fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast

  
 
jmcfadden
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
andrewd01 wrote:
jmcfadden wrote
andrewd01 wrote
jmcfadden wrote
Keith B. wroteOT: Oh, and on the subject of the $400 RCA cables for your stereo, remember that the connection between the $5000 microphone, the $2000 preamp, and the the $50,000 mixing desk in the million dollar recording studio is accomplished with a $19.95 XLR cable...although I will admit some studios have gone to the nicer $40 ones.
hah, It is nice to meet another audio guy. I owned a studio in Minneapolis, and was a engineer for over 30 years in live sound and studio as well as a performer and writer. I also had lots of tube gear for Hi Fi and in the studio. But seeing the kooks out there with 1000dollar "interconnects and 1000dollar speaker cables always made me smile

I feel the same way now about this issue, but I have more dollars in my pocket than they do in theirs and hey it's a free country

J
I would go as far as saying that upgrading to Kimber Select speaker cables is one of the most significant upgrades I have done. The impact on the system is unbelievable. You can hear the difference immediately. I am less convinced on interconnects, they make a subtle difference only.

Make up your mind with your own ears, but if you don't have an open mind you will never know what you are missing.
you missed my point or better yet i didn't make it well
before I try again , did you read the part of the post about the 20dollar mic cable? Have you ever made a record or produced one in a studio? Or built the actual room where the desk lived and soundproofed it? I can pretty much say my ears are good and i made a Lot of money off them for many decades
Now with that aside I do hear differences and when i do they are evaluated and the ones worthy of investment I have to pay the money for. There are LOTS of claims out there that don't add up to a hill of beans. 50,000dollar 10watt class A amps come to mind, 1000dollar speaker cables come to mind too. There is a term called diminishing returns, when I was in high end pro audio sales, clients would always ask me what was "best" ,and i never answered it directly. I Always asked them that they should satisfy about 85% of their requirements because to even get to 90% would mean about 60% more investment. talk of the next 10%borders on the sublime and downright silly
Your Kimber Cables qualify for the 85% BTW You are wrong about interconnects, well sorta "wrong" , it is complicated, you Must look at everything as a true "system" I am sure you use the term often but you never really understand the depth of it. I am not insulting you it is a very common thing and I am guilty of it in many ways too. But your rig is a true and real "system" not just a quickie "word" but a real almost living "thing". In a living thing everything has some impact on the whole , some things have more influence and others less , it is most likely your interconnects were adequate (think 85% again) and so whatever you bought to replace them that cost you more and did not produce a dramatic result may have disappointed you, but you felt redeemed by spending hard earned money on the Kimber Selects. Your previous cables were <85% type cables and therefore gave you a pronounced and worthwhile difference. The weakest link is where the first dollars go but if you buy ultra high end cable for a boom box what do you think you will have ? See at some point the sublime and silly can make a point.
As photographers we have it pretty easy, there are so few players in the game but i just give you one example of what i am really saying. Leica makes a point and shoot, oh but really it is a Panasonic with a little Leica badge on it and for that sublime pleasure how much extra does it cost for the same camera ? Get back to me on that one

J
No I didn't miss your point. Room acoustics etc are all valid points. Yes there are limitations on the original recordings. Get off your high horse!

I am not talking about my interpretation of "claims" read from third parties. I am talking about the differences I observed with my own ears on my own system. The differences were massive and more than enough to justify the cost.

Of course one needs to consider the context of the system when choosing cables, the rest of the system needs to be good enough.

Believe me I am tight and would not spend this sort of
...Show more →

I actually Validated your experience and offered explanation about why interconnects in Your rig didn't do for you what you had hoped and the speaker cables actually did In a different rig it could easily have been interconnects which were the weak link and where the best investment might be made. And I never ever doubted your anecdotal experience of hearing your rig sound markedly better once you brought your weaker link up to snuff

J
Sep 01, 2010 at 09:23 AM
Andre Labonte
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Jammy Straub wrote:
I prefer the smooth focusing helicoid and Italian leather in the Lambo.


That's fine, but you pay the price for that. Leather is leather in my book, whether US or Italian does not matter to me.

And why manual focus when I can auto focus? The only time I go manual is with macro work and only because I have to.
Sep 01, 2010 at 09:30 AM
Todd Adamson
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Erik Moore wrote:
Todd Adamson wroteWell, time for this thread to die, methinks.
You know, Hitler spent a lot of money on audio cables.

There. Now it's dead.


LMAO. Speaking of Hitler, I see John just posted a Swastika in the Best Nikon Shots thread.

Sep 01, 2010 at 10:13 AM
rsolti13
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Andre Labonte wrote:
Jammy Straub wroteI prefer the smooth focusing helicoid and Italian leather in the Lambo.
That's fine, but you pay the price for that. Leather is leather in my book, whether US or Italian does not matter to me.

And why manual focus when I can auto focus? The only time I go manual is with macro work and only because I have to.


Leather is leather until you feel italian leather It's like I say when people are vegetarians...they have just never had a really good Ruth's Chris prime ribeye...that will change your belief

Why manual focus....a couple reasons. One, accuracy. If you can see well and use live view the accuracy of manual focus is far better than relying on AF. I have seen several tests showing superior sharpness using MF vs AF even on AF lenses. Another reason for me (which I may be the minority b/c I am certainly no pro), but I feel I get better shots when using MF as I actually take the time to think about the shot and use the optimal settings. With AF, I go around like a tourist with a P&S. With MF, I actually take the time to think about how I want the shot to look in the end and use the right settings for it. Like I said, I am just an average amateur, so this may not apply to all, but it certainly does me.

That being said, it is not always possible to MF due to different reasons such as tracking (chasing a 3 yr old) or you just don't have the time for composing/using live view/etc. In those instances you go with the fastest focus possible.
Sep 01, 2010 at 10:30 AM
kawasakiguy37
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Honestly between the first two I prefer the Nikkor. But comparing the second two.....well isnt it odd how much the guys shirt changes in color?
Sep 01, 2010 at 10:53 AM
Todd Adamson
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
kawasakiguy37 wrote:
well isnt it odd how much the guys shirt changes in color?


That tends to happen when you change clothes.
Sep 01, 2010 at 10:57 AM
Berschwinger
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Todd Adamson wrote:
kawasakiguy37 wrotewell isnt it odd how much the guys shirt changes in color?
That tends to happen when you change clothes.


Sep 01, 2010 at 11:21 AM
Smiert Spionam
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
I'm not a true corksniffer, but I think I've got better eyes than the average bear (though this particular forest admittedly has some rather sophisticated bears).

I've looked at these pics on three different monitors, and I can't see any meaningful differences that I can attribute to the lenses used. As photographs, I think the closer versions of both work better (particularly in the second pair) -- but that has more to do with lighting, exposure, framing, and expression than any particular optical qualities.

The 35-y/o optics and coatings of the 135/2 have held up remarkably well. It would be interesting to see how the same Nikkor design would do with modern glass and coatings.
Sep 01, 2010 at 11:55 AM
Andre Labonte
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
rsolti13 wrote:
Andre Labonte wrote
Jammy Straub wroteI prefer the smooth focusing helicoid and Italian leather in the Lambo.
That's fine, but you pay the price for that. Leather is leather in my book, whether US or Italian does not matter to me.

And why manual focus when I can auto focus? The only time I go manual is with macro work and only because I have to.
Leather is leather until you feel italian leather It's like I say when people are vegetarians...they have just never had a really good Ruth's Chris prime ribeye...that will change your belief

Why manual focus....a couple reasons. One, accuracy. If you can see well and use live view the accuracy of manual focus is far better than relying on AF. I have seen several tests showing superior sharpness using MF vs AF even on AF lenses. Another reason for me (which I may be the minority b/c I am certainly no pro), but I feel I get better shots when
...Show more →

Forgive me if I'm still skeptical on the leather ... but then again I hate leather seats.

Good points on the AF part. I guess my opinion comes from my uses, kids and sports. I do manual focus for landscape and macro though.

Cheers,
Andre
Sep 01, 2010 at 12:01 PM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
'corksniffer'

All this talk of speaker cables I could never justify buying has me wanting to build speakers again. I made this budget home theater system and it hits well above it's price point.
http://www.parts-express.com/projectshowcase/dht/index.cfm

I've often desired to build my own tube amp and speakers.

Is anyone braiding speaker cable from CAT5 anymore?
http://www.venhaus1.com/diycatfivecables.html

Sooo about that Nikkor...
Sep 01, 2010 at 02:21 PM
Zebrabot
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Jammy Straub wrote:
'corksniffer'

[junk cut]

Is anyone braiding speaker cable from CAT5 anymore?
http://www.venhaus1.com/diycatfivecables.html

Sooo about that Nikkor...


I can braid you a custom speaker cable for $1200.00 foot. My power cords are $600/foot +$500 for the ends. Don't settle for plenum grade ethernet cables, I only use aerospace spec cables. Rhodium plated contacts are an extra $5000 per end.

I assure you it will sound better than any amateur nonsense on that website.



Sep 01, 2010 at 04:12 PM
hidden_Markov
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
rsolti13 wrote:

Why manual focus....a couple reasons. One, accuracy. If you can see well and use live view the accuracy of manual focus is far better than relying on AF. I have seen several tests showing superior sharpness using MF vs AF even on AF lenses. Another reason for me (which I may be the minority b/c I am certainly no pro), but I feel I get better shots when using MF as I actually take the time to think about the shot and use the optimal settings. With AF, I go around like a tourist with a P&S. With MF,
...Show more →


Bout sums it up. MF does tend to make you frame a shot differently I do find.

Also is a cost or performance issue. With alot of the Nikkor AI(S) glass, it opens some very nice glass options that are cheaper. And some AI(S) out there....makes you wish nikkor would bring these engineers out of retirement cause they made glass of equal or even better quality based on 1970's and 1980's technology.

Case of zeiss and voigtlander....a different knd of perfomance and cost issue. They rip out AF leaving the inner lens body more open to do other things. Zeiss optical builds give you the 3d effect and the better colors they are known for. Looking at voigtlander you get very nice glass in a very small package. 40mm been catching some people's eyes in another thread. Nikkor took pancakes off the menu a few years back, for those who like them, MF gives them options. The 40 is interesting tbh...also the 20mm. If I come across them on my trip next week, I'll find the time to try them out.
Sep 01, 2010 at 05:08 PM
Erik Moore
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Zebrabot wrote:
I can braid you a custom speaker cable for $1200.00 foot. My power cords are $600/foot +$500 for the ends. Don't settle for plenum grade ethernet cables, I only use aerospace spec cables. Rhodium plated contacts are an extra $5000 per end.

I assure you it will sound better than any amateur nonsense on that website.


I was just wondering... do you have anything useful to contribute?
Sep 01, 2010 at 07:41 PM
tjny
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
some wicked three d shots,rsolti13
Sep 01, 2010 at 08:46 PM
Zebrabot
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Erik Moore wrote:
Zebrabot wroteI can braid you a custom speaker cable for $1200.00 foot. My power cords are $600/foot +$500 for the ends. Don't settle for plenum grade ethernet cables, I only use aerospace spec cables. Rhodium plated contacts are an extra $5000 per end.

I assure you it will sound better than any amateur nonsense on that website.
I was just wondering... do you have anything useful to contribute?


Do you enjoy being brittle?
Sep 01, 2010 at 10:16 PM
dj dunzie
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Just a Zeiss 100/f2 M-P shot from a dreary day around here...

http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m70/dj_dunzie/Misc%20Photography/U_D3S_1862.jpg
Sep 06, 2010 at 03:56 PM
dj dunzie
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Sep 06, 2010 at 04:00 PM
Todd Adamson
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
Nice shots, DJ, especially the first. Are you liking the 100 MP? Any issues? Still getting good green dot confirmation?

I'm near giving up on mine. Too much inconsistency, especially if the subject is over 5 feet away. Sending it into Zeiss USA tomorrow; they've agreed to test it on their Nikon bodies and advise. If they tell me the lens is fine, I'm going to concede the lens is "too good for me" and sell it.
Sep 06, 2010 at 04:09 PM
dj dunzie
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
I'm actually loving it. I really like the handling on this lens, and my focus seems to be as good or better than any of my MF Nikkors, both by VF "feel" and by the green dot confirmation. Hopefully Zeiss can get yours sorted out!
Sep 06, 2010 at 04:23 PM
Todd Adamson
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Focal Length Compression vs. Microcontrast
DJ, how's the damping on your focus ring? Hard to turn, or about right, compared to the classic Nikkors?
Sep 06, 2010 at 09:22 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister