Hi all
like Katie, it too has been a while since I posted, though in my case I am here seeking opinions. I posted a similar qn on the Leica user forum but wanted to hear your opinions too.
I have a 28mm Elmarit ASPH (new version) and I'm thinking of swapping it for a 28mm Summilux. I have the 28mm Elmarit, 35FLE, 50lux ASPH, 50 f1 and a 50 1.4 Millennium Nikkor. I only ever bring 1 lens when I shoot casually and only have 1 body, the M240. I shoot mainly 35mm as my daily/travel lens. The 50lux is my portrait/"work" lens, and I cover entire shoots with just that and make do with some cropping or stitching should I need something wider or tighter. The 35lux is often in my bag in case (literally, in its leather case, but also in case I need it). I had a 28mm Cron v1 when my photography with the M was a lot more raw and I didn't know how to compose properly with 28mm and I sold it a few months after I got it. I only recently acquired the 28mm Elmarit and it is so tiny it brings me so much joy when I go out with it and the M240.
I want a 28lux because the 1.4 is a very useful tool to have. Given all my other lenses are fast lenses, I do miss the speed. I also love the way it renders. I don't believe it will necessarily replace my 35lux in my kit and I don't intend to sell the 35lux, but if I add the 28lux I will sell the elmarit. I thought about the 28cron v2 but I am reluctant because it doesn't offer the tiny size factor of the elmarit (especially without hood), and doesn't offer the rendering of the lux. I suppose the 28cron and 28lux can be contrasted to the analogy of the 50lux ASPH and the 50 0.95, with the lux rendering very similar to the 0.95 in my eyes, except it "misses" the extra stop. The 28cron and 28lux are just different animals. While the elmarit doesn't render like the 28lux, it does have size on its side and packs a punch in terms of performance.
I'm just reluctant to let the 28 Elmarit go because of its size (very refreshing to have something tinier than the already small Leica 35 and 50luxes). I do recognise there are other small lenses around. 35Cron v3/v4, the 35mm UC-Hexanon come to mind. However I don't want to keep adding lenses to my kit because I see myself as a shooter and not a collector of sorts and am too practical to have too many lenses sitting about.
Additionally, I am always admiring the 75lux from afar. It is my favourite portrait lens, stemming from the days I shot with the 80lux. With the money I save on not buying the 28lux, I can go for a 75lux. This said, 75mm won't work well for me when I do single lens-single body shoots (50mm is more flexible in this respect), and I don't use 75mm for streets or as a daily shooter. I feel I should leave the 75lux out of the equation until a time I can afford to grab a 2nd body (A7 series/SL) in which case I would shoot with a 35mm on one and 75mm on another.
If you could choose, which would you choose, and why?