fredmiranda.com Login

Manual Focus Nikon Glass

  
 
GeorgeBo
Offline
Details
p.1469 #1Manual Focus Nikon Glass
kwoodard wrote:
GeorgeBo wrote
leighton w wrote
AM4L wrote
GeorgeBo wrote
AM4L wroteI could use a little help and input from my friends here; if you were buying a new camera today to use with your Nikkor MF lenses, what would you recommend and why?

Here are my wants, as close a match as possible to use full quality of the lens, Top quality IBIS, Focus Peaking, body like Fuji's XT-4, it needs to be solid and well made and comfortable in hands. If its not the ZII series then it needs a great adapter.

Caveats, I have been looking at the XT-4 and the Z7II, but I think a Z6 II would work as well. As you may remember, I have a boat load of MF glass (see profile). I sold my X-pro 2 yesterday, and my Z7 goes up on the e block next, then my D500. I plan to have my D850 plus this camera I will buy as my two cameras. I do have a Metabones F to X converter still. This is very much about MF glass.. I barely even used my Z7, really didn't like it much, if it had IBIS I might have used it a lot more.

If you prefer to answer PM, that works too. I am sure this is a question many of you faced and already answered so I figure i could benefit from the groups wisdom!
Unless I am missing something the Z7 has IBIS.

My question to you is, how much do you want to capture the "characteristics" of these old lenses. I mean corner vignetting, edge softness, etc. Some say flaws, I say character My point being, using these lenses on a crop sensor just gives them a different feel. Now Leighton is doing outstanding stuff using a Speedbooster/Focal Reducer on his Fuji X camera and gives almost full frame field of view.

But since you had the X-Pro2 I am sure you are already aware of that.

I will let others chime in on the full frame Z stuff, and Ben is using a "C word" camera.

Not sure what the Z7II will give over the Z7... I guess real vertical grip option, 2 memory cards and some video enhancements I think.

Just thinking out loud.
yup, I forgot about IBIS on the Z7, since I am not to thrilled with that camera, maybe its the XT-4 and a speed booster, I didn't have the speed booster version of the metacones, just the cheaper $100 version. I think what worries me most about the APS-C is ISO performance. The Z7's as I read degrades IBIS to 3 Axis when used with the FTZ. Leighton, do you still get full IBIS on the Fuji with adapted lenses?

I need to confess that I love Fuji color rendering too! lol

Thanks!
Mark
Yes, 5-5.5 stops. Even more when used with Fuji lenses that have OIS.
This prompted a question...

I know in the Nikon cameras, IBIS function is tied to the focal length of the lens. When using lenses with CPUs the camera reads the FL and applies the correct stabilization for that given lens. When using adapted lenses, the stabilization applied is based on the FL that you input manually in the menu database. This is a challenge when using a non-cpu adapted zoom lens, especially one with a large range 35-200 for example. If you set the FL manually for 35 and zoom to 200, your IBIS will be way off.

Ok.. Getting to my question. For the Fuji when using the speedbooster, what focal length are you inputting in the camera. The actual FL of the lens or the effective FL from the speedbooster. Example of a 105mm lens. 105mm is the actual lens FL, but when using the speedbooster/focal reducer it is effectively 75mm (105 x .71) to the sensor

It would seem that it would impact the effectiveness of the IBIS. No?

George
I know this is from last week, but if you have the Lens Turbo II (or any of the speedboosters that have the same magnification) I made this chart that may be of use to some of you. If memory serves, when I was using a borrowed XH1, setting the lens data to the adjusted FL worked better. If using a dumb adapter (no glass) I used the FL as listed on the lens.


Thanks Kevin
Oct 19, 2021 at 12:54 PM
asiostygius
Offline
Details
p.1469 #2Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Variegated Flycatcher trying to pick up (presumably) fly kite lines for its nest by Jose, on Flickr

Variegated Flycatcher presumably trying to pick up (unsuccessfuly) fly kite lines (?) for its nest.

Olympus OM-D E-M1 MarkII + adapter + Nikkor 400mm f/5.6K ED non-IF, hand held, ISO 1600, wide open at 1/800s. 65% cropped (13/20MP).
Oct 19, 2021 at 01:34 PM
NightOwl Cat
Offline
Details
p.1469 #3Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Dishwashing gloves on your hands will give you a better grip

AM4L wrote:
While I am waiting, anyone have a solution for a rear lens cap that wont come off?


Oct 19, 2021 at 02:44 PM
cadman342001
Offline
Details
p.1469 #4Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Righty tighty, lefty loosey Mark

DSC_0059 by AndyMacDougallPhotography, on Flickr

DSC_0084 by AndyMacDougallPhotography, on Flickr

DSC_0085 by AndyMacDougallPhotography, on Flickr

DSC_0086 by AndyMacDougallPhotography, on Flickr

Andy
Oct 19, 2021 at 03:12 PM
Reagan
Offline
Details
p.1469 #6Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Today is the day our old friend Ray passed away
7 years ago
Still think about him even though we only met 3 or 4 times

Reagan




Oct 19, 2021 at 05:31 PM
Ken Hill
Offline
Details
p.1469 #7Manual Focus Nikon Glass
RIP to a good guy and a early pillar of this thread, Seven years ago we lost Ray to a heart attack, so quick. Reagan called a few minutes ago and we reminisced. I remember that lens in Reagans shot. It was at the Kiwi Swap meet.

Ray had an issue with his right eye Steve and I got him to switch to his left. He produced many fine shots that way.

So the Florida three Amigos are down to two



© Ken Hill 2021

Oct 19, 2021 at 06:32 PM
raboof
Offline
Details
p.1469 #8Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Me too. I remember the picture I took that day after we heard the news. I remember him very fond of the 28mm f2. I sold him my 20mm f4

Reagan wrote:
Today is the day our old friend Ray passed away
7 years ago
Still think about him even though we only met 3 or 4 times

Reagan

Oct 19, 2021 at 06:47 PM
raboof
Offline
Details
p.1469 #9Manual Focus Nikon Glass
400mm f5.6 ED non-IF + TC-14b





Oct 19, 2021 at 08:24 PM
rafaelcasd
Offline
Details
p.1469 #10Manual Focus Nikon Glass
The ai Kit #54 for the 300mm 4.5 ED K arrived from Finland today.

Here are all my 300mm 4.5, will do a comparison in a couple of days.

nikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_08 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Here is the tripod foot side, sorry one of them is scratched.

nikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_07 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

nikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_06 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Yes, the lens is sharp and renders 3d like at 4.5

nikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_10 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr



Oct 19, 2021 at 09:22 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

bruni
Offline
Details
p.1469 #11Manual Focus Nikon Glass


Reagan wrote:
Today is the day our old friend Ray passed away
7 years ago
Still think about him even though we only met 3 or 4 times

Reagan


Reagan - thank you for the reminder. I'm raising an espresso to him as we speak. I remember him as such a kind and enthusiastic presence here.
Ben
Oct 19, 2021 at 09:30 PM
GeorgeBo
Offline
Details
p.1469 #12Manual Focus Nikon Glass
rafaelcasd wrote:
The ai Kit #54 for the 300mm 4.5 ED K arrived from Finland today.

Here are all my 300mm 4.5, will do a comparison in a couple of days.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51609849450_964ad4a342_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_08 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Here is the tripod foot side, sorry one of them is scratched.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51608144427_4c4b125104_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_07 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51609849145_6085cb94d0_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_06 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Yes, the lens is sharp and renders 3d like at 4.5

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51608965681_1d55c3e6c0_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_10 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr



Really interested in seeing how the K performs against the 300 end of the 50-300 and the scalloped 300mm.

George
Oct 20, 2021 at 05:10 AM
HCE HCE
Offline
Details
p.1469 #13Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Here's a couple of Ray taken during our trip to Bok Gardens, my recent posts were from that trip. We had a good time swapping lenses and he carried a large bag full of them.

Here, in typical Ray fashion, he is showing off his prized 85mm f.1,4 to a perfect stranger.

D800 55mm f/1.2



-Jay- © HCE HCE 2021





-Jay- © HCE HCE 2021

Oct 20, 2021 at 05:41 AM
Oosty
Offline
Details
p.1469 #14Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Ray really was a nice guy although I didn't have the privilege of meeting him.

We exchanged PM's a few times and he was always helpful. A real loss to this thread but a much greater loss to his loved ones.

I'm sure the memories they have of him are a great comfort. RIP Ray
Oct 20, 2021 at 05:49 AM
Stokesey
Offline
Details
p.1469 #15Manual Focus Nikon Glass
Rays sense of humour was really of the best sort.

Never met the man, but had a fair bit of correspondence with him.

Obviously his favourite lens the 85mm f1.4 has been a fave of mine for many decades

Anyway today I went back to the Isle of Mull

D810 + 25-50mm f4 Ai-s and the 180mm f2.8 for the pony trekkers

Great day till I got back and smacked the car door in to the wall when the wind caught it ....

Steve
Packing Nikon




Stokesey 2021


Just like life ...... slowly decaying





Stokesey 2021


Pony trekking contre jour - Loch na Keal

Oct 20, 2021 at 12:27 PM
rafaelcasd
Offline
Details
p.1469 #16Manual Focus Nikon Glass
I hate testing good lenses. It is fun to test bad ones where you can easily point to the 'badness', or to look at the corners of a 16mm 3.5 compared to the poor 16mm 2.8 ais.

When it comes to good telephotos, focusing can make more of a difference than the lens themselves.

I believe that to be the case for the tests below, even with the high magnification finder of the Z6 focusing introduces more variability than the lenses. The old lens may have more chromatic aberration but the Z6 takes care of that.

Glass is 100% clean on these samples, not a spec of dust of haze. Test on tripod, no IBIS. processing is copy paste, all the same. Aperture is 4.5, with hoods and no filter,100% on Flickr.

Which one is best for this distance and light? don't know, can't tell. Maybe the top left OOF in the nai H is uglier.

nikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_08 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr


Lens identified in the file name

nikkor 300mm 4.5 ED K z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

nikkor 300mm 4.5 H NAI z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

nikkor 300mm 4.5 edif z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

nikkor 50-300mm 4.5 ed z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr





Edited on Oct 20, 2021 at 04:30 PM · View previous versions
Oct 20, 2021 at 03:46 PM
AM4L
Offline
Details
p.1469 #17Manual Focus Nikon Glass
rafaelcasd wrote:
I hate testing good lenses. It is fun to test bad ones where you can easily point to the 'badness', or to look at the corners of a 16mm 3.5 compared to the poor 16mm 2.8 ais.

When it comes to good telephotos, focusing can make more of a difference than the lens themselves.

I believe that to be the case for the tests below, even with the high magnification finder of the Z6 focusing introduces more variability than the lenses. The old lens may have more chromatic aberration but the Z6 takes care of that.

on tripod, no IBIS. processing is copy
...Show more →

The EDIF is my humble pic, just has a sharper output than the others, but its not over sharp like processing creates! Well done my friend! Thanks for taking the time to do this for us!
Oct 20, 2021 at 03:54 PM
rafaelcasd
Offline
Details
p.1469 #18Manual Focus Nikon Glass
AM4L wrote:
rafaelcasd wroteI hate testing good lenses. It is fun to test bad ones where you can easily point to the 'badness', or to look at the corners of a 16mm 3.5 compared to the poor 16mm 2.8 ais.

When it comes to good telephotos, focusing can make more of a difference than the lens themselves.

I believe that to be the case for the tests below, even with the high magnification finder of the Z6 focusing introduces more variability than the lenses. The old lens may have more chromatic aberration but the Z6 takes care of that.

on tripod, no IBIS. processing is copy paste, all the same. Aperture is 4.5. 100% on Flickr.

Which one is best for thsi distance and light? don't know, can't tell. Maybe the top left OOF in the nai H is uglier.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51609849450_1b3aa36b02_h.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_08 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Lens identified in the file name

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612734955_da707bb972_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 ED K z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612506404_132cb95594_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 H NAI z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612505369_c61c2d8f12_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 edif z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51611023592_4859eaab89_k.jpgnikkor 50-300mm 4.5 ed z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr
The EDIF is my humble pic, just has a sharper output than the others, but its not over sharp like processing creates! Well done my friend! Thanks for taking the time to do this for us!


I think you are right, the 300mm edif is a tad sharper than the others in this set, but in a natural way. The focus plane is slightly different and that maybe the reason one or the other is better, just don't know. Maybe at 50Mp with great technique these differences become very noticeable, for my photography any one of them would do.

The EDIF has such a low resistance when focusing that it seems to be on ball bearings, I do not like that because it is hard to keep it at the same focus setting, the lightest touch moves it. The more traditional focusing action of the others makes them better for me.

Jose's EDIF does not seem as good as mine, but his ED K may be better than mine. 'Sample variation'!

I will venture to say that at $90 for a H, $300 for EDIF, $500 for ED K/ai, and $500 for the 50-300mm ED, the winner is the H!

Or maybe if you divide the $500 of the 50-300mm into 50-85-105-135-180-200 and 300mm focal lengths, at $500/7 focal lengths = $71, the 50-300mm is the winner. Of course the 300mm ED K/ai is so rare it is the collector's winner, so forget the EDIF being a little better, it matters not.
Oct 20, 2021 at 03:56 PM
GeorgeBo
Offline
Details
p.1469 #19Manual Focus Nikon Glass
rafaelcasd wrote:
AM4L wrote
rafaelcasd wroteI hate testing good lenses. It is fun to test bad ones where you can easily point to the 'badness', or to look at the corners of a 16mm 3.5 compared to the poor 16mm 2.8 ais.

When it comes to good telephotos, focusing can make more of a difference than the lens themselves.

I believe that to be the case for the tests below, even with the high magnification finder of the Z6 focusing introduces more variability than the lenses. The old lens may have more chromatic aberration but the Z6 takes care of that.

on tripod, no IBIS. processing is copy paste, all the same. Aperture is 4.5. 100% on Flickr.

Which one is best for thsi distance and light? don't know, can't tell. Maybe the top left OOF in the nai H is uglier.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51609849450_1b3aa36b02_h.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 K ED Z6 test_01_08 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

Lens identified in the file name

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612734955_da707bb972_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 ED K z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612506404_132cb95594_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 H NAI z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51612505369_c61c2d8f12_k.jpgnikkor 300mm 4.5 edif z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51611023592_4859eaab89_k.jpgnikkor 50-300mm 4.5 ed z6 test 00 by Rafael Batlle, on Flickr
The EDIF is my humble pic, just has a sharper output than the others, but its not over sharp like processing creates! Well done my friend! Thanks for taking the time to do this for us!
I think you are right, the 300mm edif is a tad sharper than the others in this set, but in a natural way. The focus plane is slightly different and that maybe the reason one or the other is better, just don't know. Maybe at 50Mp with great technique these differences become very noticeable, for my photography any one of them would do.

The EDIF has such a low resistance when focusing that it seems to be on ball bearings, I do not like that because it is hard to keep it at the same focus setting, the lightest touch moves
...Show more →

Thanks for that testing! I always thought my H was a decent lens and my 50-300 is one of my forever keep lenses. It is my go to for video projects.

Oct 20, 2021 at 04:46 PM
raboof
Offline
Details
p.1469 #20Manual Focus Nikon Glass
I see more chromatic aberration on the EDIF. Look at the ends of the palm leaves. They turn bluer. But yeah, they are very close.


rafaelcasd wrote:
I hate testing good lenses. It is fun to test bad ones where you can easily point to the 'badness', or to look at the corners of a 16mm 3.5 compared to the poor 16mm 2.8 ais.

When it comes to good telephotos, focusing can make more of a difference than the lens themselves.

I believe that to be the case for the tests below, even with the high magnification finder of the Z6 focusing introduces more variability than the lenses. The old lens may have more chromatic aberration but the Z6 takes care of that.

Glass is 100% clean on these samples,
...Show more →
Oct 20, 2021 at 05:34 PM


FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister