fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011500/4 purchase dilema

  
 
DocsPics
Offline
Details
p.2 #1500/4 purchase dilema
Ian, I am leaning in that direction. I hate to part with my "best lens" and most reliable lens which has, for the last several years, been the 300/2.8 IS. There will be seller's remorse with any of the lot, but probably most with the 300.

Thanks all for the help. (It's not everyday that a shrink can reach out and receive some valuable advice....we are supposed to have all the answers all the time...right!)

Off to the B&S board to list the 400 (likely will have to ultimatley go to the Bay with that one)
Jan 13, 2011 at 10:03 AM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.2 #2500/4 purchase dilema
Gary, in order to save some time and your thru-ruinously-hard-toil earned $$ , I'd suggest the following items to be ordered with the lens(e):

(1) Don Zeck's cap
(2) Kirk replacement footsie
(3) Tenba LL 400 shoulder (top loading) bag.
(Need to confirm the bag model)
Jan 13, 2011 at 10:19 AM
DocsPics
Offline
Details
p.2 #3500/4 purchase dilema
Good suggestions Peter. Just called B&H to place the order and well, someone walked in off the street this morning and bought the refurb I had my eye on. Now the hunt is on again. $6399 is the going rate for a new one. (Interesting that the sales person I spoke with at B&H did not know about an upcoming Canon price hike.) An FM lurker has offered me their "hardly used" 2007 500/4 lens for $5300 (no warranty and no posted feedback). Patience...patience...patience
Jan 13, 2011 at 10:55 AM
Lars Johnsson
Offline
Details
p.2 #4500/4 purchase dilema
Rob Whiting wrote:
Breitling65 wrotealmost "as good"? Not even close in AF speed with tc, shorter than 500mm with 1.4tc (420). With 2x need tripod and very slow on AF. How is that as good?
You seemed to cut off the first part of my sentence in your quote.. "unless you're doing BIF".

Meaning the AF speed will suffer. IQ wise though, you'd be hard pressed to tell the difference between:

500 @ f/4 and 300 f/2.8 +1.4x @ f/4
500+1.4 @ f/5.6 and 300 f/2.8 + 2x @ f/5.6

obviously you'd lose some focal length.

why would you need a tripod with the 300 + 2x, but not the 500?

I do own the 500, and have used the 300 2.8 a lot.. If I did own the 300, I wouldn't sell it to get a 500
...Show more →

The 300 + 1,4x is not like the 500 or even very close
The 300 + 2x is not like the 500 + 1,4x or even close
Jan 13, 2011 at 12:04 PM
Rob Whiting
Offline
Details
p.2 #5500/4 purchase dilema
Lars Johnsson wrote:
The 300 + 1,4x is not like the 500 or even very close
The 300 + 2x is not like the 500 + 1,4x or even close


Going by image quality alone, shooting real world subjects (not test charts), I'm willing to bet most people wouldn't be able to tell the difference, even at 100% crop.

When I get my hands on a 300 again, I'll prove it
Jan 13, 2011 at 03:52 PM
eleff
Offline
Details
p.2 #6500/4 purchase dilema
I bought my 500/F4 and m,y 300/2.8 used and never had a problem. I have the 300/2.8 and the 500/F4 and I had the 400 DO. The 300 is fast, sharp and wonderful, but the 500 easily beats the 300+1.4x. Alas I generally have a 1.4 on my 500 for BIF, but can't justify the 800. The 400 is very light, wonderfully balanced. You can hold it all day. At the end of the day, the 300 and the 500 were just consistantly sharper. I would go for both the 300 and the 500, although I toyed with the idea of the 200F2 and the 500 and skipping the 300. Sometimes regret not doing that.

Scott
Jan 13, 2011 at 03:52 PM
roboticspro
Offline
Details
p.2 #7500/4 purchase dilema
Well...

I too checked the B&H site to find that the price climbed up earlier than the Feb 1st posted date. Oh well, I've lost more on bad meals, movies, shows over the years, so it is water well-over the dam and under the bridge at this point. My order goes in tomorrow for Tuesday delivery.

Gary (DocPics): Sorry about the walk-in grabbing the lens; the old "day late - dollar short" strikes again...I know to the tune of ~ $250.00 for my waiting

Edd
Jan 13, 2011 at 06:21 PM
Lars Johnsson
Offline
Details
p.2 #8500/4 purchase dilema
Rob Whiting wrote:
Lars Johnsson wroteThe 300 + 1,4x is not like the 500 or even very close
The 300 + 2x is not like the 500 + 1,4x or even close
Going by image quality alone, shooting real world subjects (not test charts), I'm willing to bet most people wouldn't be able to tell the difference, even at 100% crop.

When I get my hands on a 300 again, I'll prove it


I owned both for many years. So I know it. The 500 alone is just as sharp and good as the 300 alone. The 300 + extender has less good image quality and AF speed than the 500 alone. And it's also shorter even with the extender.
with the 2x the result is even a bit worse.

The 300 is of course very good together with extenders. But so are all the other super-teles also
Jan 13, 2011 at 07:52 PM
Lars Johnsson
Offline
Details
p.2 #9500/4 purchase dilema
eleff wrote:
I bought my 500/F4 and m,y 300/2.8 used and never had a problem. I have the 300/2.8 and the 500/F4 and I had the 400 DO. The 300 is fast, sharp and wonderful, but the 500 easily beats the 300+1.4x. Alas I generally have a 1.4 on my 500 for BIF, but can't justify the 800. The 400 is very light, wonderfully balanced. You can hold it all day. At the end of the day, the 300 and the 500 were just consistantly sharper. I would go for both the 300 and the 500, although I toyed with the idea
...Show more →

I had the 300 & 500. But today the 200 & 800. And the light 400/5,6 between those. You have to justify it before the increased price
Jan 13, 2011 at 07:57 PM
Tlazer
Offline
Details
p.2 #10500/4 purchase dilema
Why not the 400mm f2.8 IS L lens? This lens offers something the 500mm can't do and that is to go to f2.8, plus with the 1.4X TC you now have a 560mm f4 lens and the IQ will be about the same and if you don't use the TC the IQ will be even better with quicker focusing.
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:05 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.2 #11500/4 purchase dilema
roboticspro wrote:
Well...

I too checked the B&H site to find that the price climbed up earlier than the Feb 1st posted date. Oh well, I've lost more on bad meals, movies, shows over the years, so it is water well-over the dam and under the bridge at this point. My order goes in tomorrow for Tuesday delivery.

Gary (DocPics): Sorry about the walk-in grabbing the lens; the old "day late - dollar short" strikes again...I know to the tune of ~ $250.00 for my waiting

Edd



Edd......here is one suggestion .....when you receive the lens make sure the Canon box is sealed with adhesive tape and there is no sign of tampering with the tape.
All Canon supertelephoto lens sets are delivered to retailers in sealed Canon cardboard boxes.

If the box comes to you with the seal tape cut or re-applied, that effectively means you got an "open box" lens for the price of a brand new lens. Reputable retailers provide price discounts on their "open box" merchandise. (See this as an example)

Now, there could be several reasons for a broken seal......the most common one in my opinion is lens returns.

Edited on Jan 13, 2011 at 11:30 PM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:17 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.2 #12500/4 purchase dilema
Tlazer wrote:
Why not the 400mm f2.8 IS L lens? This lens offers something the 500mm can't do and that is to go to f2.8, plus with the 1.4X TC you now have a 560mm f4 lens and the IQ will be about the same and if you don't use the TC the IQ will be even better with quicker focusing.


A few reasons for that:

* 400 f/2.8 IS costs about $1,000 more.
* 400 f/2.8 IS is used handheld only by super strong or super insane.
* Yes, 400 f/2.8 IS is a bit better performing lens, but that advantage fades once you put 1.4xTC on it.
* 400mm is often not long enough for small/distant animals.
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:23 PM
Netgarden
Offline
Details
p.2 #13500/4 purchase dilema
Keep the 300, because once you shoot with the 500, whenever you get it, your standards will be raised and you won't want to shoot below the quality of those two lenses. Good luck, I held out for quite a while and got a gorgeous used 500 on fm here.

I don't know what the new 500 will do to the prices of used 500s, but I think they will hold their excellent value especially due to the high cost of the new ones, unless the price of the old version new gets reduced. But on second thought, why not sell a few lenses and get the new 500?now that sounds exciting!
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:25 PM
DocsPics
Offline
Details
p.2 #14500/4 purchase dilema
Any thoughts (guesses) on how long Canon will continue to service the 500 MKI after they release the MkII?
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:33 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.2 #15500/4 purchase dilema
DocsPics wrote:
Any thoughts (guesses) on how long Canon will continue to service the 500 MKI after they release the MkII?



I reckon 2-4 weeks.
Jan 13, 2011 at 08:35 PM
gardnerdw
Offline
Details
p.2 #16500/4 purchase dilema
About 6 months ago I purchased a used 500 F4 is from KEH. It was bgn (yes I knew what that meant) for 4200. Works great, looks bad.
They have a very good reputation and good return policy.
They are hard to get and I left my name with them until they got one in and they called in about 3 weeks.
You can get better condition for more money but I did not care about looks.
You might also call Roberts in Indianapolis. They get a lot of high end trade-ins.
Getting the 500 was the best lens purchase I have ever made. It is a great lens
Jan 13, 2011 at 09:01 PM
Lars Johnsson
Offline
Details
p.2 #17500/4 purchase dilema
Tlazer wrote:
Why not the 400mm f2.8 IS L lens? This lens offers something the 500mm can't do and that is to go to f2.8, plus with the 1.4X TC you now have a 560mm f4 lens and the IQ will be about the same and if you don't use the TC the IQ will be even better with quicker focusing.


The 500 offers many things the 400 can't do either.
500 mm without extender
700 & 1000 mm with the 1,4x & 2x
much lighter to shoot with or carry
a lower price

The 400 is more a lens for sport shooters IMO
Jan 13, 2011 at 09:11 PM
Netgarden
Offline
Details
p.2 #18500/4 purchase dilema
Lars I have to agree, have the same experience also. Been recently switching my gear around to get a satisfactory light weight set up. They all have their quirks either by weight, clarity or distance. No 2x will be able to replace the 500 in quality. My years of experience making teleconverters work told me that they are very useful, but nothing compares to a clean prime in performance and clarity. And difficult shooting situations are so critical, it is then that you wish you had your 500 with you!

Pretty tough to carry all the gear as well. That's when a teleconverter is most appreciated. But I also had days where the gear became almost the weight of the 500' and I wished I had just brought that one lens instead.
Jan 13, 2011 at 09:16 PM
roboticspro
Offline
Details
p.2 #19500/4 purchase dilema
PetKal wrote:
Edd......here is one suggestion .....when you receive the lens make sure the Canon box is sealed with adhesive tape and there is no sign of tampering with the tape.
All Canon supertelephoto lens sets are delivered to retailers in sealed Canon cardboard boxes.

If the box comes to you with the seal tape cut or re-applied, that effectively means you got an "open box" lens for the price of a brand new lens. Reputable retailers provide price discounts on their "open box" merchandise. (See this as an example)

Now, there could be several reasons for a broken seal......the most common one in my
...Show more →

Thanks for the "heads-up" Peter...I just ordered the 500 from B&H after reading your posting. Now the wait .

Back to work...

Edd
Jan 14, 2011 at 04:25 AM
ashley138
Offline
Details
p.2 #20500/4 purchase dilema
I had thought the price of the mkI 300 on the used market would have gone down starting a little before the release of the mkII, partially because there would be more of them on the market because people would want to sell to buy the mk II. But this doesn't seem to be the case at all! I'm in the market for a used 300 mkI, and it seems like there is actually fewer of them around and the prices are higher if anything! It's disappointing. Does anyone know why this is?
I am dying to have a 500, but it's too pricey, so I'm gonna make due with the 300 for now and save up for the 500.
What does everyone think - when I eventually get my 500, what lens do you guys think would be good to supplement it (something lighter, for handheld and BIFs etc.) keep the 300/2.8 or sell it and go with a 400/5.6?

Have fun with your 500's guys! (I'm so jealous!)
Jan 14, 2011 at 04:45 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister