Mitch Alland wrote:
Usually I use SilverEfex, but a few weeks I rsaw somewhere on the LUF a reference to using ColorEfex for B&W conversions. I've tried that for a while and generally like it for the type of high contrast look that I often aim for. Here's a color image followed by a ColorEfex B&W conversion, with final adjustments in Lightroom. Has anyone tried ColorEfex for this purpose?
I am using both - SilverEfex and ColorEfex - but each for different PP purposes. I have never attempted to use ColorEfext to make B&W conversions, but I find the result above too contrasty for my preference (each on their own here, it's just a subjective matter of taste). I sometimes use Nik Viveza for selective color or brightness/contrast control in B&W.
I think it's too contrasty for most people. Not so sure of it my myself. I'll post a few more images converted using the B/W Conversion filter, whose description is here:
The reason I've used these ColorEfex filters rather than SilverEfex is because the rendition of combination of colors is such that it is difficult to achieve by using the individual color sliders in Silver Efex or Lightroom. For example the tonal rendition of the second picture (Paris) I found impossible to achieve in SilverEfex or Lightroom. However, these ColorEfex filters are only useful if you want high contrast.
There are three choices for the conversions: Dynamic Contrast, Tonal Enhancer and B/W Conversion, and the Tonal Enhancer has a drop-down menu for three intensities. You can save your settings as a Recipe. There are also some built-in recipes. Here are a few more examples of using this filter in ColorEfex, although the last one, of the longan tree, uses the Infrared filter. For most images, I first process the color image in Lightroom quickly, particularly if I've underexposed significantly to protect highlights, otherwise the filters can be applied on the SOOC image.
I've probably posted most of these images befor, but thought it some people could be interested because the B&W rendition of the colors are extremely difficult to achieve in Lightroom. (Most of the images have finishing touches applied in LR.)
NOTE: You may have to copy the url above and paste it into the browser. URL links in the the FM Forums often don't work unless you clear your browser cache — at lest that is what I find with Safari on the Mac. This is something Fred Miranda should fix.
M10 | DR Summicron | ISO 200 | f/2.0 | 1/750
Chiang Mai
M9 | Elmarit 21ASPH | ISO 640 | f/5.6 | 1/350
Paris