Nifty Fifty wrote:
Something completely different. What do you think? Do you believe that more three-dimensional representation always equates to a better image? I personally don't feel that way. While I always find it fascinating (except for 3D pop—I'd rather call it a cropping effect, which I find unnatural, even downright ugly), I often find photos that appear somewhat flatter much more appealing and visually striking. It's similar to sharpness, contrast, and resolution. Sometimes less is more. At least for me.
Agreed. This topic deserves a well written essay. There is something to be said about the sense of restraint. I think people are generally attracted to images that have "the one thing" about them. Not two or three. Most commonly "the one thing" is described as "telling a story" but IMO that's too specific. Sometimes it's the combination of colors. Sometimes it's a beauty of a well-isolated subject. Sometimes it's just a sense of symmetry. Whatever it is, it's singular. And I find that the convenience of digital editing leads us to ruining it. 80% of images posted on photo forums are victims of digital temptations: too much contrast, too much saturation, too much fake drama in the skies, shadows are too lifted, etc. None of this looks ordinary and therefore grabs attention, leading to your attention being scattered and unfocused, and the photo is no longer about "the one thing".
A couple of days ago Ross Martin posted a photo of a beach lit by the harsh mid-day sun. Sorry, can't find it right now, but it is what you'd expect: a bit washed out, blueish color temperature, slight marine haze, etc. A typical "digital photographer" would have immediately tweaked the white balance towards more warmth, cranked up that clarity/degaze slider. He didn't. And that's what made that photo work for me: it refocused my attention to what's acutally in the image.