markhout wrote:
rsolti13 wrote
24 Elmar How do you find the Elmar? I am on the fence between the 24mm Elmar and the Zeiss 25mm Biogon. Aside from the price, according to the interwebs they don't seem to be significantly different. Any thoughts appreciated!
(eww this question may be off topic)
I've used the three 24/25 lenses mentioned here. First about the focal length, the Elmarit-M 24 ASPH is a true 24mm and the Zeiss Biogon 25 is about 26mm plus focal length, which you may be able to still use the M's rangefinder if you don't wear glasses. In terms of size, the Elmar-M 24 is smaller than the other two but not by much. The hood on the Elmarit-M ASPH is a bit too big and I use the lens without it. I also use the Zeiss Biogon without the hood.
Optically, they are all exceptional and you won't wrong with anyone of them. The Elmarit-M 24 ASPH is an older design but it has a wonderful Leica color brilliance that is very unique. The Zeiss Biogon, 25, on the other hand, has a very gentle color rendition which is special partially due to the Biogon’s 'symmetric' optical design. The Elmar-M 24 has the newest design with the best outer zone performance at open f stop (f/3.8). It has the latest Leica coating with deep and saturated color rendering. If you’re using the lens for landscape and don’t need f/2.8, go with the Elmar-M since it’s a bit smaller. In terms of sharpness, I give Zeiss a bit of edge in center portion of the image, but that's just splitting hair as all three are excellent. Hope you have fun deciding on one of them.