Jeremy, tilt is about a lot more than just selective blur... changing the plane of focus to make sharp a whole subject that is not parallel to the film plane, without jacking the aperture up to f/22, and doesn't fit the hyperfocal range, can be a pretty big deal.
For handheld or casual portraits, of course, you're probably just going to throw a wicked tilt on the lens, focus for your one subject area, and roll...