Coltrane wrote:
grantgoodes wrote
I purchased an 85/1.4D IF after owning the AiS version for several years -- in fact it was my first AF-Nikkor. I never really did a close comparison of the two lenses (would be very easy on my Df), but my casual estimation was that the "cream machine" moniker applied for either. The AF-D-IF version is a 9/8 design while the AiS is 7/5. Also, as an IF lens, there is focal-length shift as you focus in. So, I'd expect that there _will_ be differences in the rendering of these two lenses. I have both the AIS and D versions of the 85mm 1.4 and did a comparison earlier this year. The bokeh was very similar with the D being a bit smoother. The biggest difference was the sharpness at 1.4 where the D had slightly better center sharpness and the AIS had much better edge and corner sharpness. Stopped down, center sharpness becomes even, but the D never quite catches up to the AIS with the corners and edges.
My comparisons of the two 85/1.4 lenses were more casual, but I would concur that my impression was that the AiS version gave a little bit more overall sharpness wide-open. I'm not the biggest Bokeh guy (despite this lens being the "cream machine"!), so didn't actually notice the difference you highlight. Overall, I kind of prefer the AiS just because of how badass it looks: A true mechanical gem from the heyday of Nikkor lenses. Also the AF-D goes from 72mm to 77mm filters and has a simply gigantic hood, so aside from the fact that it is AF (resulting in more in-focus shots in low-light/concert shots), I really prefer the shooting experience with the AiS version.