Hi Ben,
Love your photos. Especially love the one in question. Of course, do what you wish, but I like the pole. It made me look at the
photo several times. To my vision, I like the way it bifurcates the image almost making it into a diptych.
Anyway, good shooting.
regards,
Joe D
Andy - I thought of removing the pole but.......remember the discussion from a few pages back about manipulating images vs integrity etc .....well, that stopped me. Normally, I would tend to favour the photo itself and not worry too much about the integrity, but I'm torn about it. One part of me thinks that a photo is a photo and what is ......is.......and should left as it is. Reality sometimes has hidden beauty and some element in a pic that you may not like at first may reveal its beauty later or it may never appeal to you but it might be the very thing that really appeals to someone else. That has happened often to me. Something that I didn't like in one of my own photos originally ends up looking very different to me a year or two later. You just never know. And of course, I'm constantly surprised by what other people see and like in my pics. They often like pics that I hate and vice versa. That is one reason to leave everything in.
But I don't know, I haven't come to a conclusion about it, as I said, I'm torn. She is a chestnut seller, that is her set up, and that pole (it's an umbrella pole) is huge and very bright. I toned down the brightness because it overwhelmed the pic but I couldn't bring myself to take it out altogether, although from an aesthetic point of view, I agree, I'd rather it wasn't there.
More importantly, congrats on the sensational MCG shot, so good, a wonderful use of that lens.
ben