fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.104 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
j4nu wroteThat's a great example and it shows how much lighting and contrast are important in perception of this effect.
Though, some will probably say that's the cut-out look ...
Can I put it this way in English: The image is easy on the eye to look at. it resembles the cut-out look but for me it isn't that at all; here i can see things continously from close to the camera to a more distant background.


Hmm, I don't think I agree. Looking around subjects faces, there's basically nothing there, except the distant blurred background. So, for me it's exactly what people call cut-out, but I like that look most of the time.
Dec 08, 2025 at 10:04 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.104 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
Can I put it this way in English: The image is easy on the eye to look at. it resembles the cut-out look but for me it isn't that at all; here i can see things continously from close to the camera to a more distant background.



j4nu wrote:
Hmm, I don't think I agree. Looking around subjects faces, there's basically nothing there, except the distant blurred background. So, for me it's exactly what people call cut-out, but I like that look most of the time.



Then we are seeing this differently. Interesting.
I see the ground, the asphalt as a clear path towards the distant background. The ground keeps it all together and for my brain the people and everything else in the city environment falls nicely at place. I don't dare to say 3D but there is a nice depth in the image (to my eyes/brain).
Dec 08, 2025 at 10:30 AM
evanhanded
Offline
Details
p.104 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
So, have we decided yet whether the lens with the most 3D pop is a pistol or a rifle? ;-)


Actually, it's a shotgun. But that begs the question...what size shot gives the most 3D pop? Not to worry, as we are so lucky to have someone who's spent 40 years reloading...40...if you didn't get it, 40 years. He knows everything that it's even possible to know about it. Just ask him.
Dec 08, 2025 at 10:50 AM
evanhanded
Offline
Details
p.104 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
mudlake wrote:
evanhanded wrote
mudlake wrote
evanhanded wrote
mudlake wrote
evanhanded wroteYeah....nope. Accepting a blurry target is a bad idea. Your eyes can quickly shift between the sights on your rifle and your target. Your brain will stitch the two sharp images together. And that's what your brain will record, not the blurry image of the target while eyes are on the rifle sight. In addition, if the lighting is good, your eyes are equivalent to about f/8 and a focal length of 22-24mm. That's a pretty substantial depth of field.
As stated above, RustyBug was referring to shooting handguns. I’ve been shooting handguns for 40 years and the first rule of hitting your target is: focus 100% on the FRONT sight. Target will be blurry. Focusing on the target will ensure you’ll miss 50% of the time or more.
Logical fallacy: appealing to authority. Your claim of shooting for 40 yrs. I don't know if you've actually done that, but I don't care if true. I never said to shoot while focusing on the target. Your reading comprehension skills are also lacking.
Got it. You didn't do one bit of research on your own about how to shoot a handgun. I didn't misread your post when you stated, "Yeah...nope. Accepting a blurry target is a bad idea." Admitting you are ignorant about a subject isn't anything to be ashamed of. The older I get the more I understand that I don't know much about anything. And I read 2-3 books on various topics a week. Peace.
Wrong again. You did misread my post. And you're wrong about how to shoot a gun. The first rule of shooting any weapon is to identify your target. It had better not look blurry.
That’s good to know. Thank you for that instruction. I would have never known that someone who had never fired a gun before could teach me something new after 40 years of shooting and reloading my own ammunition. It’s amazing who you meet on the internet! 🙂


40 years and not a dram of humility. I wish I could say I was surprised.
Dec 08, 2025 at 11:09 AM
gdanmitchell
Online
Details
p.104 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Speaking of not getting it… ;-)

evanhanded wrote:
...if you didn't get it, 40 years. .

Dec 08, 2025 at 11:30 AM
evanhanded
Offline
Details
p.104 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
RustyBug wrote
j4nu wrote
RustyBug wroteThe salient point is (imo) that the human eye (lens) functions with the similar properties of optical physics as lenses. The CoC / DOF / rate of transition / blur are all pieces of the depth / spatial cues. There is the difference in terms of accommodation that the eye / brain relationship offers vs. our beloved optics. The irony here being that since the accommodation of the eye / brain varies among individuals, it also infers that different people will have different abilities to discern / respond to those physiological cues.
Well, I'd say we have a pair of eyes to help with that 3d/depth processing in our brain. So, looking at a flat image of a scene is not the same as looking at the same scene with our own eyes...
An interesting link that expands on the differences in acuity that people can have and how that equates to resolving capability. I find it interesting that in the development of the math from the arc, the number(s) that are derived correlate to 40 lpmm, and other numbers that are consistent with certain standards, and is somewhat presented in the context of cinema vs. non-cinema. This contrasted with human vision ranges to detect micro-contrast are variable.

With "normal" at 20/20 and some at 20/12 (I'm between 12-15 ... well, 800 actually, but corrected to 20/15 or better, with help from doc and the lab), with a few rare at 20/8 ... it suggests that the ability to differentiate the micro-contrasts between lenses greater than 30 lpmm may not be detectable for all individuals. Thus, not everyone picks up on all the cues, the same way, and if 20/20 is "normal", there are those individuals, also who may be less acute than normal (20/25, etc.).

I've often found it interesting how many lens mfr's only test / present to 30 lpmm data, while others present to 40 lpmm. In the realm of "hmmm, why's that" ... I think the article gives us a clue wrt to average vs. exceptional visual acuity targets, that folks can differentiate. It doesn't state so empirically, but I think it is a reasonable extrapolation to consider. That, and the cinema vs. non-cinema considerations referenced / inferred.

https://wolfcrow.com/what-is-the-resolution-of-the-human-eye-and-do-cinema-cameras-need-more-than-8k/
Yes, I agree that people with different vision can discern different levels of detail in the same scenario. I also think that above a certain lp/mm threshold, I stop seeing the differences between the best lenses in real life (even when pixel peeping).
Still, I don't think this has much to do with the subject of this thread . As 3d pop is a general impression our eyes+brain produce when looking at a certain 2d image.

I still need to read the whole link, but as it mentions cinema, I have to say that I think for video, the requirements on
...Show more →

This thread has failed in multiple ways, but most importantly to the supposed subject. Which lenses have the most 3D pop?...unanswered. Has even one lens been identified to consistently out 3D pop another? Nope. Has a rigorous definition of 3D pop even been proposed, much less agreed to? What we are left with is subjective individual opinions. That picture seems to pop for me...so it must be at least partly due to the lens. And maybe I can even make out a unicorn in the bokeh.
Dec 08, 2025 at 11:47 AM
Planetwide
Offline
Details
p.104 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
Many things can affect perceived depth in an image. Rapid focus fall off will contribute to a "cut out" effect or perception. But sometimes it can be composition.

SL2 & L 24-90mm





Dec 08, 2025 at 12:53 PM
gdanmitchell
Online
Details
p.104 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
deleted

Edited on Dec 08, 2025 at 01:23 PM · View previous versions
Dec 08, 2025 at 01:16 PM
mudlake
Offline
Details
p.104 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
evanhanded wrote:
mudlake wrote
evanhanded wrote
mudlake wrote
evanhanded wrote
mudlake wroteAs stated above, RustyBug was referring to shooting handguns. I’ve been shooting handguns for 40 years and the first rule of hitting your target is: focus 100% on the FRONT sight. Target will be blurry. Focusing on the target will ensure you’ll miss 50% of the time or more.
Logical fallacy: appealing to authority. Your claim of shooting for 40 yrs. I don't know if you've actually done that, but I don't care if true. I never said to shoot while focusing on the target. Your reading comprehension skills are also lacking.
Got it. You didn't do one bit of research on your own about how to shoot a handgun. I didn't misread your post when you stated, "Yeah...nope. Accepting a blurry target is a bad idea." Admitting you are ignorant about a subject isn't anything to be ashamed of. The older I get the more I understand that I don't know much about anything. And I read 2-3 books on various topics a week. Peace.
Wrong again. You did misread my post. And you're wrong about how to shoot a gun. The first rule of shooting any weapon is to identify your target. It had better not look blurry.
That’s good to know. Thank you for that instruction. I would have never known that someone who had never fired a gun before could teach me something new after 40 years of shooting and reloading my own ammunition. It’s amazing who you meet on the internet! 🙂
40 years and not a dram of humility. I wish I could say I was surprised.


🧐. Take care evanhanded. Your humility is an inspiration.
Dec 08, 2025 at 01:17 PM
gdanmitchell
Online
Details
p.104 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
Planetwide wrote:
Back to images, Leica SL3 & SL 50mm Lux @f1.4@








Things that contribute to the effect of this photograph:

Lighter in the center of the frame and some vignetting (or at least darker subjects) in much of the background and near corners and edges.

Rim lighting from back left on the subjects makes them stand out a bit.

It appears that there is a bit of fill lighting on the subjects, too — see the woman’s face. Perhaps reflected from a nearby building?

Positioning the subjects on white triangle draws attention to them, too. (Note that this triangle “points” the direction that the predominant light travels.)

More saturated colors on the primary subjects and less saturation in the background.

Slight OOF in the background adds “subjective sharpness” to the front group.

The angled shadows add a sense of perspective/depth.

A subtle (maybe?) band of light from upper left toward lower right intercepts the primary subjects.

- - -

Aside from its focal length, the specific lens used here has virtually nothing to do with the effect. It is all that other stuff.

If it were my photograph, I might consider cropping a bit at left and right to eliminate the distracting people right at the frame edges, particularly the one in the red jacket.

- - -

Excellent point in a thread a bit up from this one: After something like 1034pages (over 2000 posts) it is clear that a) there is no answer to the “best 3D pop” lens question, b) that there is no single thing that produces this effect called “3D pop,” c) there is no real agreement as to quite what it even is.

Edited on Dec 08, 2025 at 10:47 PM · View previous versions
Dec 08, 2025 at 01:23 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.104 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
evanhanded wrote:
Has even one lens been identified to consistently out 3D pop another? Nope.


Take a walk through the VM 40/1.2 thread, sometime ...
Dec 08, 2025 at 09:29 PM
Nifty Fifty
Online
Details
p.104 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?


RustyBug wrote:
evanhanded wroteHas even one lens been identified to consistently out 3D pop another? Nope.
Take a walk through the VM 40/1.2 thread, sometime ...

Thank you, that answers the initial question and the thread can be closed.
Dec 08, 2025 at 11:32 PM
rsrsrs
Offline
Details
p.104 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Slight OOF in the background adds “subjective sharpness” to the front group.

and this is the secret of 3D Pop
Can we close my thread?
Dec 09, 2025 at 01:31 AM
tuxounet
Offline
Details
p.104 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
Planetwide wroteBack to images, Leica SL3 & SL 50mm Lux @f1.4@@
https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-jsd3vv2/0/NC2pD26wWbNsfSw3MWH5P5tJ8pdBXhND294DShqHx/X2/i-jsd3vv2-X2.jpg

Things that contribute to the effect of this photograph:

Lighter in the center of the frame and some vignetting (or at least darker subjects) in much of the background and near corners and edges.

Rim lighting from back left on the subjects makes them stand out a bit.

It appears that there is a bit of fill lighting on the subjects, too — see the woman’s face. Perhaps reflected from a nearby building?

Positioning the subjects on white triangle draws attention to them, too. (Note that this triangle “points” the direction that the predominant light travels.)

More saturated colors on the primary subjects and less saturation
...Show more →

Also the vignetting helps a lot (does it come from the lens or add in post)
Dec 09, 2025 at 01:35 AM
tuxounet
Offline
Details
p.104 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?


Loxia 2/50 (from https://phillipreeve.net)
Dec 09, 2025 at 01:50 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.104 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
rsrsrs wrote:
Slight OOF in the background adds “subjective sharpness” to the front group.

and this is the secret of 3D Pop
Can we close my thread?


I knew it! It was always about the (not excessive) blur ...
Dec 09, 2025 at 04:07 AM
jamesdak
Offline
Details
p.104 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
I don't get all the complaining to close the thread. A lot of people are having fun with it. If you don't want to play, just don't participate. Why is this so hard to understand?
Dec 09, 2025 at 09:25 AM
gyoung143
Offline
Details
p.104 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
It's a great thread. Proves no one can quantify Pop, amazing what some people think has it, even some 'dogs'! (Lens not people :-) )

Gerry
Dec 09, 2025 at 10:09 AM
Bacalhau
Offline
Details
p.104 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
rsrsrs wroteSlight OOF in the background adds “subjective sharpness” to the front group.

and this is the secret of 3D Pop
Can we close my thread?
I knew it! It was always about the (not excessive) blur ...


Or bokeh...

In all, there are lenses and mostly conditions that allow that impression of a 3D effect, but there are also two people that can't perceive it, and not just as not seeing but also by over-seeing it

So, it's a Trifecta > lens, moment and brain


Dec 09, 2025 at 10:22 AM
Nifty Fifty
Online
Details
p.104 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Bacalhau wrote:
that impression of a 3D

Impressions of 3D exist even without 3D pop (which, by the way, isn't defined, so one person understands this and another understands that term differently). In some cases, 3D pop is almost the exact opposite of an impression of 3D. This is precisely what makes this thread so utterly pointless. And nothing will change in the coming years. It will continue to go around in circles, just like in the countless posts on the past 100 pages.

Edited on Dec 09, 2025 at 10:35 AM · View previous versions
Dec 09, 2025 at 10:33 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister