fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
RustyRus
Online
Details
p.162 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
(OK, time to try out the new layout)
Bokeh is one of the hardest things and you could stop right there, but I'll add what I look for in bokeh for most portraits. Besides the has-to-be-interesting and exposure/ focus needs, I want the context surrounding the person, not always possible I know; and the person should look part of the scene.

Bokeh must welcome the viewer's eye inside the world of the image, so it has to be easy on the eye. I love lenses that simply present the background objects with a smooth softening - you see their distance (for
...Show more →

Nothing is in focus in the first picture- I think you took what could have been a nice shot to have both ladies in focus and made the picture about what no one cares about, the background blur.

Nov 02, 2026 at 06:37 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.162 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Apple watch on her right wrist, must be a lefty like me :-)

Love the new layout too!!
Nov 02, 2026 at 07:30 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.162 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.


i'm sorry..what?

that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?

Ansel Adams will not approve.
Nov 02, 2026 at 08:02 PM
gdanmitchell
Online
Details
p.162 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.


In the altered version, I think that what you have done to the central figure makes a lot of sense and generally improves her appearance. (Might be a bit hot in a few areas, but it is just meant as an example, I assume.)

For fun, you could also try differentiating a bit more between her and the background. It looks like when you post-processed her you also increased the brightness and perhaps saturation of that background, too. I haven’t tried it with this image, but I’d consider separating her from the background using a mask and letting the background be a bit darker (at least taming the highlights a bit) and perhaps (though I’d have to actually try it to be sure) desaturating it a bit and even shifting the color there to be a bit cooler. (A quick trick is to just ass some vignetting, to, which also tends to strengthen the visual focus on the central area.)
Nov 03, 2026 at 03:36 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
dalegaspi wrote:
1bwana1 wroteJust for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.
i'm sorry..what?

that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?

Ansel Adams will not approve.


Here are a couple of Adams direct quotes for you to think about.

“Dodging and burning are steps to take care of mistakes God made in establishing tonal relationships.”

“In the darkroom, I can experiment, enhance, embellish.”

Adams also often wrote about his view that photography is a creative art, not merely a means of communicating reality. This entitled him to complete freedom in the darkroom.

He absolutely added light in many of his images. In Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico the entire city was in shadow in the negative. In the finished print it was bathed in light that Adams added.

Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.

No lens would have added more perception of depth to that flat lit images as adding light did. That was the point, nothing more.

Edited on Nov 03, 2026 at 06:45 AM · View previous versions
Nov 03, 2026 at 06:24 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
1bwana1 wroteJust for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.
In the altered version, I think that what you have done to the central figure makes a lot of sense and generally improves her appearance. (Might be a bit hot in a few areas, but it is just meant as an example, I assume.)

For fun, you could also try differentiating a bit more between her and the background. It looks like when you post-processed her you also increased the brightness and perhaps saturation of that background, too. I haven’t tried it with this image, but I’d consider separating her from the background using a mask and letting the background be
...Show more →



As I have said, I was not trying to improve the image. What I did was cude and low effort. It only demonstrated the power of light in creating a 3D effect in a 2D medium.
Nov 03, 2026 at 06:27 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.162 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jack Flesher wrote:
jojib wroteI'm still waiting for the Viltrox 50/1.2 LAB but in the meantime I'll keep on shooting with the EF 50/1.2 L

https://a4.pbase.com/g13/30/64330/2/176656615.7b4ae804.jpg
1/800s f/1.2 at 50.0mm iso100
https://a4.pbase.com/g13/30/64330/2/176656637.3726dfea.jpg
1/800s f/1.2 at 50.0mm iso100
I def see 3-D pop in these, but it has zero to do with the lens


hahahahaha!

Same Japanese garden. f/1.2 lenses

October






1/800s f/1.2 at 50.0mm iso100

August






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/500s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100
Nov 03, 2026 at 07:20 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.162 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
>> Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning
> that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?
Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has
...Show more →

So you said dodging and burning, but you did not show dodging and burning?
Nov 03, 2026 at 10:11 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
1bwana1 wrote>> Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning
> that's not dodging and burning; that's literally applying a new light source that wasn't there. was this edited with AI with a prompt "add side lighting on camera right and reflector on camera left"?
Yes, I created the effects of three strobes that were not there. But my example was not made to suggest a proper way to edit. It was only to show that in my opinion the impact of light has a bigger potential in creating depth in an image . Possibly more that the impact of the different lenses being discussed.
So you said dodging and burning, but you did not show dodging and burning?



Here is the definition of Dodging and Burning. It is exactly what I did, and exactly what I showed.

You will notice that it specifically states it is used to create the appearance of depth in an image which is also exactly my intent.

You will also notice that it doesn't depend on a specific tool or method being used.

"In the digital darkroom, dodging and burning are selective editing techniques used to control the brightness of specific areas of a photograph without changing the entire image.

The terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques


DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Nov 03, 2026 at 10:38 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.162 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
The terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?


Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Nov 03, 2026 at 10:59 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wroteThe terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.


Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Nov 03, 2026 at 11:04 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.162 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteThe terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.

Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Nov 03, 2026 at 11:14 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteThe terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.



Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.
Nov 03, 2026 at 11:54 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.162 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteThe terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.


Your excuse is even more inadequate than your photo editing, haha.😄

As for dodging and burning, I don’t need to look up what those terms mean. Unlike you, I actually spent many years practicing these techniques, quite literally, in a darkroom.
The stuff you’re showing here really has nothing to do with that. Furthermore, I always have to chuckle when people who know nothing beyond their Lightroom sliders and who have never even set foot inside a darkroom, let alone produced a proper, hand-crafted print, try to lecture me about tools, methods, techniques, and Ansel Adams. 😂
Nov 03, 2026 at 01:02 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.162 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
Just for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.


I don't understand why you used two different images with different light to demonstrate your point. Maybe you can do it again but use only one image?
Nov 03, 2026 at 01:34 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.162 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
This one popped up in my YT listing today. It would not be wise for me to comment, apart from pointing out the sheer ugliness of much of the process of street photography. It just feels alien. I'm posting not because of the subject matter but because of the very poor sense of image depth that pervades the material. It seems to integrate with the genre however, and maybe that is its own raison d'etre.
..


..
The Street Photographer Who Taught Himself to Be Fearless
Nov 03, 2026 at 01:46 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
1bwana1 wroteJust for the sake of the discussion, no lense could have added as much to the shaping of this image as five minutes of dodging and burning. Just put them side by side and compare.
I don't understand why you used two different images with different light to demonstrate your point. Maybe you can do it again but use only one image?


The first image was not mine to edit and post. So I made a similar one to demonstrate my point. Nothing sinister going on.
Nov 03, 2026 at 02:13 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.162 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wroteThe terms come directly from traditional photographic darkroom printing, as practiced by Ansel Adams.
The two techniques

DODGING
Lighten
- Increases the brightness of selected areas.
- Reveals detail in dark shadows.
- Draws attention to important subjects.
- Creates the appearance of additional illumination. (I specifically did this as I said)

BURNING
Darken
- Decreases the brightness of selected areas.
- Adds depth and contrast. (My specific intent)
- Controls distracting highlights.
- Creates stronger shadows and visual emphasis."

How did I not Dodge and Burn?
Because it’s blindingly obvious that significant alterations have been made here—most likely using AI. For one thing, the background has been completely changed; it’s not just a matter of adding a few highlights—the entire composition of the background has been overhauled, to the point where what’s visible now bears no resemblance to the original image. Furthermore, the scale of the person in relation to the background has been altered. The whole thing is a botched job that has only made matters worse, and it also comes across as looking completely and artificially manipulated.
Happy to read that you enjoyed the image.
Well, frankly, it’s an absolute cheek to claim that you only used dodging and burning—when it’s patently obvious that this is a lie, to call a spade a spade. The fact that I don’t like the result is, in this context, rather beside the point. I can really only imagine one scenario that would lead to such an outcome while you still somehow convince yourself that you only applied dodging and burning: perhaps you uploaded the image to an AI and asked it to dodge and burn, but the AI—unfortunately—ended up doing significantly(!) more than that.
Oh now I see your issue. It is either a language or reading problem. I never used the term "only". I guess you added that in your head?

In fact, I never addressed how I did it. I only said I used dodging and burning to enhance the appearance of depth to the image.

That is 100% true.

Get a dictionary and re-read the definition of dodging and burning. It contains no reference to tools, methods, technique, or limitation...Those are all coming from whatever is troubling you.
Your excuse is even more inadequate than your photo editing, haha.😄

As for dodging and burning, I don’t need to look up what those terms mean. Unlike you, I actually spent many years practicing these techniques, quite literally, in a darkroom.
The stuff you’re showing here really has nothing to do with that. Furthermore, I always have to chuckle when people who know nothing beyond their Lightroom sliders and who have never even set foot inside a darkroom, let alone produced a proper, hand-crafted print, try to lecture me about tools, methods, techniques, and Ansel Adams. 😂


Except once again you make assumptions without basis. I do have two analog cameras, and do shoot film. I develop the film myself rather than use a lab. I have both printed from Negatives and scanned and printed digitally. It is not however a main process for me, and I don't have years of experience nor consider myself an expert.

I am absolutely not trying to lecture you about tools etc.. I am not interested in doing that. I am just having on open conversation on our community forum.


That chip you have on your shoulder must be starting to hurt a bit to inspire so much vitriol. Wipe it off a bit, you might feel better. OK that may be lecture . But a well intentioned one...

Nov 03, 2026 at 02:28 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.162 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?

Jonas B wrote:
I don't understand why you used two different images with different light to demonstrate your point. Maybe you can do it again but use only one image?


1bwana1 wrote:
The first image was not mine to edit and post. So I made a similar one to demonstrate my point. Nothing sinister going on.


I didn't suspect anything sinister, it's just a bit strange asking us to compare two different images when you quite easily should have been able to use another, single, image. Then the discussion could have been about processing or light versus magic lenses. Now it didn't work that well.

Nov 03, 2026 at 02:51 PM
RomanMF
Offline
Details
p.162 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
I always admire these guys for sharing the images Paulie sees them capturing during the interview. In the early portions of this video, I kept thinking, "man, he would have way more keepers if he chose a different tool for this assignment." There are so many awkward compositions and missed focus captures due to the insistence on using the M11. I also feel these guys would stand out from the crowd more if they used different tools from one another.

I want to see the street shooter who's using a Sony/Nikon/Canon/Fuji AF camera and a lens other than a 28/35mm lens. There's still great work being made the "traditional," way, but I love guys like https://www.instagram.com/kyohnam/

philip_pj wrote:
This one popped up in my YT listing today. It would not be wise for me to comment, apart from pointing out the sheer ugliness of much of the process of street photography. It just feels alien. I'm posting not because of the subject matter but because of the very poor sense of image depth that pervades the material. It seems to integrate with the genre however, and maybe that is its own raison d'etre.
..


..
The Street Photographer Who Taught Himself to Be Fearless


Nov 03, 2026 at 02:57 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister