Jim,
I use CF IV-1-2 and achieve the ability to focus on stationary subjects and retain the ability to
re compose as in One shot mode all while in the Ai Servo mode.
What do you find preferable about CF IV-1-1?
Jim, if you repeatedly bump focus and shoot almost immediately instead of tracking with the AF operating, won't you risk missing out on the benefits of predictive focus tracking, at least initially ?
Alan321 wrote:
Jim, if you repeatedly bump focus and shoot almost immediately instead of tracking with the AF operating, won't you risk missing out on the benefits of predictive focus tracking, at least initially ?
- Alan
While I can't do BIF, once in a while I try to photograph in-flight ducks, pijuns, geese and terns . . In doing that I haven't seen (experienced) one single shred of practical evidence which would suggest that Canon cameras have any manifest sort of predictive AF servo capability. Have you ?
PetKal wrote: Alan321 wroteJim, if you repeatedly bump focus and shoot almost immediately instead of tracking with the AF operating, won't you risk missing out on the benefits of predictive focus tracking, at least initially ?
- AlanWhile I can't do BIF, once in a while I try to photograph in-flight ducks, pijuns, geese and terns . . In doing that I haven't seen (experienced) one single shred of practical evidence which would suggest that Canon cameras have any manifest sort of predictive AF servo capability. Have you ?
Yes - it's noticible particularly when fast birds are flying directly at you. Try shooting head on birds with One Shot and compare it to AI Servo and you will see the difference.
Alan321 wrote:
Jim, if you repeatedly bump focus and shoot almost immediately instead of tracking with the AF operating, won't you risk missing out on the benefits of predictive focus tracking, at least initially ?
- Alan
The AI Servo Af kicks in very quickly. I tend to focus (very brief pause) then shoot when BIF are coming head on. Without the brief pause, the first frame is sometimes not sharp. When they aren't head on, I don't need the brief pause.
Ray Still wrote:
Great tips here I figure I can use a good part of this with my 1D Mark III, it is a totally different ballgame shooting BIF coming from a Landscape shooter background
Ray Still
With the Mark III I used center AF point only with no expansion all the time.
Ron Hole wrote: JimN wrote6. * button set to AF Lock. I use this when shooting still subjects. It allows me to remain in AI Servo AF and center AF point, but still be able to compose images of still subjects in camera. This way I am always ready for action without compromising my ability to compose images of perched birds. I use the shutter button to focus.
Jim NeigerThanks Jim..very useful information. Point 6 though confuses me a bit. I use the * button for focus and track using it by holding it, or letting off and re aquirring focus (bump as you aptly called it) then use the shutter buton to meter and take the picture.
I'm unclear how you are using it..would you mind going over this please.
thanks again
Ron
Ron,
WHen shooting still subjects, I focus using center AF point and AI Servo AF, then I press and hold the * button, then re-compose the image and shoot all while holding the * button. If the bird takes off, I simply release the * button, track and shoot. I prefer this over focusing with the * button. See my next post.
Lexoluck wrote:
"For AF Lock I use CF IV-1-1 and CF IV-2-1 "
Jim,
I use CF IV-1-2 and achieve the ability to focus on stationary subjects and retain the ability to
re compose as in One shot mode all while in the Ai Servo mode.
What do you find preferable about CF IV-1-1?
Andrew
Andrew,
I prefer focusing with the shutter button in combination with AF lock on the * button for three reasons.
1. My index fnger is more co-ordinated than my thumb. This means I can bump more precisely with my finger on the shutter button than I can with my thumb on the * button.
2. I shoot using my index finger which allows me to focus and shoot in one motion. If I use the * button to focus and shutter button to shoot, I need to co-ordinate two fingers together which is harder than simply using one finger and pressing harder.
3. I'm used to doing it this way.
JimN wrote:
...2. I shoot using my index finger which allows me to focus and shoot in one motion. If I use the * button to focus and shutter button to shoot, I need to co-ordinate two fingers together which is harder than simply using one finger and pressing harder.
I've always been vaguely fascinated by this technique. You're only the second person I've ever heard of using it (and I think the other was a BIF'er also). Seems utterly counter-intuitive and inefficient to me for several reasons. First, you're actually having to coordinate three actions, not two... half press of index finger to start AF, thumb press of * to stop AF, full press of index finger to fire the shutter. I tend to think of focusing and firing as two completely separate functions — so it just makes more sense to me for two separate buttons, manned by two separate digits, to perform those functions.
Second, as a sports shooter (and I would have guessed BIF is similar), I like to track a subject, getting on and off the shutter. I find this a lot easier holding down the * button (or not, as necessary) and firing occasionally, rather than trying to shoot sporadically while still trying simultaneously to maintain the half shutter press (failing which the camera loses and has to reacquire focus).
Third, and this can be very important... you say, "I shoot using my index finger which allows me to focus and shoot in one motion..." In AI servo if you literally do it in one motion you risk having your first frame OOF. You need to give the AF a fraction of a second to catch up before releasing the shutter. (The AF guide for the Mark IV devotes two whole pages to this.) Admittedly your "bump focus" technique should have you in the ballpark already, but for most people, pressing the shutter button all the way all in one motion is not the best way to go.
JimN wrote: PetKal wroteAlan321 wroteJim, if you repeatedly bump focus and shoot almost immediately instead of tracking with the AF operating, won't you risk missing out on the benefits of predictive focus tracking, at least initially ?
- AlanWhile I can't do BIF, once in a while I try to photograph in-flight ducks, pijuns, geese and terns . . In doing that I haven't seen (experienced) one single shred of practical evidence which would suggest that Canon cameras have any manifest sort of predictive AF servo capability. Have you ? Yes - it's noticible particularly when fast birds are flying directly at you. Try shooting head on birds with One Shot and compare it to AI Servo and you will see the difference.
OK, next time I'll try to shoot DIF using AF Servo and we'll see what happens.
Nill Toulme wrote: JimN wrote...2. I shoot using my index finger which allows me to focus and shoot in one motion. If I use the * button to focus and shutter button to shoot, I need to co-ordinate two fingers together which is harder than simply using one finger and pressing harder.I've always been vaguely fascinated by this technique. You're only the second person I've ever heard of using it (and I think the other was a BIF'er also). Seems utterly counter-intuitive and inefficient to me for several reasons. First, you're actually having to coordinate three actions, not two... half press of index finger to start AF, thumb press of * to stop AF, full press of index finger to fire the shutter. I tend to think of focusing and firing as two completely separate functions — so it just makes more sense to me for two separate buttons, manned by two separate digits, to perform those functions.
Second, as a sports shooter (and I would have guessed BIF is similar), I like to track a subject, getting on and off the shutter. I find this a lot easier holding down the * button (or not, as necessary) and firing occasionally, rather than trying to shoot sporadically while still trying simultaneously to maintain the half shutter press (failing which the camera loses and has to reacquire focus).
Third, and this can be very important... you say, "I shoot using my index finger which allows me to focus and shoot in one motion..." In AI servo if you literally do it in one motion you risk having your first frame OOF. You need to give the AF a fraction of a second to catch up before releasing the shutter. (The AF guide for the Mark IV devotes two whole pages to this.) Admittedly your "bump focus" technique should have you in the ballpark already, but for most people, pressing the shutter button all the way all in one motion is not the best way to go.
But:
Definitely can't argue with that. ;-)
Nill...Show more →Earlier quote3. I'm used to doing it this way.
1. I'm only using AF Lock for still subjects so the speed at which it I do it is not critical. I can do it very quickly anyway. I'm used to it and do it almost without thinking about it.
2. BIF are generaly smaller faster targets than sports subjects and they often move unpredictably. This requires alot of speed and precision when bumping the focus. Index finger wins over thumb for me. The shutter button is also larger and more sensitive.
3. The first frame AI Servo problem only comes into play with subjects moving directly or nearly directly towards you. In this case I often use a brief pause between focus and shoot. Again the index finger wins over thumb for this.
JimN wrote:
2. BIF are generaly smaller faster targets than sports subjects and they often move unpredictably. This requires alot of speed and precision when bumping the focus. Index finger wins over thumb for me. The shutter button is also larger and more sensitive.
You can add me as #3. I went back to using the shutter for AF for BIF/servo back when I had the MKIII. While I got used to the AF on button for just about everything else it just didn't seem as fast, especially if one "pumps" as Jim proposes. I don't normally ever need to stop AF while tracking so I don't have any problems coordinating it all. I do like the idea of using the AF on button to freeze AF for stationary objects if F&R is warranted so I am going to try setting cfn IV-1 to 1. I never got used to using the * button for AF so IV-2 isn't something I'll use.