gdanmitchell wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
Is the horrendous bokeh in the last image due to the floating element? The images that poster shares to illustrate his posts about “pop” really make me wonder what he is seeing. To put it delicately, if we put those in a stack of prints of all sorts of similar photographs from other sources and asked observers to pick out those best exhibiting “pop,” I don’t think they would top the list.
I also cannot help feeling that these portraits make me uncomfortable.
Street people photography constitutes an invasion of privacy, and must be done responsibly.
In the simplest sense, at the very least, there must be a reason for taking street pictures with people in the frame.
Particularly when taking large and detailed close-up portraits - these are very intimate, in a way, and that intimacy is inappropriate when it is forced on the subject, when it is not enthusiastically consensual.
The portraits from "that poster", particularly the female portraits, look to me like the individuals were randomly approached in the streets, and nearly harassed into being photographed, because those young shy females in a third-world Asian country might possibly not be accustomed to say "f--k off" when being approached by a foreign male.
The series of portraits that I have seen from "that poster" almost all look like random shots taken for no obvious reason and taken out of the cultural/geographic context. These portraits don't look like professional portraits either. Thus, my impression is that the photographer is interested in portrait photography but has no access to models and, thus, is practicing on the innocent strangers.