fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.163 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wroteBecause it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.
Your excuse is even more inadequate than your photo editing, haha.😄

As for dodging and burning, I don’t need to look up what those terms mean. Unlike you, I actually spent many years practicing these techniques, quite literally, in a darkroom.
The stuff you’re showing here really has nothing to do with that. Furthermore, I always have to chuckle when people who know nothing beyond their Lightroom sliders and who have never even set foot inside a darkroom, let alone produced a proper, hand-crafted print, try to lecture me about tools, methods, techniques, and Ansel Adams. 😂
Except once again you make assumptions without basis. I do have two analog cameras, and do shoot film. I develop the film myself rather than use a lab. I have both printed from Negatives and scanned and printed digitally. It is not however a main process for me, and I don't have years of experience nor consider myself an expert.

I am absolutely not trying to lecture you about tools etc.. I am not interested in doing that. I am just having on open conversation on our community forum.

That chip you have on your shoulder must be starting to hurt
...Show more →
Well, I still remember the drama surrounding the film development. If your prints look the same way (and I assume they do), then there’s no point in us discussing this any further. Furthermore, I believe that a somewhat more direct tone is entirely appropriate when someone shows up here with some kind of AI nonsense, deceives people with it, and then tries to dodge responsibility by making excuses.
Nov 03, 2026 at 03:24 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.163 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteHappy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.
Your excuse is even more inadequate than your photo editing, haha.😄

As for dodging and burning, I don’t need to look up what those terms mean. Unlike you, I actually spent many years practicing these techniques, quite literally, in a darkroom.
The stuff you’re showing here really has nothing to do with that. Furthermore, I always have to chuckle when people who know nothing beyond their Lightroom sliders and who have never even set foot inside a darkroom, let alone produced a proper, hand-crafted print, try to lecture me about tools, methods, techniques, and Ansel Adams. 😂
Except once again you make assumptions without basis. I do have two analog cameras, and do shoot film. I develop the film myself rather than use a lab. I have both printed from Negatives and scanned and printed digitally. It is not however a main process for me, and I don't have years of experience nor consider myself an expert.

I am absolutely not trying to lecture you about tools etc.. I am not interested in doing that. I am just having on open conversation on our community forum.

That chip you have on your shoulder must be starting to hurt a bit to inspire so much vitriol. Wipe it off a bit, you might feel better. OK that may be lecture . But a well intentioned one...
Well, I still remember the drama surrounding the film development. If your prints look the same way (and I assume they do), then there’s no point in us discussing this any further. Furthermore, I believe that a somewhat more direct tone is entirely appropriate when someone shows up here with some kind of AI nonsense, deceives people with it, and then tries to dodge responsibility by making excuses.


yeah, he used the term "dodging" and "burning" but actually used AI manipulation like it's the same thing (you can use https://openai.com/research/verify/ to upload the modified photo to confirm that it is AI-generated or was AI-manipulated)...worse was he was not upfront with using AI until called out...it was a weird flex.

i think there should be a new rule that posters should be transparent WRT use of AI in their posts and tags their images as AI generated or AI manipulated if they are such.

Edited on Nov 04, 2026 at 05:38 AM · View previous versions
Nov 03, 2026 at 06:55 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.163 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteHappy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.
Your excuse is even more inadequate than your photo editing, haha.😄

As for dodging and burning, I don’t need to look up what those terms mean. Unlike you, I actually spent many years practicing these techniques, quite literally, in a darkroom.
The stuff you’re showing here really has nothing to do with that. Furthermore, I always have to chuckle when people who know nothing beyond their Lightroom sliders and who have never even set foot inside a darkroom, let alone produced a proper, hand-crafted print, try to lecture me about tools, methods, techniques, and Ansel Adams. 😂
Except once again you make assumptions without basis. I do have two analog cameras, and do shoot film. I develop the film myself rather than use a lab. I have both printed from Negatives and scanned and printed digitally. It is not however a main process for me, and I don't have years of experience nor consider myself an expert.

I am absolutely not trying to lecture you about tools etc.. I am not interested in doing that. I am just having on open conversation on our community forum.

That chip you have on your shoulder must be starting to hurt a bit to inspire so much vitriol. Wipe it off a bit, you might feel better. OK that may be lecture . But a well intentioned one...
Well, I still remember the drama surrounding the film development. If your prints look the same way (and I assume they do), then there’s no point in us discussing this any further. Furthermore, I believe that a somewhat more direct tone is entirely appropriate when someone shows up here with some kind of AI nonsense, deceives people with it, and then tries to dodge responsibility by making excuses.



Well at least we agree that there is no point.
Nov 03, 2026 at 11:47 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.163 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
The fact that some definition of dodging points out that it is used to lighten areas of an image does not mean that every technique that lightens areas of an image is dodging.

For one thing, dodging lightens all tones in the dodged area without distinction. An arguably more sophisticated alternative that many photographs use in similar situations is to create a mask (to select that area that otherwise you might burn) and then adjust the curve int hat area. This lets you, for example, lighten the bright tones while leaving the dark tones as is… or any other variation on that theme.

I’m not aware of anyone calling that “dodging,” even though it “lightens” at area of the imge.

Also, if I read correctly, the edits on the image in question were done using some kind of AI tool. If so, the specific approach to editing the image demonstrates some of the real shortcomings of that approach.

(Note: BTW, if it seems like I’m posting at sort of odd hours… I’m currently 9 times zones away from where I usually am when I post. ;-)

1bwana1 wrote:
Daran wrote
1bwana1 wrote>> Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning
> that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?
Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.
So you said dodging and burning, but you did not show dodging and burning?
Here is the definition of Dodging and Burning. It is exactly what I did, and exactly what I showed.

You will notice that it specifically states it is used to create the appearance of depth in an image which is also exactly my intent.

You will also notice that it doesn't depend on a specific tool or method being used.

"In the digital darkroom, dodging and burning are selective editing techniques used to control the brightness of specific areas of a photograph without changing the entire image.

The terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two
...Show more →

Nov 04, 2026 at 03:14 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.163 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
The fact that some definition of dodging points out that it is used to lighten areas of an image does not mean that every technique that lightens areas of an image is dodging.

For one thing, dodging lightens all tones in the dodged area without distinction. An arguably more sophisticated alternative that many photographs use in similar situations is to create a mask (to select that area that otherwise you might burn) and then adjust the curve int hat area. This lets you, for example, lighten the bright tones while leaving the dark tones as is… or any other variation on
...Show more →
1bwana1 wrote
Daran wrote
1bwana1 wrote>> Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning
> that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?
Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.
So you said dodging and burning, but you did not show dodging and burning?
Here is the definition of Dodging and Burning. It is exactly what I did, and exactly what I showed.

You will notice that it specifically states it is used to create the appearance of depth in an image which is also exactly my intent.

You will also notice that it doesn't depend on a specific tool or method being used.

"In the digital darkroom, dodging and burning are selective editing techniques used to control the brightness of specific areas of a photograph without changing the entire image.

The terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?


Actually Luminosity masks to isolate certain tones to be dodged are explicitly included in the definition as quoted below.

"We identified several digital techniques for achieving this:
1. Brushes – selectively lighten or darken specific areas.
2. Masks – isolate areas where lightening or darkening is applied.
3. Gradients – create gradual transitions in brightness or darkness.
4. Luminosity selections / masks – target specific tonal ranges (highlights, midtones, or shadows) to control where lightening or darkening occurs.
An important distinction: Dodge and burn describes the photographic editing objective, not the particular tool used to accomplish it.

For example, using a luminosity mask to selectively brighten highlights or darken shadows is absolutely a form of dodge and burn.

In fact, luminosity masks can be particularly effective because they allow you to make tonal adjustments that follow the existing light and tonal structure of the photograph, rather than simply painting arbitrary areas lighter or darker."

AI was used to create a similar image to demonstrate on. Manual brushing, and gradients, vignette, and masks were also used. The point was and remains to show how much effect lighting has on the appearance of depth. The discussions on techniques used was not part of the original intent. That was interjected by others.

Hmm, 9 hours from your home in California. Sounds like you may be in my neighborhood. The Alps somewhere?
Nov 04, 2026 at 03:55 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.163 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
The recent comments are not about the semantics. There seems to be a divide between photographers. While some embrace AI as a tool for processing that can alter a major part of an image, others strongly detest images adulterated by AI.

While I agree that the image in question was improved by the AI processing (and it was an ugly image to begin with, to be honest), the result is like drinking vine carefully crafted from synthetic ethanol and several synthetic ingredients. The resulting product might well taste better than some average natural vine, but I wouldn't buy it.
Nov 04, 2026 at 06:43 AM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.163 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
The recent comments are not about the semantics. There seems to be a divide between photographers. While some embrace AI as a tool for processing that can alter a major part of an image, others strongly detest images adulterated by AI.

While I agree that the image in question was improved by the AI processing (and it was an ugly image to begin with, to be honest), the result is like drinking vine carefully crafted from synthetic ethanol and several synthetic ingredients. The resulting product might well taste better than some average natural vine, but I wouldn't buy it.


i personally have no issues with the use AI in images... i use AI for blemishes correction and AI masking to balance out exposure (but not make the image look like HDR)

in that post i see two problems:

1. using AI to an extent that it completely changes the image (it was altered so much a couple folks here thought it was a completely different image!) ...and try to pass it as normal darkroom post-processing and something Ansel Adams would do. the argument was just ridiculous.
2. a bigger offense to me was not disclosing that AI was used in manipulating the image until called out and i personally have zero tolerance for that.
Nov 04, 2026 at 07:02 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.163 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
You are absolutely correct to correct the misconception about Ansel on the part of this poster. I’ll forgive him — it is a pretty common mistake to imagine that Adams was all about “realism.” He was actually a master and eager user of film and darkroom post0processing techniques.

I recommend looking into the history of two pretty well known examples.

One is a photograph of a horse caught in a beam of light with Mt. Whitney in the distance. Sorry, at this moment the title escapes me. He shot it from Long Pine, CA with a closer hill in the foreground. Local high school students had placed a large and obvious “LP” on the hillside in honor of their school. Ansel included it in the capture and then burned down the area of the letters to (mostly) disappear them, though you can still make them out in many prints of the image if you look closely.

The famous “Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico” photograph is a very obvious example of the extremes he went to. If you search ab it you can find the contact print of the original negative online. It is flat and gray and not all that exciting. But Ansel had something else in mind for that exposure. He radically (and I really do mean “radically” ) burned down the sky to become virtually black, while lightening some clouds that are hardly visible in the contact print so that they jump right out of the black sky background. He also did a lot of work on the foreground.

A third example is his photograph of Wonder Lake and Mt. McKinley. One fascinating thing about this image is how his interpretation of this negative changed radically over the years, moving more in the direction of abstraction.

None of this was a secret. Adams was quite open about all of this, sharing the techniques wiht his students/ followers and writing about it.

1bwana1 wrote:
dalegaspi wrote
1bwana1 wroteJust for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.
i'm sorry..what?

that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?

Ansel Adams will not approve.
Here are a couple of Adams direct quotes for you to think about.

“Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships.”

“In the darkroom, I can experiment, enhance, embellish.”

Adams also often wrote about his view that photography is a creative art, not merely a means of communicating reality. This entitled him to complete freedom in the darkroom.

He absolutely added light in many of his images. In Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico the entire city was in shadow in the negative. In the finished print it was bathed in light that Adams added.

Yes, I created the
...Show more →

Nov 04, 2026 at 08:56 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.163 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Sorry if I missed it, but what is the source of that definition.

In any case, I strongly disagree that “luminosity masks’ are “dodging and burning. “ Dodging and burning were by blocking areas of the print under the enlarger that the photographer wanted to lighten (e.d. “dodging”) or blocking other areas of the print to allow selected areas to receive more exposure, thus darkening them (“burning”). By definition, that does not change local contrast within the dodged and burned reads — it uniformity increase or decreases overall exposure of the affected areas. (It can increase contrast between those areas and other unaffected areas of the print, but that not the same as how we use luminosity masks.)

Luminosity masks were more or less impossible in the traditional darkroom — e.g. selecting an area of the print for increased/decreased contrast by altering a “contrast” setting there or by applying a curve. You don’t “dodge” or “burn” anything with a luminosity mask — you do a localized contrast/curves adjustment. It is more like being able to vary the contrast of the paper locally.

And, of course, there are “dodge” and “burn” tools in applications like Photoshop which do the former buy not the latter. Do dodge and burn in Photoshop you use the dodge and burn tools. To create local luminosity (also color, etc.) masks you don’t generally touch the dodge and burn tools.

One reason that I think that making the distinction clear is important is that too many folks only understand the (relatively crude) masking tools and don’t learn (at least not right away) about the much more powerful application of masked curves and so forth.

A friend who knew and worked with Ansel describes luminosity masks as “the thing Ansel couldn’t do.” Which is one reason taht you’ll occasionally find things like blocked shadows in some of Ansel’s prints, where today we’d probably apply a mask to those areas and then a curve to keep black tones purely black but raise the slightly-less-black tones enough to bring a bit of detail t o those very dark areas.:-)

To answer the other question, Heidelberg for a couple more days then on to some other fun places. No alps this time, though. :-)

- - - - -

On a different topic in this thread (and concerning comments by other posters), I’m neither for or against AI. I land somewhere in the middle. I think that some AI tools are pretty useful — for example the AI Denoise tool in Adobe software. But I’m not very impressed with the generic, unsubtle outcomes like those in the example discussed here earlier. (Having said that, I can imagine how a more skillful AI prompt writer could have done something more sophisticated.) I also believe strongly that the way a photograph communicates the specific vision (and hand) of the photographer is more important that creating some algorithmically “perfect” image, and that a photographer and post-processor would make some far more subtle and effective changes to photographs like what we saw in the example. (I’m interested in how the photographer “sees.” I’m pretty much completely uninterested in “how the AI sees.”)

1bwana1 wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteThe fact that some definition of dodging points out that it is used to lighten areas of an image does not mean that every technique that lightens areas of an image is dodging.

For one thing, dodging lightens all tones in the dodged area without distinction. An arguably more sophisticated alternative that many photographs use in similar situations is to create a mask (to select that area that otherwise you might burn) and then adjust the curve int hat area. This lets you, for example, lighten the bright tones while leaving the dark tones as is… or any other variation on that theme.

I’m not aware of anyone calling that “dodging,” even though it “lightens” at area of the imge.

Also, if I read correctly, the edits on the image in question were done using some kind of AI tool. If so, the specific approach to editing the image demonstrates some of the real shortcomings of that approach.

(Note: BTW, if it seems like I’m posting at sort of odd hours… I’m currently 9 times zones away from where I usually am when I post. ;-)

1bwana1 wrote
Daran wrote
1bwana1 wrote>> Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning
> that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?
Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.
So you said dodging and burning, but you did not show dodging and burning?
Here is the definition of Dodging and Burning. It is exactly what I did, and exactly what I showed.

You will notice that it specifically states it is used to create the appearance of depth in an image which is also exactly my intent.

You will also notice that it doesn't depend on a specific tool or method being used.

"In the digital darkroom, dodging and burning are selective editing techniques used to control the brightness of specific areas of a photograph without changing the entire image.

The terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Actually Luminosity masks to isolate certain tones to be dodged are explicitly included in the definition as quoted below.

"We identified several digital techniques for achieving this:
1. Brushes – selectively lighten or darken specific areas.
2. Masks – isolate areas where lightening or darkening is applied.
3. Gradients – create gradual transitions in brightness or darkness.
4. Luminosity selections / masks – target specific tonal ranges (highlights, midtones, or shadows) to control where lightening or darkening occurs.
An important distinction: Dodge and burn describes the photographic editing objective, not the particular tool used to accomplish it.

For example, using a luminosity mask to selectively brighten highlights
...Show more →

Nov 04, 2026 at 09:08 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.163 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
dalegaspi wrote:
ruthenium wroteThe recent comments are not about the semantics. There seems to be a divide between photographers. While some embrace AI as a tool for processing that can alter a major part of an image, others strongly detest images adulterated by AI.

While I agree that the image in question was improved by the AI processing (and it was an ugly image to begin with, to be honest), the result is like drinking vine carefully crafted from synthetic ethanol and several synthetic ingredients. The resulting product might well taste better than some average natural vine, but I wouldn't buy it.
i personally have no issues with the use AI in images... i use AI for blemishes correction and AI masking to balance out exposure (but not make the image look like HDR)

in that post i see two problems:

1. using AI to an extent that it completely changes the image (it was altered so much a couple folks here thought it was a completely different image!) ...and try to pass it as normal darkroom post-processing and something Ansel Adams would do. the argument was just ridiculous.
2. a bigger offense to me was not disclosing that AI was used in manipulating the
...Show more →

While I didn't mean exactly what you state in point 1 ("completely changes the image"), I meant something closely related:
"AI as a tool for processing that can alter a major part of an image"
Nov 04, 2026 at 09:22 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.163 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
By definition, that does not change local contrast within the dodged and burned reads

Not necessarily. Since the advent of variable contrast paper, it's possible to burn with a different gradation than the initial exposure. It becomes even more interesting when using splitgrade exposure, meaning controlling the desired contrast through two exposures (one at 00 and one at 5). This not only offers the advantage of stepless contrast selection, but also allows you to choose whether to dodge during the 00 or 5 exposure, thus influencing the contrast of the dodged area. I almost exclusively used this technique during my darkroom days and find split exposure truly ingenious.
Nov 04, 2026 at 09:38 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.163 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteBy definition, that does not change local contrast within the dodged and burned reads
Not necessarily. Since the advent of variable contrast paper, it's possible to burn with a different gradation than the initial exposure. It becomes even more interesting when using splitgrade exposure, meaning controlling the desired contrast through two exposures (one at 00 and one at 5). This not only offers the advantage of stepless contrast selection, but also allows you to choose whether to dodge during the 00 or 5 exposure, thus influencing the contrast of the dodged area. I almost exclusively used this technique during my darkroom days and find split exposure truly ingenious.


I think we’d probably call that something like “local contrast enhancement” rather than dodging and burning. :-)
Nov 04, 2026 at 10:14 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.163 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
gdanmitchell wroteBy definition, that does not change local contrast within the dodged and burned reads
Not necessarily. Since the advent of variable contrast paper, it's possible to burn with a different gradation than the initial exposure. It becomes even more interesting when using splitgrade exposure, meaning controlling the desired contrast through two exposures (one at 00 and one at 5). This not only offers the advantage of stepless contrast selection, but also allows you to choose whether to dodge during the 00 or 5 exposure, thus influencing the contrast of the dodged area. I almost exclusively used this technique during my darkroom days and find split exposure truly ingenious.
I think we’d probably call that something like “local contrast enhancement” rather than dodging and burning. :-)


Regardless of what you choose to call it, it is achieved through burning in and dodging.
Nov 04, 2026 at 10:17 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.163 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
The following are some general thoughts on this thread.
I believe that there are distinct groups of photographers:
1) Those who use a computer to process their raw images , and
2) Those who use in-camera processed jpegs.

Those in the first group are less (or little) dependent on the choice of their lenses.

Those in the second group may well subscribe to the idea that some lenses give high-quality images, straight out of camera (or after minimal processing, in the worst cases). Such lenses are usually primes, and these are expected to have a "rendering", and would not be "sterile." For example, photographers in this second group may well have a collection of Cosina Voigtländer lenses. Presently, the influencers seem to strongly promote some new lenses from Chinese companies.

I think the question on "which lens has the most 3D POP" is coming from someone from the second group of photographers.
If this is correct, then the arguments like "5 min of dodging and burning," or related arguments that appeal to the power of post-processing as a method of achieving the desired effect, are misdirected. Those who believe that the choice of certain lenses is the principal way of achieving success in photography may not agree with the view that composition and post-processing skill take priority in photography.

Related to the above, I wonder whether the photos from Phillip in this thread are out-of-camera jpegs?
The recent examples do look like SOOC, unprocessed otherwise - they are often dull and the WB looks uncorrected.
Nov 04, 2026 at 11:50 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.163 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
dalegaspi wrote:
i think there should be a new rule that posters should be transparent WRT use of AI in their posts and tags their images as AI generated or AI manipulated if they are such.


Absolutely.

Amazon publishing has long required creators to disclose in advance their use of AI. Failure to do so, and later realized results in permanent banishment from Amazon publishing.

The point isn't the use of it ... it is the deception potential it presents. Personally, from a copyright perspective, I'd like to see it also be part of the broader law, requiring disclosure ... much like advertising, i.e. fictional characterization requiremetns, etc. While this instance from Steve was so overt that it didn't even require it to be differentiated to detect it (although, it was called out) ... the level of capability today ... and looking forward, to tomorrow and beyond ... the trajectory of inability to differentiate is / going to be impossible for consumers to evaluate / distinguish AI from non-AI sans disclsoure.

As world class organization that Fred aspires for FM to be ... I'd like to think that we can collectively be the "gold standard" that Fred aspires for. That'll be Fred's call, of course, but the point about AI disclosure is a pertinent topic and the ability to lead the issue vs. quibble / debate it ad nauseum is at hand.

Sure, this will draw a firestorm of debate among folks ... but, given how greatly our medium can reside in context of captured vs. created, wheren that difference is not overly obvious, it should be disclosed. It's not that there isn't a given problem with using the tool, but since there is a degree of expectation that our work ... is our work ... well, you get the gist (or you don't).


Simply put ... "shoot straight" with your fellow FM Members (et al). Omissions happen, nobody's perfect. But, yeah if something is AI generated, it should be disclosed that it while it may be construed as a tool for image creation, it is not a photographic tool unto itself. Others will dissent.

Nov 04, 2026 at 12:51 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.163 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
You are absolutely correct to correct the misconception about Ansel on the part of this poster. I’ll forgive him — it is a pretty common mistake to imagine that Adams was all about “realism.” He was actually a master and eager user of film and darkroom post0processing techniques.

I recommend looking into the history of two pretty well known examples.

One is a photograph of a horse caught in a beam of light with Mt. Whitney in the distance. Sorry, at this moment the title escapes me. He shot it from Long Pine, CA with a closer hill in the foreground.
...Show more →
1bwana1 wrote
dalegaspi wrote
1bwana1 wroteJust for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.
i'm sorry..what?

that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?

Ansel Adams will not approve.
Here are a couple of Adams direct quotes for you to think about.

“Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships.”

“In the darkroom, I can experiment, enhance, embellish.”

Adams also often wrote about his view that photography is a creative art, not merely a means of communicating reality. This entitled him to complete freedom in the darkroom.

He absolutely added light in many of his images. In Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico the entire city was in shadow in the negative. In the finished print it was bathed in light that Adams added.

Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.

No lens would have added more perception of depth to that flat lit images as adding light did. That was the point, nothing more.


Agreed that Adams use maniupative techniques. When I first was introduced to his workmanship techniques, my response was "He Cheats !!!"

Bear in mind, I was a dedicated chrome shooter at the time. Took me about 20 years or so to "get over it", but I eventually came to better understand what / why Adams did what he did. BUT, there was no misrepresentation regarding how it came to be. THAT is the matter at hand, where it pertains to AI disclosure vs. non-disclosure (imo). Again, many will dissent.

Nov 04, 2026 at 12:58 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.163 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
Those who believe that the choice of certain lenses is the principal way of achieving success in photography may not agree with the view that composition and post-processing skill take priority in photography.



I think one has to understand that just because someone has a deep interest in optical design influence ... that does not automatically infer they believe the optic supersedes composition, lighting, processing (standard or custome) or other aspects of our beloved craft. It may simply mean they have a strong interest in optical influence. And to the point of the optic ... it is one component in the image creation path. It is neither the start, nor the finish ... it resides in the middle.



Light > subject > composition > lens > sensor / film > PP (std / custom) > print (and back to lighting on print / viewing distance, etc.)



The thread was intended to discuss ONE aspect of the image production chain ... optics. That doesn't negate folks from having an understanding and appreciation of the entire image chain, just because they want to "deep dive" optical contribution. You can have an appreciation for both, each and all aspects of our belvoed craft. I mean, we have a forum dedicated to processing ... what, we need to spend 10 years telling those folks who are wanting to talk about processing ... that lighting is important ...

Oh, wait, we have a forum dedicated to lighting ... let's go tell those folks about the importance of processing ... ummm, this is the gear forum, not the lighting forum, not the processing forum, not the composition forum. If folks want to talk about gear in the gear forum ... idk, let 'em talk about gear.

Nov 04, 2026 at 01:07 PM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.163 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
OregonSun wrote:
Some '50s pop
Telisar C 35mm f/3.5

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55594763662_a6cc8583af_o.jpg


Good idea! The outfit, however, looks more like it’s from the 21st century. 😇

If we’re going to do it, let’s do it right!
Here’s a bit of 50s-style pop, captured around 1962 by my father using an Altissa Altix camera.

20261104_195944 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr
Nov 04, 2026 at 01:14 PM
OregonSun
Offline
Details
p.163 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
OregonSun wroteSome '50s pop
Telisar C 35mm f/3.5

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55594763662_a6cc8583af_o.jpg
Good idea! The outfit, however, looks more like it’s from the 21st century. 😇

If we’re going to do it, let’s do it right!
Here’s a bit of 50s-style pop, captured around 1962 by my father using an Altissa Altix camera.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55632859490_589cd6200b_b.jpg20261104_195944 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr


Very cool!

Yes, photo is recent, but the lens I used was from the '50s (camera from the late '60s).
Nov 04, 2026 at 01:24 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.163 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
OregonSun wroteSome '50s pop
Telisar C 35mm f/3.5

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55594763662_a6cc8583af_o.jpg
Good idea! The outfit, however, looks more like it’s from the 21st century. 😇

If we’re going to do it, let’s do it right!
Here’s a bit of 50s-style pop, captured around 1962 by my father using an Altissa Altix camera.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55632859490_589cd6200b_b.jpg20261104_195944 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr


It does "pop" - in the bottom left corner! 🙂
Nov 04, 2026 at 01:34 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister