philber wrote:
Sorry to disagree, Edward, but IMHO, only based on a short loan of the 24-85, 35-70 is much closer to Zeiss primes in terms of IQ. Usability OTOH is a totally different story, there 24-85 is lovely, and 35-70 a pain...
No disagreement Phil. The 35-70 is one of the best zooms ever made. It has been advertized by Zeiss as being equal or better than equivalent primes, a true statement according to my experience. However it is a 2X zoom only, and covers 2 1/2 classic FL. The 24-85 covers 5 classic FL. A fairer comparison would be with the C/Y 28-85, and in this case I believe the 24-85 wins.