Mystik wrote:
Jack Flesher wrote
Lighting contours shape and form, and multiple source lights and modification of them can mold, enhance or soften the effects. Next focus points, DoF and the character of the focus falloff can add to or detract from the effects depending. So end of day, it’s a combination of lighting and lens characteristics that render the look. And finally how the image is processed after capture, can further enhance —or as often— destroy said effect. Yep. Photographs are 2 dimensional in nature so any perceived dimension in a photos is implied by the elements in the frame, and you can achieve that sense of dimension in a number of ways. No absolute single way to define it, or single path to achieve it. Photographers have a tendency to be self indulgent lol but painters understood this long before the idea of a camera existed. But we're getting into theory here and definitely not what the OP intended.
>>But we're getting into theory here and definitely not what the OP intended. <<
I'm not so sure... The harsh reality is while lens character has some input, it's lighting and processing that are far more important; and to the point I'd say almost any lens of reasonable quality can render 3-D pop with proper lighting, composition and processing...
My .02 anyway.
PS: Do we know if the OP is even still interested?