fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20105D II or A850/A900

  
 
Sami Ruusunen
Offline

p.1 #15D II or A850/A900
I need some opinions from users who have used or tested both Canon and Sony systems. My issue is that I need to get a FF system with 3 or 4 lenses since I need to move a lot with my equipment and I dont want to carry more weight. 3 lenses are must have for me from the beginning:

Wide angle zoom for shooting exhibitions, venues and landscapes
- I would like to use prime but its simply impossible to use it on exhibition photographs (most of my income will be coming from exhibitions so this is important)
- I shoot sometimes in low light, so IS is a plus but not mandatory
- on travels I shoot landscapes which will be printed 75 or 100cm wide

About 85mm tele for portraits, nude shots, low-dof-artistic shots and landscapes mostly
- needs to be great wide open and also sharp stopped down since it will be used to landscapes too
- must have af since I will be sometimes shooting fast moving subjects, but needs to be well controlled also in manual focus

about 135mm for portraits and close up shots
- must have af since I will be sometimes shooting fast moving subjects, but needs to be well controlled also in manual focus

basic fast 50mm MF lens (optional)

So, my options are probably:

Canon 5D mk II
16-35/2.8 L
Zeiss ZE 50/1.4 (optional)
Sigma 85/1.4 or Contax N 85/1.4
Canon 135/2 L

or

Sony A850/A900
Zeiss ZA 16-35/2.8
Zeiss ZS 50/1.4 (optional)
Zeiss ZA 85/1.4
Zeiss ZA 135/1.8

Nikon is out of my radar since D700 dont have enough resolution for large prints and D3X is too big.

What I am interested in:
- How does the 5Dmk2 and A850/A900 compare, specially their autofocus and handing in generally?
- Sony dont have liveview so do I need to get focusing screens for critical close up shots and landscapes?
- How does the equivalent lenses compare and would you get some other lens instead for that purpose?
- How does the Sonys IBIS compare to 5D2:s better ISO perfomance when shooting in low light.

What I am not interested in:
- how many lenses there are on market for both systems since I can see that myself from the shop. I will never need long teles or TS-lenses I try to keep my package simple.

Thank you in advance, all help will be appreciated.
Nov 28, 2010 at 05:13 PM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.1 #25D II or A850/A900
I have not tried Canon system, but I can answer the Sony liveview question:

I never have any problem at close up WO shot with my 50/1.2 with or without the M screen (matte screen for manual focus). It's the near infinity WO shot would throw me off. But for most landscape, you need to stop down a lot, so I don't think it would be a problem at all.

As for the other questions, I can speculate based on what I've read. IQ-wise, the ZA is better than the Sigma, and a bit better than the L lens. The Sigma will focus faster than the ZA 85, so will the Canon 135 compared to the ZA 135. 16-35 range would be a tie I think.

There will be a firmware update for the A900, so you'll have to wait a bit to see if there is any ISO improvement. Other than that, careful exposure and good raw converter can bring them quite close.
Nov 28, 2010 at 05:31 PM
Utahlefty
Offline
Details
p.1 #35D II or A850/A900
my experiences with the Zeiss ZA 85 & 135 are that they are better than *any* other brand's comparable offering at the moment .

I think the ZA 24-70 is a little stronger than the ZA 16-35 in terms of IQ, but the 16-35 is a wash compared to the Canon L.

the 50mm is a current weak spot for the Sony system.

I prefer the A900 body to the Canon 5D in terms of ergonomics, and the in-body IS works well.

The A900 vs. Canon 5D are on par up to ISO 800, above that Sony loses ground rapidly, so take that into consideration (as well as lack of live view if that's important to you).
Nov 28, 2010 at 06:42 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.1 #45D II or A850/A900
FWIW, I owned the A900 and some ZA lenses, and the Sony 50/1.4 was still my most used lens. Although it is a bit soft wide open, I think it is excellent from f2 on. It is a no brainer for a few hundred bucks.
Nov 28, 2010 at 06:49 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.1 #55D II or A850/A900
i don't have much personal experience with either camera other than just trying out a friends for a day, however i have been researching this myself for nearly a year (coming to the conclusion that neither fits my needs and i should just wait for the next models).

- af should be faster with the canon and sigmas (except maybe for the 16-35mm).
- sony lenses should perform a bit better optically, but i doubt it would be a huge margin. it really is too bad nikon hasn't released a non pro high mp body, because the 14-24mm seems to blow away both 16-35mm lenses.
- i personally find focusing landscape shots with live view to consistently result in sharper images on average than hyperfocal focusing, split prism focusing, autofocusing, or matte screen manual focusing. the sony viewfinder is quite a bit better than the canon (with or without the precision screen).
- at focal lengths you are looking at you should be able to count on getting an extra 2 stops of slower shutter speed with IBIS. But this won't stop motion obviously. this is a great help in the intermediate low light region where it allows you to shoot in the below iso 800 range that sony excels at, in extreme low light you probably won't be happy with your results from either camera.
- obviously there are a lot more canon lenses available than sony/minolta lenses so it's probably worth looking at the areas you think you might add a lens or to to see what is available.
- another interesting lens to look at for sony is the 135 STF for portraits.
- if you into using nikkor, OM, k-mount, leica R, or contax lenses they are much easier to adapt to canon then sony, but, there are a bunch of great lenses that have mirror conflicts with canon that do not with sony, alt lenses are stabilized on the sony body, and leitax offers easy mount conversions to sony for most of the brands i listed.
- you might also consider a different ~50mm lens: the rokkor 58mm f/1.2, nikkor 50mm f/1.2 AIS, takumar 50mm f/1.4, and the sigma 50mm f/1.4 will probably all outperform the zeiss 50/1.4 for everything except landscape. the rokkor and maybe the takumar could have mirror issues on the canon but not the sony.
Nov 28, 2010 at 06:58 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.1 #65D II or A850/A900
Another lurker who has been evaluating both systems but owns neither, two points to add to your thoughts - or maybe you've already had them.

- Since using a camera with a good live-view system I've come to realize just how much I've hated DSLR AF systems and MF in a OVF (even with a split prism). For me, tripod mounted landscape work is far better served by a live-view system. Obviously OVF is superior for many types of photography, but for landscapes I now consider it a useless feature (I'm sure some would strongly disagree).

- Be aware people hold some strong opinions with regards to the Canon vs. Sony sensors in base ISO performance with regards to DR, color, and banding issues. I don't have any relevant experience, but if you haven't already search around and see what you find. There are threads on 5DmkII vs. 850 about once a week here.

Sorry I don't have anything more useful for you. Perhaps just my bump of your thread will be more useful than what I had to say .

Ken
Nov 28, 2010 at 07:16 PM
Chris48
Offline
Details
p.1 #75D II or A850/A900
I have the 5D but don't have the 5D2, so can't answer Q1.

Q2. The A900/850's OVF is excellent and in my experience is on par with many classic film cameras, much better than the 5D and I guess also better than the 5D2. But in dim lights MF could be difficult, as usual. The M screen is better than the stock screen and helps a bit. But overall, for the lenses you need, I think manual focus should be quite doable.

Q3. The ZA 17-35 is better than the 16-35II L, especially on the wider end. The ZE 50/1.4 is the same as the ZS 50/1.4. The ZA 85/1.4 is very similar to the 85/1.4 N but you get the factory AF. Don't know about the Sigma 85/1.4. The ZA85, stopped down is sharp from corner to corner and excellent for landscape. But generally speaker, a mid tele with a smaller aperture would be better for landscape. Sony have a new 85/2.8 coming out. It's said to be based on the Z 85/2.8 Sonnar design. It's cheap too. The ZA 135/1.8 and 135/2 L are both exceptional and except for the critical pixel peepers, they are on par. If you go with Sony, you can actually consider the Sony SA 50/1.4 (old Minolta design) instead of the ZS 50/1.4. While both are exceptional performers (with perhaps the ZS slightly better) but some people prefer the SA and you gain AF and its cheaper. If distortion control and sharpness is critical, the SA 50/2.8 Macro is even better.

Q4. I don't use IBIS so can't answer.
Nov 28, 2010 at 07:29 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.1 #85D II or A850/A900
I went from a 5D to the a900 so I don't have direct experience with the 5DII. The a900 AF is dramatically better then the AF on the original 5D. I don't know if the 5DII has improved AF over the original 5D though. The optical viewfinder on the a900 is again a dramatic improvement over that of the 5D. Not only does it offer 100% accuracy but the acuity/ clarity is much better, particularly noticeable when using manual focus lenses. With Sony you of course get in body stabilization with all lenses, something I often use with wide angles and documentary work. The build quality of the a900 body is also of a higher standard in my opinion. I have made landscape exhibition prints up to 52" wide with the a900 so you would have no issue with the sizes your considering depending on the lens used. Those are the positives of course.

From what I have seen, the 5DII will offer dramatically better high ISO performance. I think that is the biggest plus for the 5DII. We will have to wait to see what the forthcoming a900 firmware does but I just can't imagine it will be magic and give the same results of the 5DII. I would not take the a900 above ISO 800 when shooting in theatre lighting so if you shoot at ISO 1600 or above, that is something to consider.
Nov 28, 2010 at 08:39 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.1 #95D II or A850/A900
A900 vs 5D2: The most notable difference, apart from what has been already said by others, is that the A900 files look deep, almost heavy.They have a certain analog look not too far from chrome film. 5D2 files are more transparent, or light, which also can be appealing, depending on your taste.

I don't buy into the high iso noise theory. On the A900 you can completely turn off NR, while on the 5D2 the camera still does NR on the hardware level (and possibly in the raw as well). I use Noise Ninja to clean up my files and the results are very good up to 1600 and very usable at 3200.

As for the lenses:

The ZA 16-35 is definitely better than the L.
The ZA 85 is probably the only 85mm out there that has been designed without any compromises when used wide open. The IQ even at f/1.4 is stellar.
The ZA 135 is even better.

As for the 50, I have owned the Sony and can attest to what Douglas has said above. I find it to give good 3D rendering, almost as good as a Zeiss. I use currently the ZS because I prefer its rendering style. My adapter has no chip, so it can only be used in manual, but the good news is that the firmware upgrade available from Dec 2 will allow me to use it in AV mode too.

The only reason I would buy a 5D2 would be to use the ZE line of lenses, but as the development of the ZA line continues, there will be less reason for me to do so.

There are 2 additional ZA lenses rumoured to be released in 2011, 200/2 and 35/2 (possibly 1.4 but less likely). I don't know if this is true, but I certainly hope so.

Nov 29, 2010 at 03:24 AM
johntodd
Offline
Details
p.1 #105D II or A850/A900
edwardkaraa wrote:
The ZA 85 is probably the only 85mm out there that has been designed without any compromises when used wide open. The IQ even at f/1.4 is stellar.


Is the ZA 85 a significantly different design than the ZE 85? When I looked at the OP`s suggested lineup, I wondered about the ZE 85 slotting in.
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:33 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.1 #115D II or A850/A900
johntodd wrote:
edwardkaraa wroteThe ZA 85 is probably the only 85mm out there that has been designed without any compromises when used wide open. The IQ even at f/1.4 is stellar.
Is the ZA 85 a significantly different design than the ZE 85? When I looked at the OP`s suggested lineup, I wondered about the ZE 85 slotting in.


The ZE 85 is based on the old Contax design. Optimized for infinity, it does not have floating elements to correct for short shooting distances, hence the somewhat long (1m) MFD. Below f/2.8 it produces the "dreamy" effect that may be used to good effect in portraiture.

The Contax N referred to by the OP was designed as a portrait lens with floating elements and soft image borders, and a special attention paid to out of focus blur.

The ZA is optimized for shooting wide open. It does not produce the hazy effect below f/2.8, in fact it is sharp across the frame corner to corner at f/1.4. It has floating elements for close range shooting. And the bokeh is beautiful, as good or better than the N in my opinion.
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:55 AM
Sami Ruusunen
Offline
Details
p.1 #125D II or A850/A900
Thanks for all the feedback and succestions, I think I really need to test both of the cameras before decicion what to do.
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:55 AM
Utahlefty
Offline
Details
p.1 #135D II or A850/A900
Sami Ruusunen wrote:
I think I really need to test both of the cameras before decicion what to do.


Yep!
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:57 AM
Sami Ruusunen
Offline
Details
p.1 #145D II or A850/A900
johntodd wrote:
edwardkaraa wroteThe ZA 85 is probably the only 85mm out there that has been designed without any compromises when used wide open. The IQ even at f/1.4 is stellar.
Is the ZA 85 a significantly different design than the ZE 85? When I looked at the OP`s suggested lineup, I wondered about the ZE 85 slotting in.


ZE 85 does not interest me at the moment, although it is very good stopped down at infinity. Its pretty crap wide open at close to MFD. Have tried it, didnt like it. Also like I said in first post I really need AF in some situations and dont want 2 different lenses for same focal lenght.
Nov 29, 2010 at 10:59 AM
Utahlefty
Offline
Details
p.1 #155D II or A850/A900
FWIW, re: A850 vs. A900

I don't believe the price difference is large enough to justify missing out on the dual processors / full functionality of the A900. I'd only consider the A900 v. 5DII.

YMMV.

Nov 29, 2010 at 11:09 AM
h00ligan
Offline
Details
p.1 #165D II or A850/A900
Silly question but I know nothing about sony's line of slr.. Fom what I read one actually gets 'real' zeiss glass with the Sony offering which is capable of af, not just mf. That seems like a pretty strong argument.
Nov 29, 2010 at 11:27 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.1 #175D II or A850/A900
Utahlefty wrote:
FWIW, re: A850 vs. A900

I don't believe the price difference is large enough to justify missing out on the dual processors / full functionality of the A900. I'd only consider the A900 v. 5DII.

YMMV.



I'm a bit perplexed by this comparison of the a850 to the a900. For instance, I knew about the frame coverage difference and higher FPS of the a900 but it surprises me that the a850 actually has a higher buffer size. Is this down to the higher FPS of the a900 or does the a850 have more memory for the buffer or an updated processor? Anyone know? Just curious because I fully expected to find the a850 had less of a buffer. Any difference between the two regarding weather sealing? Is the only other difference the viewfinder shutter? Seems like I recall the body material was said to be slightly different between the two.

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/sonydslra850/page2.asp
Nov 29, 2010 at 11:29 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.1 #185D II or A850/A900
h00ligan wrote:
Silly question but I know nothing about sony's line of slr.. Fom what I read one actually gets 'real' zeiss glass with the Sony offering which is capable of af, not just mf. That seems like a pretty strong argument.


What do you mean by 'real' out of curiosity?
Nov 29, 2010 at 11:30 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.1 #195D II or A850/A900
Tariq Gibran wrote:
Utahlefty wroteFWIW, re: A850 vs. A900

I don't believe the price difference is large enough to justify missing out on the dual processors / full functionality of the A900. I'd only consider the A900 v. 5DII.

YMMV.

I'm a bit perplexed by this comparison of the a850 to the a900. For instance, I knew about the frame coverage difference and higher FPS of the a900 but it surprises me that the a850 actually has a higher buffer size. Is this down to the higher FPS of the a900 or does the a850 have more memory for the buffer or an updated processor? Anyone know? Just curious because I fully expected to find the a850 had less of a buffer. Any difference between the two regarding weather sealing? Is the only other difference the viewfinder shutter? Seems
...Show more →

Nevermind, I see the difference of the buffer frames is due to the higher FPS of the a900 and does have the viewfinder shutter as well. At 3FPS, the a900 would be greater then the a850.
Nov 29, 2010 at 11:34 AM
Sami Ruusunen
Offline
Details
p.1 #205D II or A850/A900
Differences between a900 and a850 also interest me since the specs dont justify the price difference between those two for my use. Only slightly larger vf. I dont shoot action that much so slower buffer/fps not much of an issue. Somewhere was stated that a850 is slightly less weather sealed than a900, whatever than means. Although none of the lenses is weather sealed so not so important.
Nov 29, 2010 at 11:42 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister