Paul, you do it with different lenses actually almost with every lens, so i doubt it's the lens or your PP that creates the 3D effect, it seems like partial sharpening? You know i love your shots
prosep wrote:
Does this image have any 3D feeling?
Maybe a bit in parts, but overall no. This is a good case of the composition inhibiting 3Dness --- the top half of the photo is just a flat black block; perhaps with more light/detail there, the perspective lines would help "connect" the top to the bottom half and make the depth more apparent.
mpmendenhall wrote:
Maybe a bit in parts, but overall no. This is a good case of the composition inhibiting 3Dness --- the top half of the photo is just a flat black block; perhaps with more light/detail there, the perspective lines would help "connect" the top to the bottom half and make the depth more apparent.
Thanks for your feedback. I'll be more careful next time. It was a handheld shot and I think, I was concentrating too much on the benches while shooting as I was sure that part of the image would show some 3D.
Definitely, this thread needs more images and less hot air! Good one! Bokeh looks a little distracting but not too bad! I love the colors! Here's one from me:
also for me some pictures create the illusion of 3D for me. from my lenses it is:
rokkor 85 1.7 (probably due to the strong difference in sharpness between focus and background)
and some pictures with the ultron 40 2.0 at 2.0, also very very sharp in focus. here it is especially, that you image some 3D effect due to a consequence of the perspective:
it is just an illusion, since the fotos are clearly 2D. but once i read, that 10% of the people cannot notice 3D in the real world - ... so, how can they have that illusion.... very difficult ... could be different from person to person ...
....if i remember correctly these were also not pped..
