3dpophunter wrote:
jojib I like your shots and you're a great portrait photographer. A lot better than me'
But I'm not sure you understand what 3d pop is.
I guess there's no real definition.
That’s correct. There’s no specific, definable individual thing that people agree is pop.
The way the term “pop” functions is similar to how some of the following words function: beautiful, cool, rugged, wise, colorful, yummy, interesting, big, and many others. We use these words in subjective ways, yet we have some notion of how they can be applied, but there’s no specific set of objective features that universally defines them
I can say something is beautiful, but things can be beautiful for many different reasons. We have an idea what it means to say someone is “cool.” But there is no specific thing that makes a person cool.
If you and I look at a photograph and I remark, “That photo really pops!” we might agree, but if I followed that statement with, “What makes it pop?”, you might point to any number of features and qualities that explained it. We’ve been through a list of many of those things earlier in this thread, presented by people who would be pleased if you told them their photograph “pops,” but who would explain it in a variety of ways.
By the way, if there was a singular definition of “pop,” can we agree that it would have emerged over the course of the thousands of osts in this thread? And if there was a lens that produced the most of it, that some agreement might have been reached by now? But neither has happened. That’s because it cannot.
FWIW.