I believe it's a combination of things, similar to what you say. Where a lens can contribute.....and the more of those things come together the more "pop" you may perceive.
darrellc wrote:
In one of these discussions a few years ago, someone (maybe it was me) pointed to a few articles on painting techniques to simulate 3d in painting (pretty close to 2d). Painters figured out perspective and 3D a long time ago. Animators and graphics developers have surely figured it out.
I imagine composition, color, gradients, etc have most to do with it, but I bet some of the techniques map to lens attributes and might help understand what lenses might be more 3D in circumstances where those attributes are the appropriate tool to induce 3D.