fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2009 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2009Image Quality - A850 or D700

  
 
mawz
Offline
Details
p.15 #1Image Quality - A850 or D700
Tariq Gibran wrote:
mawz wroteNote the LR3 engine will likely be ACR 6 in CS5 next year. We are unlikely to see a new engine in ACR5.x at this point in its life cycle.
yes, Adobe will probably pull another Canon 5DII trick with CS5. Of course, the irony is that one of the supposed main benefits of having ACR as a separate plug-in was that one could easily just update ACR whenever new cameras were introduced rather than having to update Photoshop. I guess that did not work out from a money-making marketing standpoint for Adobe.


Well, you can do exactly that(update easily whenever new cameras are introduced), within minor versions. It's much nicer than waiting for the (always later) LR updates.

Adobe never promised that major versions of ACR would be compatible across PS versions.

Adobe has made it much easier to get new cameras to work in older software than any other RAW converter vendor thanks to the free DNG Converter.
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:23 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.15 #2Image Quality - A850 or D700
joekraft wrote:
ACR5 and greater only worked with CS4? That _is_ a dirty trick.


Nope,

ACR2.x works with CS
ACR3.x works with CS2
ACR4.x works with CS3
ACR5.x works with CS4

Major versions of ACR are tied to the matching PS version. Minor revisions are shipped every few months during the lifecycle of the PS version. Major changes can happen in minor revisions such as the engine revisions in ACR5.2.

Note I'm using major revision/minor revision in the software sense, where the first number in the version number is the major revision, the second number is the minor revision and any additional numbers indicate pure bugfixes or build numbers. Adobe only publicly uses major.minor for ACR.
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:27 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.15 #3Image Quality - A850 or D700
mawz wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
mawz wroteNote the LR3 engine will likely be ACR 6 in CS5 next year. We are unlikely to see a new engine in ACR5.x at this point in its life cycle.
yes, Adobe will probably pull another Canon 5DII trick with CS5. Of course, the irony is that one of the supposed main benefits of having ACR as a separate plug-in was that one could easily just update ACR whenever new cameras were introduced rather than having to update Photoshop. I guess that did not work out from a money-making marketing standpoint for Adobe.
Well, you can do exactly that(update easily whenever new cameras are introduced), within minor versions. It's much nicer than waiting for the (always later) LR updates.

Adobe never promised that major versions of ACR would be compatible across PS versions.

Adobe has made it much easier to get new cameras to work in older software than any other RAW converter vendor thanks to the free DNG Converter.


Of course, there are actually different versions of even DNG's, a fact that introduces confusion between those using older or newer versions of Photoshop. Things are never as simple as one would think. I ran into this issue recently with a student trying to use their older CS2 version of Photoshop with a Panasonic G1 raw file. She converted it to DNG at my suggestion as CS2 is dng compatible. Well, turns out it is compatible with a specific version of dng and some research turned up that she had to choose that earlier dng compatible version when converting in order for CS2 to read it. Earlier versions of PS will not read the most current DNG version. Common user problem apparently. So, all DNG's are not the same.

Adobe made no promises but did stress/insinuate when ACR initially came out that one major benefit would be the ability to only update ACR when new cameras are released instead of having to continuously update Photoshop. In the end, it's all about the money of course.
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:45 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.15 #4Image Quality - A850 or D700
mawz wrote:
joekraft wroteACR5 and greater only worked with CS4? That _is_ a dirty trick.
Nope,

ACR2.x works with CS
ACR3.x works with CS2
ACR4.x works with CS3
ACR5.x works with CS4

Major versions of ACR are tied to the matching PS version. Minor revisions are shipped every few months during the lifecycle of the PS version. Major changes can happen in minor revisions such as the engine revisions in ACR5.2.

Note I'm using major revision/minor revision in the software sense, where the first number in the version number is the major revision, the second number is the minor revision and any additional numbers indicate pure bugfixes or build numbers. Adobe only publicly uses major.minor for ACR.


Why do you say "Nope"? ACR5 will not work with versions of PS earlier than CS4. Is that not what he said?
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:49 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.15 #5Image Quality - A850 or D700
Tariq Gibran wrote:
Of course, there are actually different versions of even DNG's, a fact that introduces confusion between those using older or newer versions of Photoshop. Things are never as simple as one would think. I ran into this issue recently with a student trying to use their older CS2 version of Photoshop with a Panasonic G1 raw file. She converted it to DNG at my suggestion as CS2 is dng compatible. Well, turns out it is compatible with a specific version of dng and some research turned up that she had to choose that earlier dng compatible version when converting
...Show more →

True and unfortunate. That's something Adobe changed recently and it's caused no end of troubles. As late as ACR 5.3/DNG Converter 5.3 this wasn't an issue, you just ran the converter and it worked on ACR2.4 and later.Adobe screwed it up and really needs to go back and fix it.

Edited on Dec 04, 2009 at 06:54 PM · View previous versions
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:52 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.15 #6Image Quality - A850 or D700
Tariq Gibran wrote:
mawz wrote
joekraft wroteACR5 and greater only worked with CS4? That _is_ a dirty trick.
Nope,
Why do you say "Nope"? ACR5 will not work with versions of PS earlier than CS4. Is that not what he said?


ACR5 only works with CS4 (and the compatible versions of Elements). Later versions will not work with CS4 (it's the "and greater" that I was specifically objecting to).
Dec 04, 2009 at 06:54 PM
joekraft
Offline
Details
p.15 #7Image Quality - A850 or D700
Well, it sounds like it's _been_ a dirty trick for a long time, then. I wasn't keeping up on this because I've been upgrading PS all along, but if the output of ACR is a standard like tiff or psd, I can't see why that shouldn't work with an earlier version. Sounds fishy. Don't mean to derail this any further though.
Dec 04, 2009 at 08:56 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.15 #8Image Quality - A850 or D700
joekraft wrote:
Well, it sounds like it's _been_ a dirty trick for a long time, then. I wasn't keeping up on this because I've been upgrading PS all along, but if the output of ACR is a standard like tiff or psd, I can't see why that shouldn't work with an earlier version. Sounds fishy. Don't mean to derail this any further though.


I'm pretty sure it's the hooks into PS and Bridge that are the issue. ACR is quite seriously integrated into the two applications and that is what's driving this. ACR doesn't appear to use the standard plugin API.
Dec 05, 2009 at 08:01 AM
joekraft
Offline
Details
p.15 #9Image Quality - A850 or D700
That is exactly what I figured.
Dec 05, 2009 at 10:21 AM
mortyb
Offline
Details
p.15 #10Image Quality - A850 or D700
I'll just bore you with a hopefully final update about the backfocus issues I've had.

I've had two A850s: A1 and A2. I've had two 50mm lenses: L1 and L2. On A2, the L1 and L2 both need -16 micro adj. On the A1, L1 needed more than -20. Hence, L2 on A1 would probably need the same, but I haven't tried.

I picked up an A900, and L2 is dead on without any micro adj.

My concusion: Both my A850s were off. Why, I don't know. I'll stick with the A900.
Dec 07, 2009 at 07:34 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.15 #11Image Quality - A850 or D700
Hmm. Looks like the a900 gets hand tuned at the factory perhaps.
Dec 07, 2009 at 08:01 AM
moire
Offline
Details
p.15 #12Image Quality - A850 or D700
2 samples aren't enough data to draw any conclusions from.

But they have to reduce the cost somehow ...

Dec 07, 2009 at 08:04 AM
mortyb
Offline
Details
p.15 #13Image Quality - A850 or D700
My conclusion holds. Unless the A900 is off by +16
Dec 07, 2009 at 08:14 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.15 #14Image Quality - A850 or D700
My 50 1.4 needs -15 on my A900. The rest of my lenses need -5 or less.
Dec 07, 2009 at 10:10 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.15 #15Image Quality - A850 or D700
Mine needs -2. The only other lens that needs adjustment is the 16-35 (-5). The others are ok.
Dec 07, 2009 at 10:16 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.15 #16Image Quality - A850 or D700
Dec 07, 2009 at 01:02 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister