Hm. If one and the same lens is magical for a while, then suddenly not anymore, and then all at once again, this wonderfully proves that whether a lens is magical or not depends on the viewer and their state of mind, their mood, so to speak.😉👍
Agree. And the emotion one feels for the subject perhaps as a result of personal connection.
Conversely, we all know that certain lenses DO consistently perform better than others. It's just difficult to demonstrate with a handful of posts in a thread like this. Probably better to rely on reported experiences, eg Tim saying the Sigma 28-45 consistently pleases him.