James Markus wrote:
Rafael,
They both look excellent to me with the edge seemly going to the 800mm f5.6. I have always liked Great Egrets, but the dazzling white of their plumage makes getting the correct exposure a challenge.
Jim
rafaelcasd wrote
The egret came back again, this is almost a daily occurrence. She seems to like hunting for lizards or the occasional rodent here.
This Time I used the 400mm 3.5 EDIF ais and TC 300 combo to take the pictures.
My observation is that this 800mm combo does not have equal quality to the 800mm 5.6 EDIF ais; competent combo but not as sharp, not as smooth OOF, and showing minor color aberrations not corrected by the camera.
James, the 400mm 3.5 was fully open and the quality was excellent, closing it down to f/8 makes it much better. I would not hesitate to get a 400mm 3.5 for less than $1K plus the old TC 14 and 300 for $100 each to get a high quality 400mm 3.5, 560 mm 5.0 and 800mm 7.1. Heck, adding a TC16a modified to work with the D series cameras gets you a high quality auto focusing 640mm 5.6!!!
The 800mm 5.6 is better than any of these combinations but not by a lot, and it will set you back at least $2,500.
Highlights do burn on these egrets under sunlight, but the 800mm keeps the edges of the burned area quite sharp as shown in the last photo.