values for various frequencies. Slightly less boring than lp/mm numbers but far from a mystical "3D pop".


I think his point is that lens designers do design for different rates of transition by intent.

While Dan (et al) is totally dismissive of lens contribution, the lens designers haven't consulted him, yet.
Jun 21, 2025 at 05:52 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
But, to me there is depth in the image and I posted it supporting my belief that you can follow the guidelines posted earlier in this thread and make an image with some depth in it. Now you say the image is, in short, a typical example of no sense of depth. That's OK. I say I get a sense of depth when looking at it. Perhaps that is OK to you?

Of course that's OK with me, very OK in fact, because it illustrates how little prospect of consensus a discussion like the one we're having here has.

Jonas B wrote:
We can however agree that it basically is not about the lens, right?

Yes and no. Of course I believe that there are various ways of creating a sense of depth using image composition. The type of fall-off in sharpness is one of them for suitable subjects, and in my opinion this also depends on the lens used, which is why the lens does have an influence (otherwise I certainly wouldn't be lugging around a stovepipe like the 1.2 GM). However, this can also be overestimated, which is often done here. And as I said, there is simply a personal point of view, which is not up for debate. What is 3D pop for one person and therefore appears three-dimensional to them, for example, seems to me like it has been cut out and pasted on and devoid of any spatiality (there have been various such examples here; I will cite post #5 on page 64 as an example). What is the point of arguing about it? One person perceives this, another that.
Jun 21, 2025 at 06:08 AM
Garmadon
Online
Details
p.68 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
What do you think about this one? :
I have a strong "feeling" that the boy is in front of the girl ,like I understand the placement of each subject in the space.
DSC03193 by amit Garmadon, on Flickr
Jun 21, 2025 at 06:44 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.68 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Well, it's called perspective.
Jun 21, 2025 at 06:56 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.68 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
To provide evidence that dimensionality is indeed very real (because many do not believe it is real)…


No one said that”dimensionality is not “real.”

What we are saying is that it is not obtained by choosing special lenses. It comes from the application of a bunch of well-understood visual elements that are not even unique to photography.







- - -

Some auto-correct errors are so hilarious that I almost don’t want to fix them. I fixed this one above: “ What we are saying ishtar it is not obtained…”



Edited on Jun 21, 2025 at 10:04 AM · View previous versions
Jun 21, 2025 at 08:02 AM
hasenbein
Offline
Details
p.68 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?


Garmadon wrote:
What do you think about this one? :
I have a strong "feeling" that the boy is in front of the girl ,like I understand the placement of each subject in the space.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53667165350_d20709133f_b.jpgDSC03193 by amit Garmadon, on Flickr


Not so much, sorry.
Jun 21, 2025 at 08:05 AM
Garmadon
Online
Details
p.68 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
I don't think so. Take away the contrast , play a bit with the colors and it will have a flat look .
I can 'see' the depth in this photo . Maybe because of the side light source , the contrast ,the colors ,the angle , the lack of distracting objects in the background. I also believe the lens can help ,and of course PP .

Nifty Fifty wrote:
Well, it's called perspective.

Jun 21, 2025 at 08:08 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister