fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
tuxounet
Offline
Details
p.142 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Steve Spencer wrote:
Ripolini wrotehttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5298491/
Interesting article. Note the distinction between monocular cues and stereoscopic cues. Stereoscopic cues generally aren't used in photography, but they can be used in paintings as this study demonstrated, but were probably introduced late in the history of paintings.


I can’t help but make the connection with the slight residual LoCA on the Zeiss objectives…
Jul 27, 2026 at 08:59 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.142 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
tuxounet wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Ripolini wrotehttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5298491/
Interesting article. Note the distinction between monocular cues and stereoscopic cues. Stereoscopic cues generally aren't used in photography, but they can be used in paintings as this study demonstrated, but were probably introduced late in the history of paintings.
I can’t help but make the connection with the slight residual LoCA on the Zeiss objectives…


LoCA is not a stereoscopic cue to depth perception.
Jul 27, 2026 at 09:15 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.142 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
This has been noted already that the "pop" is not the same as subject separation.
I think the distinction between the two is well seen in the extended series of images of the sexualized females on the previous pages. These girls, that seem to be desperately trying to look glamours, don't pop, in my view.
Subject separation is relatively trivial to achieve and this thread is contaminated by examples of subject separation.
Jul 27, 2026 at 10:41 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.142 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
Good thing the orange warning had been lifted






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/3200s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100
Jul 27, 2026 at 10:56 AM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.142 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
Good thing the orange warning had been lifted

https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176452259.oJovptVN.1DSC07527.jpg
SONY ILCE-7M5
1/3200s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100


What are you seeing that is 3d pop here?

It’s harsh lighting and massive structure behind your subject isn’t even creating subject isolation much less pop to my eyes?
Jul 27, 2026 at 12:30 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.142 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
I'm seeing some separation between the model and lifeguard stand from the background. Also, the colours just pop.
Jul 27, 2026 at 12:33 PM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.142 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
I believe that 3D POP is passed down from generation to generation. This gentleman has a lot of 3D POP in his genes.

DSC03627 by stm geist, auf Flickr
Jul 28, 2026 at 12:13 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.142 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Indeed!!! Love that Batis 135 rendering---but then again I am already in the choir having got the 85.
Jul 28, 2026 at 12:27 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.142 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
What the gent above has is a face that fits entirely within the envelope of highly acceptable DOF. As does the woman, bottom left. These are (heavily compressed) planar effects.

ALL really dimensional lenses must impart to the viewing of their images different imaging characteristics on the longitudinal axis - that is, image depth. You should see variations in color, contrast and (brightness) tone with increasing/decreasing distance from the lens.

This fellow's facial features actually show no such thing. His forehead and chin are identical left-to-right in image space. That does not happen in the real world, well, outside cheesy old Hollywood movies anyway. Same with the wispy hair from where it is thinning to the super sharp single hair above his forehead, left side.

Can you estimate how many degrees of difference there is between his gaze and the direction his upper body is facing? Not easy, is it? Another visual key you can try: mask out all other image content but the man and get back to us with what is left. Your eyes are being fooled into believing that different levels of 'sharpness' front-to-back of the image convey 3D - they do not, any lens can do it, with judicious lens-subject and aperture settings.

If you want 3D, stay well clear of modern APO lenses as they are full of the wrong glass formulae. The older 'APO' lenses were so labelled for super general performance, certainly not 300% inspections on giant monitors.

They are still in strong market demand today for the qualities of their images, Contax Zeiss and Zeiss Super Speeds as one noteworthy example.

Did you know that Leica's (currently available!) M-mount 50mm, 75mm and 90mm APO lenses date from: 14 years ago, 21 years ago and 28 years ago? Why do you think that is so?

AI can help with the answer, which is known to precious few of us:

'The oldest apochromatic (APO) designated photographic lenses still sold new today include the Leica APO-Telyt-M 135mm f/3.4 (introduced in 1998) and the Leica APO-Summicron-M 90mm f/2 ASPH (also introduced in 1998).'

Over half the glass in the Batis 135/2.8 are low dispersion elements - eight of 14 elements. It's why his face is 'etched' so heavily, every irregularity is on full display. Not a nice look for women or today's 'male' actors! Few want to study blackheads and zits.

Cosina, who know their clientele very well, took steps to soften the 50/2 APO-Lanthar for M-mount users. Using the E-mount version as the source for the later release M lens, they scaled back the count of APD elements from five to just two, as well as changing element shaping and spacing. See it here:

https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/vm-mount/apo-lanthar-50mm-f2-aspherical/
https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/e-mount/apo-lanthar-50mm-f2-aspherical/

Low dispersion IS important for 'acceptable' correction, but for portrait/people use it must be balanced carefully with genuine high refractive index (HRI) glass. You won't see much of that in lens specs these days because of the sharpness craze.

The exceptions are several of the Chinese lens producers, who either use mostly high end spherical glass and/or balanced APD/ED and HRI glass - just like the Leica APOs from half most peoples' lifetimes ago.

From the data sheet of the Leica APO-Summicron-M 50/2:

'To realize the apochromatic correction (resulting in a common focusing plane for three light wavelengths), three are made of glass types with high anomalous partial color dispersion, while
two of the others have a high refractive index.' So a 3/2 ratio.

From the data sheet of the Leica APO-Summicron-M 90/2:

'Two of the five lens elements are made of high-refraction optical glass, and two others make judicious use of anomalous partial dispersion.' So a 2/2 ratio.

From the data sheet of the Leica APO-Summicron-M 75/2:

'glass with anomalous partial dispersion is used (no. 2/3). Lens element no. 2 is made of a fluorite-type glass, while the glass used for lens element 3 can trace its origins back to the former Leitz glass laboratory. Lens element no. 4 has a pressed aspherical surface. To minimize monochromatic aberrations, as well as having an aspherical shape the glass used is also highly refractive (no. 5/6).' So a 2/2 ration again - see the pattern?

Some aspherical surfacing has been used for decades, but it should be used sparingly if it is used at all, for beauty and character (and cine!) lenses. Each of these early Leica APO M lenses had just ONE asph surface, and one source suggests the 90/2 contains 'exactly one ground/polished aspherical surface on a single element.'

At the end of the day, enjoy the lenses that make images you like. As you see, this is a technical question as well as a vision question. cheers.

Jul 28, 2026 at 04:15 PM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.142 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
Schwarzlicht wrote:
I believe that 3D POP is passed down from generation to generation. This gentleman has a lot of 3D POP in his genes.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55426470769_65ef86124d_k.jpgDSC03627 by stm geist, auf Flickr


Good one!

Love it!
Jul 28, 2026 at 04:25 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.142 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
What the gent above has is a face that fits entirely within the envelope of highly acceptable DOF. As does the woman, bottom left. These are (heavily compressed) planar effects.

ALL really dimensional lenses must impart to the viewing of their images different imaging characteristics on the longitudinal axis - that is, image depth. You should see variations in color, contrast and (brightness) tone with increasing/decreasing distance from the lens.

This fellow's facial features actually show no such thing. His forehead and chin are identical left-to-right in image space. That does not happen in the real world, well, outside cheesy old
...Show more →

Philip with all due respect, I think this is highly speculative and I am very skeptical of it. I think you are likely wrong. Some really great portrait lens have a lot of APD elements and no advertised high refractive index elements. For example, my favorite portrait lens that I have used is the Zeiss Milvus 85 f/1.4. It has seven APD elements in a planar design and is sharp without being too sharp and given all those APD elements not surprisingly controls axial CA very well. You see a similar setup with a Sonnar design in my second favorite portrait lens I have used the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. It has four APD elements and no reported high refractive index glass.

You seem to fail to appreciate the primary reason that high refractive index (HRI) glass is used in lenses. From everything I have read it is to get the same correction with a smaller amount of glass and therefore a smaller lens. Given this primary purpose of high refractive index glass, it is not surprising that it is used extensively by Leica in Leica M glass that a huge part of the design goal is to keep the lenses small. I don't think the HRI glass is in those lenses to balance APD elements. That seems to be a totally made up fiction on your part. I think it is there to keep the lenses small.

With that in mind it isn't surprising there isn't any (at least noted) HRI glass in the Zeiss Milvus 85 f/1.4 or the Zeiss Milvus 135 f/2 APO. Keeping those lenses small clearly was not much of a design goal.

You constantly hypothesize claims about special glass without any documentation. Let me try to set the record straight.

Anomalous partial dispersion glass is primarily used to reduced color aberrations like axial CA and purple fringing. See these links:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-dispersion_glass

https://www.nikon.com/company/technology/technology_fields/materials/extra_low_dispersion_glass/

https://www.zeiss.com/photonics-and-optics/en/photography/products/lenses-for-slr-cameras/otus-lenses.html
(this is the page for Otus lenses, but note the quote below)

From the Nikon link:

"Extra low dispersion glass, also called anomalous dispersion glass, its refractive index wavelength dependency differs from that of general optical glass in certain wavelength ranges. This allows for effective chromatic aberration correction when combined with general optical glass"

From the Zeiss link:

"Because ZEISS Otus lenses are apochromatic, chromatic aberrations (axial chromatic aberrations) are corrected using elements made of special glass with anomalous partial dispersion.. The chromatic aberrations are therefore significantly below the defined limits."

Then there is high refractive index glass. As described above its primary use is to do the work of regular optical glass with thinner elements that keep the lens smaller.

Here a link that explain its use:

https://www.orau.org/health-physics-museum/collection/consumer/products-containing-thorium/camera-lens.html

And from that link:

"In designing optical lenses, it is often desirable to employ glass with a high index of refraction. The greater the index of refraction, the greater the bending of the light. Since this reduces the necessary curvature of the glass, the lens can be made thinner and lighter."

All that said, one of the things that you can see in the links above is that some HRI glass increases color dispersion. At times HRI glass might be paired with APD glass not to balance the supposed negative properties of APD glass, but to reduce the high dispersion of HRI glass. It is APD glass that is making up for a weakness of HRI glass not the other way around.

Oh and APD glass is not without its weaknesses too, but its primary weakness seems to be not that it makes images flat as you propose without any evidence or documentation, but that it is hard to manufacture and hard to work with and is expensive.

Jul 28, 2026 at 05:38 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.142 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
oh someone started a 135mm party and forgot to invite me :-)





















SONY ILCE-7M5
1/500s f/1.8 at 135.0mm iso100
Jul 28, 2026 at 08:51 PM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.142 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?

I asked the youtube guy ,Shaul, about it once. He told me that Zeiss use different kind of ED glass that is less 'harsh'.
He said that if you use Zeiss glass in his method you should divide the ED in 2 or 3.
philip_pj wrote:
What the gent above has is a face that fits entirely within the envelope of highly acceptable DOF. As does the woman, bottom left. These are (heavily compressed) planar effects.

ALL really dimensional lenses must impart to the viewing of their images different imaging characteristics on the longitudinal axis - that is, image depth. You should see variations in color, contrast and (brightness) tone with increasing/decreasing distance from the lens.

This fellow's facial features actually show no such thing. His forehead and chin are identical left-to-right in image space. That does not happen in the real world, well, outside cheesy old
...Show more →
Jul 28, 2026 at 09:19 PM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.142 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jul 29, 2026 at 09:01 AM
SteveCl55
Offline
Details
p.142 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Whoever came up with this fabled '3d pop' mantra has a great potential in marketing.
So many talk about it, none can definitively explain it.
Jul 29, 2026 at 10:54 AM
gammarART
Offline
Details
p.142 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?


SteveCl55 wrote:
Whoever came up with this fabled '3d pop' mantra has a great potential in marketing.
So many talk about it, none can definitively explain it.


Same with the one Leica look through decades people always talk about.
Jul 29, 2026 at 11:07 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.142 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
SteveCl55 wrote:
Whoever came up with this fabled '3d pop' mantra has a great potential in marketing.
So many talk about it, none can definitively explain it.


That doesn't mean it doesn't exist, just that lots of people are talking around it
Jul 29, 2026 at 11:09 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.142 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
I think the OP already moved on---Fuji? Anyway, my picks with my sole criterion of as if the subject is ready to leap out of my monitor. Oh I also require AF:

Portrait slam (35, 50, 85 and 135):

35: I'll take my Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N any day albeit I haven't seen any pics from the Sigma 35/1.2 II---maybe they are too shy to show them.

50: I don't have this lens but I've seen samples---Sony 50/1.2 GM for sure!!

85: I'll take my Canon 85/1.2 LII any day

135: pick 'em. Doesn't matter. I've seen pics from the Batis 135/2.8 but I truly enjoy my Sony 135GM and the good old EF 135/2 L
Jul 29, 2026 at 11:16 AM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.142 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
gammarART wrote:
SteveCl55 wroteWhoever came up with this fabled '3d pop' mantra has a great potential in marketing.
So many talk about it, none can definitively explain it.
Same with the one Leica look through decades people always talk about.


There is a Leica look though-

Shoot with any Leica lens and you have it- That one is extremely simple to quantify!

I would say there is some truth to a Leica look back in the early days of 35mm photography- But I am not that old so I can't say for certain
Jul 29, 2026 at 11:22 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.142 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Beggars can’t be choosers, and we often have to photograph people in strange light. The best dramatic light for portraits enters from the side, the worst (you might say) evenly lights the face. That’s because the even lighting seems to encourage what I call ‘flat face’.

And this is the condition that damages dimensionality badly if the subject is overexposed. This choice destroys facial image ‘content’, also known as skin! We are photographing light falling on the subject, and it often does not fall with great evenness on objects that have shaped depth and contours, such as a human face in sunlight or incidental light.

It’s a current trend that will not age well. The rising concern in the cine business right now is the challenge of how to instill texture into digital imagery.

The breakthroughs that will eventually domesticate digital will come from the cine world because they know what they are looking at, and even better, they know what they are looking for. Motivation is very high.

(You can look up ‘film outs’ for more on this expensive technique. Rightly so, people hate the look of digital, they want something more akin to reality, even if it incurs great cost to achieve it.

‘A "film out" is a post-production technique where digital video footage is printed frame-by-frame onto physical motion picture film stock using a laser or CRT recorder, chemically developed in a lab, and then scanned back into a digital file.’

A good primer: ‘Why Movies Suddenly Look Like Film Again’ by Jimmy on Film. On The Batman (2022) and Dune (2021), cinematographer Greig Fraser shot these massive digital productions on high-end sensors, but intentionally ran a film-out pass to physical stock and re-scanned it to inject organic grain and authentic analog texture.)

But sensible exposure and a little retouching is a solid start to:
. retain texture in faces,
. to make them not look anemic,
. to use contour shaping to render them with dimensionality (the technically accepted word for 3D, and it’s the third D we care about in this discussion).

Correct exposure reveals the character that draws from their innate identity. And it’s easy enough to fix in post, if it matters enough to you. We need many more portrait-oriented lenses to be made primarily for artistic people photography, not directed only at commercial expedience, where the high tone fashion look most likely originated, to then be propagated out to the imaging industrial complex. You see it seemingly all the time in event photography.

Why does it all matter? Why does it matter to have people look more like themselves? Because, if we can’t image the human face aesthetically such that it respects and compliments the person for who they are in real life, what does that say about photography?
Jul 29, 2026 at 06:50 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister