Ripolini wrote:
- by how gradually the transition between the plane in focus and planes ahead and behind said plane occurs. My Zeiss 100/2 Makro-Planar is a perfect example of how pleasant the transition is even at f/11. Few optics succeed in this.
This is the contribution from the lens. I recall the 100/2 as being a strong performer in this regard, from the "What is 3D?" thread.
Some lenses are faster / slower than others. All lenses transition ... and that rate of transition is accompanied by the rate of lighting transition (i.e. modeling). The combination of those two provide an amplified rate of change. Add in the camera : subject distance and the rate is again different. Add in the subject : background distance and the rate is again (perceived) different. Factor in the rate of change variance between zones A, B, C and again, another piece of the puzzle.
As, all the puzzle pieces of the physiological perception for depth cues change, the effect increases / decreases accordingly. I recall once when I was shooting with my old Vivitar Series 1 100-400 ... typically a lower contrast, slow transition lens, compared to top tier optics. And, yet I caught my lighting / angle in such a way that it "popped", as there was enough of the other pieces of the puzzle to offset the weak lens.
With glass such as the 100/2 (for instance), the inherent optical rate of transition is contributing more to the equation, than a different rate of transition lens. Imo, Zeiss leans the most aggressive in their lens designs for this. That doesn't mean that all their lenses do ... nor, that other mfr's don't / won't / can't ... just that Zess probably designs for this more frequently than other mfrs tend to. Some others are a bit less aggressive / more gradual. Again, the lens designer sets the pace ... and that can range from mild > more.