fredmiranda.com
Login

Moderated by: Fred Miranda
  New fredmiranda.com Mobile Site
  New Feature: SMS Notification alert
  New Feature: Buy & Sell Watchlist
  

FM Forums | Lighting & Studio Techniques | Join Upload & Sell

1       2       3              19              21              26       27       end
  

Archive 2010 · PLM V2's announced!

  
 
kenyee
Offline
• • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #1 · PLM V2's announced!


The D-Lite is made in India?? I always thought all Elinchrom stuff was made in Switzerland...



Oct 08, 2010 at 10:03 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #2 · PLM V2's announced!


Posted replaced below

Edited on Oct 08, 2010 at 10:51 PM · View previous versions



Oct 08, 2010 at 10:23 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #3 · PLM V2's announced!


kenyee wrote:
The D-Lite is made in India?? I always thought all Elinchrom stuff was made in Switzerland...



No, made in India. That's what my box and unit says. To my knowledge, BX Series is also made in India, Can't verify origin of other ELI products.



Oct 08, 2010 at 10:26 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #4 · PLM V2's announced!


Seanzky wrote:
The D-Lite 2 is actually $274.89. The prices have dropped since you did that comparison, Mr. Buff. Also the new D-Lite has built-in receiver on top of being cheaper than the previous model.

There might be other stuff as well that might be different on the new one than what's stated on your old test results (Feb. 2007).



This comparison was done in 2007 when I bought one for testing. There has been no price change since I published the comparison.

Just placed a current order in B&H shopping cart to verify price as follows:

D Lite 2 - $274.89
Optional reflector (mentioned in my comparison) - $62.39 . . . . total $337.28
"2 year protection plan (free with AB) - $75.98 . . . . d-Lite 2 Total $413.26

AB400 160WS monolight compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $224.95
AB800 320WS monolight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $279.95
AB1600 640WS monolight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $359.95


I didn't post this to rehash this comparison . . . only to answer the OP's question.



Oct 08, 2010 at 10:49 PM
corndog
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #5 · PLM V2's announced!


Who cares, ship me my PLM already!








Oct 08, 2010 at 10:55 PM
Seanzky
Offline
• •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #6 · PLM V2's announced!


Paul Buff wrote:
This comparison was done in 2007 when I bought one for testing. There has been no price change since I published the comparison.

Just placed a current order in B&H shopping cart to verify price as follows:

D Lite 2 - $274.89
Optional reflector (mentioned in my comparison) - $62.39 . . . . total $337.28
"2 year protection plan (free with AB) - $75.98 . . . . d-Lite 2 Total $413.26

AB400 160WS monolight compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $224.95
AB800 320WS monolight . . . . . . . . .
...Show more

And you have to add $89.95 for the receiver which is built-in for the D-Lite. The 2-year protection plan for the D-Lite 2 is $37.99 not $75.98. That's on top of the 1-year warranty. That makes it 3 years compared to the ABs 2 years. The reflector is also $44.95 not $62.39. That totals to $357.83 with built-in transmitter, digital controls, 3-year warranty, and less/barely noticeable color-shift in the lower power level.

AB400 160WS monolight compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $314.90
AB800 320WS monolight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $369.90
AB1600 640WS monolight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $449.90

The Elinchrom strobes have a sub reflector but the ABs don't. For example, I get by without the reflector for my Elinchrom just fine, but I couldn't with my B800s because it would be bare bulb. So that area is debatable.



Oct 09, 2010 at 07:34 AM
RDKirk
Offline
• • • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #7 · PLM V2's announced!


And you have to add $89.95 for the receiver which is built-in for the D-Lite.

The 89.95 for the Buff receiver is for the CSR+, which has full power level and modeling light control capability. The built-in D-Lite receiver is trigger only.

Although the warranty for the Buff stuff is two years, IME I haven't suffered an inherent problem that they would not fix for free even out of warranty. Others may have different experience with that, however.



Oct 09, 2010 at 11:58 AM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #8 · PLM V2's announced!


&QSeanzky wrote:
And you have to add $89.95 for the receiver which is built-in for the D-Lite. The 2-year protection plan for the D-Lite 2 is $37.99 not $75.98. That's on top of the 1-year warranty. That makes it 3 years compared to the ABs 2 years. The reflector is also $44.95 not $62.39. That totals to $357.83 with built-in transmitter, digital controls, 3-year warranty, and less/barely noticeable color-shift in the lower power level.

AB400 160WS monolight compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $314.90
AB800 320WS monolight . . . . . . .
...Show more


It wasn't my intention to make this a $ VS $ thing or nitpicking point for various bells and whistles.

That said, let me first address the warranty issue: What comes with the D Lite is a LIMITED one year warranty VALID ONLT TO THE ORIGINAL BUYER AND NOT VALID IN FLORIDA.

What this means is that it is not covered if you drop it, scratch it, dent the reflector, plug it into the wrong power source or do anything else the manufacturer deems "improper use", you are screwed an will pay repair charges an go thorough RMA numbers and weeks of red tape and unknown, potentially exorbitant repair charges and you light will be confiscated until you pay whatever charges they choose to assess In short, their warranty service and extended service plans Are profit centers.

Contrast this to our 29 year warranty repair policies that are well discussed and verified on all forums. On all products, you have a 60 day absolute no questions asked return policy. If your equipment falls into the ocean, or off a truck. you send us what's left and we credit you purchase. minus shipping charges. I f you are happy with the equipment, we'' replace it with new at no charge,

On AB, we have 2 year factory warranty in addition to the 60 return policy. Again, no RMAs and paperwork. Send us the equipment with a description of the issue. When we receive it we don't attempt to define if it was abused . . . .we fix it and send it back. If the case is cracked or scratched, we replace it. If capacitors are blown from excess firing rates, we replace them.

It's Golden Rule thing . . . if you are fair and honest we reciprocate to the very best of our ability. But if you keep throwing units onto the freeway and send them back once a month, we will object and tell you we can't keep replacing them free. Does this cost us money . . . of course, but it is built into our pricing as an advertising cost, and it pays off for us in customer good will.

Since we have over 500,000 flash units in the field, yes, we repair a lot of them, in and out of warranty and have a pretty streamlined procedure for getting them in and out . . . 7 technicians and two receiving/processing personnel.

This reminds me of an early experience with a 23 year old girl back in the 80s who had purchased a WL10,000. She called me in tears because her lightstand had tipped over and it all fell in the pool. Replacing the unit was a serious hit on her cash. I told her "I know the cost of the unit is a heartbreaker for you, but for me replacing it is a minor cost of business . . .so just send it back and I'll send you a new one at no charge." Needless to say, this girl became a customer for life and my $$179 investment has been returned 1000 times over. This sort of thing is a one in a hundred and that relates to less than a 1% advertising cost. When most companies spend 5 to15% of sales in ad costs it's kinda' of a no brainer. (Sure glad I didn't go to marketing or business school!!!)

Now back to the D-Lite arguments:

Yes, the new D Lile comes with Skyport receiver, but the transmitter will set you back another $92.50 if you actually want to use it. Many customers buy the basic $224.95 AB400 or $279.95 AB800 and use the supplied sync cord until such time as they want wireless sync.

Attached is a sample order to B&H (if it opens) for D Lite 2 equipped with what you get from a $224.95 AB400. Indeed, it comes out $413.26 I would once again direct you to http://www.alienbees.com/compare.html for performance comparisons And, yes, AB, WL Zeus and CyberSinks are made and serviced in America, and you can talk to us any time on our dime instead of traveling to NYC and standing in line for hours to get an answer from a salesman who just looks up the spec on their (rather technically challenged/limited IMHO) spec sheets.

As for color shift VS power, I suggest you examine this link (D=Lite and RX exhibit the same color VS power characteristics). AB exhibits slightly less color shift VS Power, though repeatability at the low end is better on D-Lite http://www.paulcbuff.com/pcb2009/e640detail.html http://www.paulcbuff.com/pcb2009/plmv2ad.html


B&H quote:

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bah/controller/?O=cart&A=setQty=

Sorry, the B&H Link won't open because it was generated with my login number. I will cut and paste and upload it. To generate it yourself, go to to http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/673589-REG/Elinchrom_EL_20483_D_Lite_IT_200Ws_Flash.html

plug in one D Lire 2, then go to accessories and plug in one standard 8 1/4" reflector. then plug in 2 year extended warranty. Regarding the warranty I believe you get a total of two years of protection from accidental damage . . . not three years as you implied. Read the fine print.

Sorry for all the typos - I've been in the hospital for five days and am highly sedated and have dumb fingers right not.

Edited on Oct 09, 2010 at 12:19 PM · View previous versions



Oct 09, 2010 at 11:58 AM
Seanzky
Offline
• •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #9 · PLM V2's announced!


I wasn't trying to argue anything. And I definitely wasn't trying to argue your warranty policies. I was just pointing out the misrepresented numbers in your post and giving the correct ones. You made it seem like the D-Lite and ABs are absolutely equal (even though one is 160ws and the other is 200ws) except that the D-Lite was overpriced. I certainly don't think it is.

As for the D-Lites being plugged into the wrong power source, it's multi-voltage unlike the ABs. Also, you don't have to spend $92.50 to use the receiver. Just like the ABs, it also comes with a sync cord and optical slave.



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:14 PM
Seanzky
Offline
• •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #10 · PLM V2's announced!


RDKirk wrote:
The 89.95 for the Buff receiver is for the CSR+, which has full power level and modeling light control capability. The built-in D-Lite receiver is trigger only.

Although the warranty for the Buff stuff is two years, IME I haven't suffered an inherent problem that they would not fix for free even out of warranty. Others may have different experience with that, however.


Right you are! My mistake. It's $69.95, not $89.95, for the receiver.

As for the warranty, I was just pointing out the cost was dramatically less than what Mr. Buff stated and that as a result of the additional warranty, it became 3 years instead of AB's 2. That's all. I wasn't comparing what their warranties covered. I wouldn't know since I baby everything I own including all the PCB gear I've owned. In my experience, if my gear is built to work and not crap out in a year or two, then it will work forever. I don't know the meaning of "abusing gear".



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:22 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #11 · PLM V2's announced!


There are no misrepresentations in my numbers. As for the 200WS VS 160WS thing . . . look at the exposures from equalized reflector patterns. If you want to skip the protection plan, go ahead, but keep your fingers crossed.

Also notice current D Lire 2 t.5 flash duration is 1/2000 sec (up from 1/1200) while AB is 1/6000. Also notice AB has accurate modeling lamps and 32:1 power range, VS horribly inaccurate modeling and 16:1 power range for D Lite. Also, AB400 recycles to Full in 0.50 seconds. D-Lite spec is 1.6 times as long. No, they're not absolute Apple to Apples . . . hey, they copied us.

Buy all the D-Lites you like . . . it doesn't affect my sales or customer base. Oh, if you want to actually use the radio trigger you do indeed need to spend another $92.50. For $130 you can add transmitter and receiver to AB or go with a $20 eBay set if performance and FCC compliance are of no concern.



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:39 PM
c2thew
Offline
• •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #12 · PLM V2's announced!


let's get back on topic...

d-lites suck when it comes to flash duration, yes we know that. we were just correcting someone questioning whether the d-lite 4 was 400ws

any more news on the plm progress/distribution.



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:41 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #13 · PLM V2's announced!


Seanzky wrote:
Right you are! My mistake. It's $69.95, not $89.95, for the receiver.

As for the warranty, I was just pointing out the cost was dramatically less than what Mr. Buff stated and that as a result of the additional warranty, it became 3 years instead of AB's 2. That's all. I wasn't comparing what their warranties covered. I wouldn't know since I baby everything I own including all the PCB gear I've owned. In my experience, if my gear is built to work and not crap out in a year or two, then it will work forever. I don't know the
...Show more


I disagree on the extended warranty. If you buy the one year plan, it will start on the day you make the purchase and be gone one year later, The warranty that comes with the unit ain't going to cover tip overs and scratches or broken tubes or fried components determined to be from improper use. If you think it will, you haven't read it.

The only way you're going to get three years out of the two year extended warranty is to buy it a year after you buy the light and hope nothing unusual goes wrong in the first year.



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:54 PM
corndog
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #14 · PLM V2's announced!


c2thew wrote:
any more news on the plm progress/distribution?


Seconded!



Oct 09, 2010 at 12:58 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #15 · PLM V2's announced!


c2thew wrote:
let's get back on topic...

d-lites suck when it comes to flash duration, yes we know that. we were just correcting someone questioning whether the d-lite 4 was 400ws

any more news on the plm progress/distribution.


D Lite 2 is stated as 200WS, WL400 is stated as 160WS, By calculation, this make the D Lite 0.29f stops brighter. But many factors affect the efficacy from WS to Lumens . . . . flashtube design, wiring, quality of flash capacitors, reflectors, etc. This is why I offered the controlled side by side exposures.

As I sad in he comparison, the two lights are roughly comparable in core performance and not one in a 1000 shooters in blind test can reliable identify which light took which shot (unless action stopping capability come into play).

If you need a 1f light increase, spend $279.95 and get an AB800 . . . That's what the majority of our customers do. Or spend $387.29 for D-Lite 4, Plus the price of 2 year extended warrantees (about $80?) and settle for 1.6 times as longer recycle, 4 times longer flash duration, inaccurate non-regulated modeling lamps and 1f stop less power adjustment range.

As I say, D Lites have virtually no affect on US Continent business, as hard as they try. In EU, sure, they are more competitive, but EU is less than 5% of our market a this point.

What i comes down to is buyers should inform themselves and buy what best suits their purpose and budget and workflow,







Oct 09, 2010 at 01:46 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #16 · PLM V2's announced!


corndog wrote:
Seconded!



PLMs are shipping in limited quantities. We are working very hands on with a personal agent (our respected moldmaker/metal parts supplier) and he is quality controlling a relatively small sewing and frame shop.

We don't want to get too many out there that we might later feel the need to replace. This week's delay is that we have had to change from Nylon based fabric to Polyester fabrics. Seems Nylon fabrics have a higher water absorption rate and this is causing some dimensional change from low humidity to high humidity. Unlike ordinary umbrellas, PLMs depends on exceedingly dimensional stability to achieve our standards of performance.

The Polyester fabrics are on order and are 100% stable.

I have had a serious hospitalization for the past week but am now OK but drugged up like a junkie!

Please see these upcoming ads for Pix with PLM and Einstein. I find the outcome little short of wonderful.

We're getting there, and it's a lot more painful and costly for me than anyone else Please try to accept I'm sorry and I am doing everything humanly possible, and have been for so long now it is really taking a toll on on my 74 year old body. I'll be back kicking assess from Austin to Hongkong next week.

http://www.paulcbuff.com/pcb2009/plmv2ad.html
http://www.paulcbuff.com/pcb2009/e640ad.html
http://www.paulcbuff.com/pcb2009/e640detail.html









Oct 09, 2010 at 02:20 PM
Kacey
Offline
• •
[X]
p.20 #17 · PLM V2's announced!


Any idea when the Version 3 with the Polyester fabric will be shipping?
Will you be making any other planned changes in the next year to them?



Oct 09, 2010 at 02:30 PM
corndog
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #18 · PLM V2's announced!


Paul Buff wrote:
PLMs are shipping in limited quantities. We are working very hands on with a personal agent (our respected moldmaker/metal parts supplier) and he is quality controlling a relatively small sewing and frame shop.

We don't want to get too many out there that we might later feel the need to replace. This week's delay is that we have had to change from Nylon based fabric to Polyester fabrics. Seems Nylon fabrics have a higher water absorption rate and this is causing some dimensional change from low humidity to high humidity. Unlike ordinary umbrellas, PLMs depends on exceedingly dimensional stability to
...Show more

Thanks for the info Paul!

I assume you have a limited quantity of polyester on hand and those are the ones shipping?

Bummer to hear about the hospital visit, a week in there will drive an active man insane. If not too personal, was it injury or illness related? I ask because if it were illness, that Hong Kong trip may be unwise. At least with injury, pain will typically let you know what you can get away with.

The ads look good.

I didn't know you guys were in Austin, it's a great area. I had work in Houston and we ended up driving to Pflugerville for dinner, t'was was a nice break from the miserable humidity!




Oct 09, 2010 at 02:46 PM
Paul Buff
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #19 · PLM V2's announced!


corndog wrote:
Thanks for the info Paul!

I assume you have a limited quantity of polyester on hand and those are the ones shipping?

Bummer to hear about the hospital visit, a week in there will drive an active man insane. If not too personal, was it injury or illness related? I ask because if it were illness, that Hong Kong trip may be unwise. At least with injury, pain will typically let you know what you can get away with.

The ads look good.

I didn't know you guys were in Austin, it's a great area. I had work in Houston and we ended
...Show more

All PLMV2s shipped to date are Nylon. They are useable, but have a tendency to get loose and floppy at 80%+ humidity and and overly tight below 40%. The silver versions aren't as bad as the white ones, because the sliver coating reduces the effect about 50%.

As for the hospital, I took it i upon myself to order full body CAT Scan and MRIs at my cost four weeks ago , , , just to be sure nothing bad showed up. . . . . Bad stuff showed up.

1. A 5.4cm aortal aneurysm (tennis ball size) behind my stomach. These things tend to rupture at 5.8mm, then you die (google it)

2. An egg size mass showed up in my bladder

3, Before I could proceed with the aneurism repair, I had to do a complete heart stress test and angiogram to make sure no heart condition would interfere with the aneurism surgery. Because the cardiologist did not want to do a normal angiogram via the groin for risk of accidentally puncturing the aneurism (death knoll) he had to go in from my elbow (much less fun).

The heart tests came out OK and I didn't need any stents or anything . . . just a a little BP Med adjustment.

4. Aortal aneurism repair involves one of two procedures: The hard way is slicing open your front, setting all the organs aside and doing an actual aorta bypass. Three weeks and gobs of dollars in the hospital and a 4 to 6 month recovery.

If the conditions are ideal (mine were) two small incisions are made at each side of the inner groin and a three piece stent is fed in through tubes and sewn together in place (the aorta itself is about 1 inch diameter). It's about a two hour procedure and a day or to in the hospital. This all went fine.

5. Next I had a 1/3" catheter shoved up my willy to scope the bladder mass. Prior tests indicated it was not malignant. The surgeon then did a processes of burn. cauterize and suck out the pieces of the mass through the catheter. I had a spinal anesthesia so was wide awake but shutdown entirely below my waist . . . erie.

6. During the aneurism repair I picked up a super bug and anesthetic artifacts that damn near killed me and left me psychotic - many go arounds with the hospital staff and threats of litigation on my part . . . ugly story.

Been home since yesterday and working with my prized internist to get past it all. Making good progress and should be ready ti kick some ass next week.

We're not in Austin . . . our programmer and digital experts are there as consultants. We have 45,000 square feet here in Nashville and probably another 45,000 feet in our sister robotic assembly plant in Kansas. Who knows how many Chinese and square meters we have in Asia . . . maybe another 300 or more.

So there it is . . . the good, the bad and the ugly



Oct 09, 2010 at 03:56 PM
corndog
Offline
• • • •
Upload & Sell: Off
p.20 #20 · PLM V2's announced!


Well...that's more info than I needed!




Oct 09, 2010 at 04:09 PM
1       2       3              19              21              26       27       end




FM Forums | Lighting & Studio Techniques | Join Upload & Sell

1       2       3              19              21              26       27       end
    
 

Welcome back
Log in to your account