fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20105D II or A850/A900

  
 
h00ligan
Offline
Details
p.2 #15D II or A850/A900
Sorry, I guess I mean more traditional design than branded pas lenses. it wasn't intended to be inflammatory..the main thing is, to use zeiss in other dslr requires mf..but not so for the Sony?

I have yet to figure out what all the zeiss letter designations mean too..

Edited on Nov 29, 2010 at 12:03 PM · View previous versions
Nov 29, 2010 at 12:01 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #25D II or A850/A900
Päivää Sami,
both Canon and Sony have their merits as you know. Which merits appeal to you is a decision only you can make.

I went from Canon 5D and 135/2L to Sony A900 and ZA135/1.8. I did not expect the lens to be better, but I was wrong. The files from Sony and the 135 were stunning, much more so than with the Canon 5D/135L combo. And they were not too bad either.

From a landscape photography point of view I am never going back to Canon, it was hopeless trying to translate hues/nuances back to natural colors. I have been working full time with digital photos but I found Canon files took too much time to make them look good and often I would lose track of my perception of what the scene looked like along the way. Sony files have been much easier to work with and I am happy for that part. It saves me a lot of time. Unfortunately I have had NO time this year (except for an excursion to Canada earlier this summer) for either photography or even postprocessing the back log. Ironic.

The higher ISO capability of Canon weighs heavy for some people but it does not make or break the deal for me anyway. With the A900 viewfinder I have never had the need for Live View, whatever the subject/distance. Even though my eyes are not as accurate as they've been the A900 viewfinder is much better than on any Canon camera I have tried. The 5D was not very good in that regard.

Sony on parempi, but the lens selection is limited which only is a problem if you need lenses that are not in the line up.

/ Henrik, asuun Tukholmasta.

Nov 29, 2010 at 12:02 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #35D II or A850/A900
h00ligan wrote:
Sorry, I guess I mean more traditional design than branded pas lenses. it wasn't intended to be inflammatory..the main thing is, to use zeiss in other dslr requires mf..but not so for the Sony?


No, I did not take it as inflammatory at all, just curious what you meant.

Yes, the interchangeable AF Zeiss lenses for 35mm only are available for the Sony system. Curiously, they are very modern and new designs, unlike the Zeiss manual focus lenses whose designs have been around for a while and could thus be considered more traditional from an optical design point of view.
Nov 29, 2010 at 12:05 PM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.2 #45D II or A850/A900
Utahlefty wrote:
FWIW, re: A850 vs. A900

I don't believe the price difference is large enough to justify missing out on the dual processors / full functionality of the A900. I'd only consider the A900 v. 5DII.


I don't really care about the higher burst rate of the A900. What else would I need the dual processors for?
On the other hand, the A850 has some small improvements to the sensor architecture.
Nov 29, 2010 at 12:44 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #55D II or A850/A900
AhamB wrote:
On the other hand, the A850 has some small improvements to the sensor architecture.


What improvements are these?
Nov 29, 2010 at 12:58 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #65D II or A850/A900
theSuede has mentioned in the past that the "botched" powerlines to the A900 sensor were fixed in the A850.

Also, as far as dual processors and performance, there's a chance that then A850 is simply software limited. There was a thread a few weeks ago on dyxum where a guy had A900 firmware loaded on his A850, and, voila, 5 fps.
Nov 29, 2010 at 01:13 PM
Utahlefty
Offline
Details
p.2 #75D II or A850/A900
that wouldn't surprise me at all -- IIRC, the idea of the A850 was to quickly compete on price with the 5D (without deploying a whole new camera AND not torquing off existing A900 owners)
Nov 29, 2010 at 01:41 PM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.2 #85D II or A850/A900
Tariq Gibran wrote:
AhamB wroteOn the other hand, the A850 has some small improvements to the sensor architecture.
What improvements are these?


They were discussed in your own thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/847088/0
Nov 29, 2010 at 01:42 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #95D II or A850/A900
douglasf13 wrote:
theSuede has mentioned in the past that the "botched" powerlines to the A900 sensor were fixed in the A850.

Also, as far as dual processors and performance, there's a chance that then A850 is simply software limited. There was a thread a few weeks ago on dyxum where a guy had A900 firmware loaded on his A850, and, voila, 5 fps.


Interesting though I would like to see proof so to speak. If this is the case, perhaps it could contribute to better high ISO performance withe the a850?
Nov 29, 2010 at 01:42 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #105D II or A850/A900
AhamB wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
AhamB wroteOn the other hand, the A850 has some small improvements to the sensor architecture.
What improvements are these?
They were discussed in your own thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/847088/0



Ha!
Nov 29, 2010 at 01:43 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #115D II or A850/A900
douglasf13 wrote:
theSuede has mentioned in the past that the "botched" powerlines to the A900 sensor were fixed in the A850.

Also, as far as dual processors and performance, there's a chance that then A850 is simply software limited. There was a thread a few weeks ago on dyxum where a guy had A900 firmware loaded on his A850, and, voila, 5 fps.



So, here is what theSuede said in my own thread from a year ago. Thanks to AhamB for pointing that out.

"One of the major reasons that the A850 is better at higer ISO's than the A900 is that they reinforced the botched and underdimensioned powersupply lines going into the sensor. The support structure around the chip is totally different from the D3x implementation."

By the way, in that same thread theSuede estimates that the noise difference between the a900/850 is probably only 1/10 ev and not noticeable. The thread also covers color nuances so is very good reading for potential a900/850 buyers.
Nov 29, 2010 at 02:05 PM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.2 #125D II or A850/A900
Yes, that's why I said a "small" improvement.
It's indeed an interesting thread. Too bad that there didn't come any feedback on the custom LR/ACR profiles done by TheSuede.
Nov 29, 2010 at 02:40 PM
RZetter
Offline
Details
p.2 #135D II or A850/A900
kosmoskatten wrote:
...
Sony on parempi, but the lens selection is limited which only is a problem if you need lenses that are not in the line up.

/ Henrik, asuun Tukholmasta.



Almost there. You don't live from Stockholm, but in Stockholm: Tukholmassa.

Hälsningar både på svenska ja suomeksi from a Swedish-speaking Finn.
Nov 29, 2010 at 02:43 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #145D II or A850/A900
Ahh, somehow it felt wrong writing it. Kiitos för educating me on that.

Nov 29, 2010 at 03:05 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.2 #155D II or A850/A900
AhamB wrote:
Utahlefty wroteFWIW, re: A850 vs. A900

I don't believe the price difference is large enough to justify missing out on the dual processors / full functionality of the A900. I'd only consider the A900 v. 5DII.
I don't really care about the higher burst rate of the A900. What else would I need the dual processors for?
On the other hand, the A850 has some small improvements to the sensor architecture.


The A850 does have the dual processors, this has been confirmed at Dyxum.

There are significant questions as to what exactly is the difference between the two models aside from the OVF spec. There's actually at least one confirmed 5fps A850 on Dyxum (looks like its a mix of A900 parts but it has an A850 outer shell and viewfinder and definitely does 5fps).

Most likely the only real differences are in the viewfinder (the A900's OVF is extremely complex to calibrate, the A850's 98% finder requires less rigorous calibration, as these must be hand calibrated there's a big difference in assembly costs) and software.
Nov 29, 2010 at 05:38 PM
chrisnyee
Offline
Details
p.2 #165D II or A850/A900
I know I'm joining in a bit late, but I figure some extra opinions couldn't hurt. I shoot with an A850 right now, Konica-Minolta 17-35 2.8-4, Minolta 50mm 1.7, and ZA 135 f/1.8

The Zeiss is out of this world with the A850, and I have shot nothing like it. The only issue that you may have sometimes with it is that it can get some CA's here and there in high contrast situations. But the lens is almost unforgivingly sharp. Portraits when you go 1:1 which is ridiculous with 24 MP and this lens, you see every last pore and imperfection on a person's face. I don't normally pixel peep, but when I first got the set up, who doesn't?

The other lenses are definitely not on par with the Zeiss, but are no slouches either.

I tested out the ZA 85mm as well, but found the 135 was a better performer, and also the FL was more to my liking. I made the choice of going for the 135. If the budget allows however, go for it. Just because I say the 135 was better, doesn't mean the ZA 85 was poor by any means.

I am considering swapping out the KM 17-35 for the Zeiss 16-35 one day, another fine performer, but as a college student it isn't in the budget just yet.

Personally for me, I choose Sony because the ergonomics, coming from Nikon were much more familiar and comfortable to me. Canon feels far more foreign, and when you are shooting, being comfortable with your camera is everything.

I would recommend getting in touch with your local Sony Alpha rep if you can (I used to work at a camera store so I knew him and got him to bring in all sorts of fun gear. He brought in an A900, essentially the whole ZA lineup that was out at the time, and many other stellar Sony lenses like the 70-400. ) I'm sure if you can get a hold of one, he or she would love to give you a little introduction to the Sony lineup. Same goes with Canon, if you can do so.

As far as what I understand in the differences between the A900 (don't have one, but have used one) and the A850 is the 5 fps vs 3 fps and the 100% vs 98% VF respectively. The prism apparently is a different part, i.e. cheaper. (would have to dig through dyxum to find the exact info)

If you are curious I may be able to upload a 100% crop or two from the ZA 135 if you are interested. I know when I first saw the images when I was just messing around, they blew me away.

The one drawback I find with Sony, at least for the older models (don't know how the newer, more consumer oriented models go) is that the AF performance is not as good for fast motion and action as when I shot with Nikon. If I ever shoot the occasional sports event, like basketball I am not the happiest person in the world, but I that is not what this camera is mainly used for so I can deal with it. Low light can sometimes be another issue.
Haven't shot with the 5DMKII enough to say how it compares.
Nov 29, 2010 at 08:42 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #175D II or A850/A900
Yes, Mawz, that was my understanding also - the 100% VF is very time-consuming and costly to assemble over the A850 VF. I would also quibble that the cost difference is something to look past - in my (online) market the difference is 25% the price of the A900.

Anyone coming from Nikon will be very pleased with the Sonys' ergonomics - very intelligent choice of what needs to be at hand and what can be relegated to the menus.

Nov 29, 2010 at 09:01 PM
cputeq
Offline
Details
p.2 #185D II or A850/A900
I shot with the A850 for a while, nice camera if you plan to do landscape stuff or portraiture with nice primes. I had the CZ 24-70 and while a great lens, I'm not sure it was up to snuff in delivering all the resolution the A850 was capable of.

That said, the price difference and stat similarities make the A900 almost redundant - Might as well save yourself some cash and get the A850 unless you really need the 5 FPS.


Great camera for its intended uses, but it was just too noisy for my tastes (as I found myself shooting in the 400-800 ISO range and losing resolution to noise) and freaking mirror slap (which was holy crap loud and weird sounding - "chu-chunk"). Shooting the A850 then my wife's D90 was like shooting a howitzer then a dart gun

I've seen great stuff coming from the A850/900, especially with the CZ primes - if I had the cash I'd rebuy the setup with a collection of primes and enjoy some serious tripod work.

(though after having started using live view for landscape stuff --- not having it really sucks! A great, great OVF can only get you so far with some landscape shots)

Nov 29, 2010 at 10:12 PM
chrisnyee
Offline
Details
p.2 #195D II or A850/A900
Not a replacement, but the A850/900 have Intelligent preview. Which is kind of nice to have at the very least.

On a more personal note, curious to see a swap from an A850 to an E-5. How do you like the 4/3 system? The one intriguing factor with olympus is the amazing weather proofing they have done with their cameras. Would be great outdoors not having to worry in the slightest about the wet. When it starts to rain more than a light drizzle I put a plastic bag over the Sony
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:19 PM
cputeq
Offline
Details
p.2 #205D II or A850/A900
chrisnyee wrote:
Not a replacement, but the A850/900 have Intelligent preview. Which is kind of nice to have at the very least.

On a more personal note, curious to see a swap from an A850 to an E-5. How do you like the 4/3 system? The one intriguing factor with olympus is the amazing weather proofing they have done with their cameras. Would be great outdoors not having to worry in the slightest about the wet. When it starts to rain more than a light drizzle I put a plastic bag over the Sony


Overall I like the system. There's actually a lot going for the 4/3 system as a whole and I'll have to grudgingly give credit to the crazy guys in the Canon forum for implanting the bug in my head to even *consider* Olympus when I asked about cameras a while back.

To be more accurate, I actually swapped from A850 to D700 to E-5
Since you asked about the Sony, though, I'll relate what I can remember about the systems, especially regarding vs one another:

Flash performance - This is something I simply could not get used to out of the A850. For whatever reason, the camera would do its damnedest to protect every single highlight in a scene forever and ever amen. This mean, of course, that a lot of my photos with flash would be seriously underexposed, and I'd see a tiny trail of 1-pixel-high white line heading off into the right side of the histogram

But because of the A850's rear LCD (for some strange reason), my photos would look great on the LCD...Pull up the RAW (or JPEG) on the PC, though, and dark dark dark. I'm pretty sure it was a setting in the Sony menu that would allow me to get around this over-protection of highlights, but I could never get it to work "nikon-consistently" and found myself having to juggle EV comp all the time with the flash. Freaking annoying.

The Olympus System - Works a bit more how I'm used to from Nikon, except for up-close stuff - the Oly system seems to over-expose when you're doing close photography (a few feet or less). I find myself typically dialing in -3EV comp on the flash, bounced from 8ft ceilings. This is only for the close-ups, though.

Autofocus -- I never did much AF-C with the Sony so I'll compare AF-S: Sony wins in low light, which is also born out in Pop Photo AF timed tests. Using center points.

Oly is great with the 14-54 II in decent light, but head indoors at night and watch your lens stair-step like a Pentax K20D. Even with the 50-200, AF can be hesitant. Really depressing and one of the only real drawbacks to Oly (besides lacking primes). AF-C with the Oly and the 50-200 (SWD) is also too slow for my tastes, though I've been giving it some pretty difficult tests.

Weathersealing - Took the A850 out in some decently heavy snow and it worked fine with the CZ 24-70, though I was fairly nervous about the melting snow and kept wiping it down fairly often, the lens more than the camera.

Took the E-5 and my 14-54 out in a straight-up rain (not a wimpy drizzle but not a Biblical flood, but a good rain) and no problems. I have no qualms about taking it outside when it's nasty. You can see the weather sealing working on the lens because when you retract/extend the zooms, you notice the gaskets pushing the water/dust up towards the front of the lens. I still wipe occasionally to be sure, though.

Colors from the camera - Skin tones, Sony (but Oly are very good). Landscape, Oly. yeah yeah, people say you can match colors from camera bodies and shooting RAW makes this a moot point, but I have to disagree. I can usually tell my Nikon files from my Sony ones, especially the greens (I have a really hard time getting greens, and sometimes blues, that I like from Nikon).

Noise - You've got a fairly noisy A850 compared to a fairly noisy 4/3 sensor. Tie

Other stuff

Live view - Oly's is pretty nice, A850 lacks this. A850's intelli-preview is actually really neat and I liked it, but it's not a perfect substitute.

Ergo - Sony. I hate Oly's arrow placement on the back. A850's joystick rocks.

Mirror slap - Oly by a mile

IBIS - Both seems to do pretty well, so I can't really comment. I initially thought the A850's "shake meter" was kinda neat but I found myself paying more attention to that damned graph than my shot so I started to ignore it

Flip LCD - pretty darn useful when I need it, especially low-low landscape that I don't feel like configuring my tripod for.

AF tuning - Never needed it with my A850. Oly's method is awesome, as it accounts for different values on a zoom. This is badass, and it can be customized per AF point.

Viewfinder - Really no contest, A850 by a mile. Not to say the E-5 is bad...I'd put it around D300 levels, but the A850 is just amazing.

Lenses - A850 primes, Oly zooms. Oly's glass is truly spectacular - almost prime-like quality from their HG zooms. Very impressive stuff and highly flexible. The 14-54 II and my 50-200 both have around 0.5x macro performance, not too shabby. Both sharp wide open at any aperture. Both take the 1.4x TC very well, and now I have a ~586mm birding setup at f/4.9 wide open (though at f/5.6 I can't tell there's a TC on the lens).

Oly loses the game at the primes, though. It's really annoying my only real "50mm" option is the $1000 Pan/Leica 25mm f/1.4 I mean, yes it's a Leica and I'm sure it's awesome, but c'mon Oly, wtf?

Overall great systems both, but the Oly was more of an experiment after selling off my D700 and I like it a lot. Not perfect of course, but it's pretty nice.








Nov 29, 2010 at 11:22 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister