fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread

  
 
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.106 #1ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
Derek, have you ever tested your 28/2's at closer distances? I think they might also perform better at near distances rather than at infinity.


yes, they do. in fact all the rokkor wide angles i've used share this characteristic (21/2.8 and 17/4 are the others i've tried). i believe it's part of the minolta design strategy, they seem to believe that their wide angles should be more useful for near focus compositions than infinity (i tend to agree). kinda the opposite of zeiss. on the other hand, most normal and telephoto rokkors seem to be optimized for infinity.


Mar 28, 2015 at 04:15 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.106 #2ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Basso wrote:
For me it is hard to understand its bad performance in the infinity shot and at the same time the quite remarkable performance in the near focus shot that I posted above (taken within hours of each other). If something is misaligned would then the near focus shot turn out as good as this one? Well anyway, I have the 55mm version and a Novoflex adapter that works flawlessly for all my Rokkors (except for certain angles towards a lightsource when it can produce flare).
Maybe I should put the lens through a more systematic test than the one showed
...Show more →

your close up shot really only has the center in focus. if the FLE is improperly placed or one of the elements is out of alignment it won't really effect the central performance only the off axis performance.

also, the 24/2.8 has a floating element (FLE) while most of the longer rokkors do not (though your 35/1.8 does). if the adapter allows focus past infinity it means that the FLE will not be miscalibrated. finally, the wider a lens is the more sensitive it is to small variations in alignment. this is because it takes smaller movements to change focus a given distance on wider lenses.

to check for field curvature (a problem with FLE calibration on this lens) shoot at infinity with the frame tilted diagonally so there is detail in the corners. take three shots, one where you focus in the center of the frame, one where you focus in the mid zone, and one where you focus in the corner. if the FLE is properly calibrated all of these shots will be identical.

Mar 28, 2015 at 05:10 PM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #3ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
sebboh wrote:
Basso wroteFor me it is hard to understand its bad performance in the infinity shot and at the same time the quite remarkable performance in the near focus shot that I posted above (taken within hours of each other). If something is misaligned would then the near focus shot turn out as good as this one? Well anyway, I have the 55mm version and a Novoflex adapter that works flawlessly for all my Rokkors (except for certain angles towards a lightsource when it can produce flare).
Maybe I should put the lens through a more systematic test than the one showed here (at the middle of a Summer day with the sun coming from the left), as the sunlight may have influenced the performance by producing flare or related things, which can be an issue with these lenses as you and Phillip observe above. Anyway, thanks for commenting
your close up shot really only has the center in focus. if the FLE is improperly placed or one of the elements is out of alignment it won't really effect the central performance only the off axis performance.

also, the 24/2.8 has a floating element (FLE) while most of the longer rokkors do not (though your 35/1.8 does). if the adapter allows focus past infinity it means that the FLE will not be miscalibrated. finally, the wider a lens is the more sensitive it is to small variations in alignment. this is because it takes smaller movements to change focus a
...Show more →

That is a lot of very useful knowledge. Thank you, sir!
Mar 29, 2015 at 03:27 AM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #4ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Time for a small Rokkor bump. Had a hard time to nail focus on this robin that hopped around for about an hour but never sat longer than a few seconds. Cropped. Minolta MC Tele Rokkor-PF 135/2.8.

Mar 30, 2015 at 01:45 PM
Listera
Offline
Details
p.106 #5ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
A 28mm with attractive bokeh...


A patch of Lamium

Rokkor 28 2.5 on OM-D EM5
Apr 03, 2015 at 02:34 PM
kevinleedrum
Offline
Details
p.106 #6ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
My Minolta collection currently includes the MD 28/2.8, MD 35-70/3.5 Macro, MD 50/1.7, MC 58/1.2, and the MD 135/2.8. Sometimes I feel like I need a fast 35mm, but I also sometimes feel that I have too many lenses.

Here are a couple recent shots with the 58mm 1:1.2.


Crawfish


Bisset Park
Apr 04, 2015 at 07:16 PM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #7ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
One with the MC Rokkor 85/1.7 on a NEX5N. Stopped down this lens can be very sharp and contrasty. See also Phillip's read worthy assessment HERE




And one of last week on the A7r. MFD is not the biggest selling point of this lens...

(probably at f/2.8 instead of f/1.7, given the hexagon to the right)
Apr 08, 2015 at 02:18 AM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #8ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
And another one with the MC Rokkor 85/1.7. Cross post with A7-thread.


Apr 09, 2015 at 01:51 PM
Sirfishalot
Offline
Details
p.106 #9ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Basso,
You're making it more difficult for me to part with my 85/1.7, which I'm planing to sell. Here's a recent shot from it on the A7:
http://www.jaytaylorphotography.com/Photography/Monochrome-Images/i-cgHLQ3M/0/X2/IMG_2960-X2.jpg

JayT

Edited on Apr 09, 2015 at 10:22 PM · View previous versions
Apr 09, 2015 at 05:37 PM
arduluth
Offline
Details
p.106 #10ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread


Sirfishalot wrote:
Basso,
You're making it more difficult for me to part with my 85/1.7, which I'm planing to sell. Here's a recent shot from it on the A7:

http://www.jaytaylorphotography.com/Woodworking/i-2DBhj2g/0/XL/IMG_2968

JayT


Page Not Found
Apr 09, 2015 at 05:48 PM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #11ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Sirfishalot wrote:
Basso,
You're making it more difficult for me to part with my 85/1.7, which I'm planing to sell. Here's a recent shot from it on the A7:
http://www.jaytaylorphotography.com/Photography/Monochrome-Images/i-cgHLQ3M/0/X2/IMG_2960-X2.jpg

JayT


That is really a great shot. Smooth focus transitions supported by reflections and yet great clarity and atmosphere.

I think that I understand your feelings about the 85/1.7. Also sometimes contemplating to sell it. I do not use it very often nor is it the first lens I would pick when I go out. It's limited versatality is a bit of a concern. Yet, when used in the right conditions it really can give great images (save for the fringing that I overlooked in the shot below...) that few other lenses (that I have, i.e. ContaxG90, Rokkor 100/2.5) can. Also from a mechanical perspective this lens is a joy to use, probably the nicest engineered and most durable lens that I have.

Here to make it easier for you two more from 2 weeks ago when Spring was hesitating...





Edited on Apr 10, 2015 at 02:20 AM · View previous versions
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:13 AM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #12ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Cross-post from the NEX-thread which seems to have become a rather quiet place. Minolta MC Rokkor 58/1.2.



Apr 10, 2015 at 02:17 AM
Basso
Offline
Details
p.106 #13ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
And one with the MD Rokkor 100/2.5 (cross-post from the A7-thread)


Apr 10, 2015 at 03:50 PM
daleaherman
Offline
Details
p.106 #15ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
58/1.2

DSC07713 by Dale Herman, on Flickr

DSC07671 by Dale Herman, on Flickr

5N
May 18, 2015 at 01:30 PM
sceptic
Offline
Details
p.106 #16ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Found this in a thrift shop:

Catch of the day by scepticswe, on Flickr

Pretty sharp when stopped down to f/4

Minolta MC TELE ROKKOR-PF 100/2 test shot (f/4) by scepticswe, on Flickr

Wide open bokeh ain´t bad, either:

Minolta MC TELE ROKKOR-PF 100/2 test shot (f/2) by scepticswe, on Flickr

All in all, not bad for $75
Jun 04, 2015 at 12:37 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
Jun 04, 2015 at 01:35 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
Jul 03, 2015 at 02:26 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.106 #19ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
Great shots with the MD 35-70, Phillip! Do you by chance know how it compares to the MC Soligor 28-80/3.5-4.5 C/D (in Canon FD mount)? I have the Soligor lens but would be interested how it compares to this Minolta lens.
Jul 03, 2015 at 07:34 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.106 #20ROKKOR Image & Discussion Thread
retrofocus wrote:
Great shots with the MD 35-70, Phillip! Do you by chance know how it compares to the MC Soligor 28-80/3.5-4.5 C/D (in Canon FD mount)? I have the Soligor lens but would be interested how it compares to this Minolta lens.

sorry never heard of that Soligor.
Jul 05, 2015 at 02:14 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister