JohnDizzo15 wrote:
Your analogy makes perfect sense, and I do not disagree with the logic at all as it is quite sound. Additionally, it would be more than an appropriate response if the OP asked, “how does one achieve the most 3D pop?” But alas, that was not the question.
Putting aside your personal characterizations and borderline ad hominem for the moment, and instead considering the “that was not the question” idea:
Sometimes a question cannot be taken at face value, and pointing out the problem with the question is the most relevant and useful response when the question itself is flawed.
If someone asks, “What is the very best spoon for making soup?” and in the follow up there are answers claiming that some exotic spoon is the one that will greatly improve soup and that others fall short, the most useful response is — as mine and others has been — that getting some expensive, exotic spoon will make essentially no meaningful or objective improvement in the soup… and, sensing that the person posing the question really does want to make better soup, steering the discussion in a direction that might have that result.