fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2009 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2009My D200: a Mini-Essay....

  
 
veroman
Offline

p.1 #1My D200: a Mini-Essay....
As some of you know, I've been a dedicated Canon shooter for several years. A little more than a year ago, I "dabbled" in Nikon with the purchase of a used D2x. As much as I liked and enjoyed that camera, I sold it some months after using it and regretted it ever since. So I recently picked up a D200 during the Best Buy closeout of that model and have been posting D200 images from time to time. Many of you have commented on them.

Well, I've just returned from a wonderful 10 days at Big Bear Lake, California, where my wife and I were joined by our grown children and a couple of grandchildren for a pretty marvelous time. Big Bear Lake is 3 hours east of Los Angeles and 7,000 feet above the city of San Bernardino. It's one beautiful place. I've been going there since the early 1970's.

The camera I took along was the D200. It was my first real use of that camera as my sole camera for an extended period. The lenses I packed were the Nikon 50mm f/1.8 and 18-55 VR; a Tamron 55-200 (don't knock it until you've tried it) and a Zeiss 25mm f/2.

Sometime within the next couple of weeks I'll post a variety of images from that trip. But in the here and now, I'm posting three images that are just a small sample of the kind of quality and photographic integrity I got from my D200 during this vacation. I am more than impressed with this remarkable camera ... or perhaps I should say: with the remarkable Nikon platform and their approach to digital photography. I have never been able to achieve ... with any degree of ease ... images of similar color depth, acuity, clarity, richness and naturalness (among other qualities) with either of my Canons (a 5D and a 1Ds II).

I do not hesitate to say that I think the images I get from my D200 are better than what I achieved with my D2x. I also can't imagine that the D300 could be all that significantly better, except perhaps in the higher ISO ranges.

It is possible ... and I've been giving this some serious thought ... that I will convert to the Nikon platform at some point in time ... not something to be done lightly, of course. All of my pro work is done with the Canon 5D and 1Ds II along with some of Canon's best lenses. I've learned how to use these Canons to best advantage when shooting interiors and know them like the back of my hand. But ... when all is said and done ... the Canon IQ is to my eyes rather plastic, false and "fabricated" compared to what I've been getting from my D200. The D200's metering is also miles better than the metering of the Canons. I've gotten used to endless fiddling with my Canons' exposures to achieve an acceptable histogram; I just accepted it as a matter of course when shooting with these cameras. The D200, on the other hand, is almost routinely spot on, requiring only the most minor adjustments for achieving a histogram that is not only acceptable but often nearly perfect.

I've considered renting a D700 and trying it out. I just may do that. It's the camera I would migrate to if I were to switch platforms. The D200 would be reserved as my travel and always-in-the-car camera.

Here are three images from my recent trip. More to come as soon as I have time to process. Just so you know: I've been shooting since 1970. I migrated to digital in 2001 or so. To date, the D200 is providing the best photographic experience of all the cameras I've owned, which have included the Fuji S2 Pro, Kodak SLR/c, Canon 1Ds Mark 1 and Mark II, Canon 10D and 5D, and the wonderful but notoriously frustrating Sigma/Foveon camera.

Thanks very much for reading ....

- Steve
http://www.pbase.com/image/114786931/original.jpg
http://www.pbase.com/image/114786983/original.jpg
http://www.pbase.com/image/114787069/original.jpg
Jul 09, 2009 at 03:14 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.1 #2My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Awesome set, Steve...as far as I'm concerned you're preachin' to the choir
Jul 09, 2009 at 03:16 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #3My D200: a Mini-Essay....
trenchmonkey wrote:
Awesome set, Steve...as far as I'm concerned you're preachin' to the choir


Thanks Will. I tell you, when I arrived home and viewed the pics on my monitor, my jaw dropped with nearly each image that came up. I think I shot around 12GB of pics, so I have a lot of processing to do. But I can hardly wait to get to them each morning. The D200 gives me some really exciting stuff to work with. It's been a long time since I've felt that way ....

- Steve
Jul 09, 2009 at 03:20 PM
davenfl
Offline
Details
p.1 #4My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Steve I also own and use both Canon and Nikon systems. Your comments don't come as any real surprise and frankly what your discovering is something that has changed a lot of peoples minds lately. They both build excellent camera's but Nikon's are particularly well engineered general purpose photographic equipment. Not to say that Nikon doesn't do some things that drive me a bit nuts but the basics work, are intuitive, and damn consistent. The flash system alone is sufficient for a lot of people to make the change, really a well thought delivering consistent results. I too find myself reaching more often for the D700 and D3. It is all a matter of personal choice but it sounds like a total switch to Nikon would be a happy event for you. Best of luck on your decision.

Dave
Jul 09, 2009 at 03:33 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #5My D200: a Mini-Essay....
davenfl wrote:
Steve I also own and use both Canon and Nikon systems. Your comments don't come as any real surprise and frankly what your discovering is something that has changed a lot of peoples minds lately. They both build excellent camera's but Nikon's are particularly well engineered general purpose photographic equipment. Not to say that Nikon doesn't do some things that drive me a bit nuts but the basics work, are intuitive, and damn consistent. The flash system alone is sufficient for a lot of people to make the change, really a well thought delivering consistent results. I too find myself
...Show more →
Dave: I'd bought the SB-800 when I owned the D2x and was quite impressed with that flash and overall flash system compared to Canon's. Professionally, I still shoot continuously lighting as much as possible; a lot easier for me to control and expose for. But I really did like that SB-800 and how it filled a scene or lit people.

Still not sure about a "total switch" to Nikon. I'm still learning about my D200. If I do switch, it won't be for awhile, and not until I've done some hands-on with a D700.

- Steve
Jul 09, 2009 at 06:00 PM
ibcj
Offline
Details
p.1 #6My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Great set Steve. I look forward to your D700 Mini-Essay.
Jul 09, 2009 at 06:16 PM
NightOwl Cat
Offline
Details
p.1 #7My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Nice ones Steve, looking forward to the rest of the vacation slides
Jul 09, 2009 at 07:13 PM
camerapapi
Offline
Details
p.1 #8My D200: a Mini-Essay....
In the first place, those are absolutely gorgeous pictures. The light and colors are very nice and as you have mentioned, the exposures are right on.
The wonderful neutral colors of the D200 are simply beautiful and it renders skin colors among the most beautiful I have seen from other Nikon cameras.
If a camera in the Nikon lineup is closer to the D2X that is the D200. The AF of the D2X is superior and would be my choice for birds in flight and sports photography. Simply, out of curiosity, I wish you had mentioned what lens you used in each particular shot. The 18-55 kit lens is a great optics for pennies and the 50mm f1.8 is a super bargain. Those pictures look as if they had been shot with the 50mm lens.
Most probably you know that Nikon is celebrating this month the introduction in 1959 of the Nikon F. My Nikon F has been idle but I got it out, cleaned it, lubricated the lens mount and run all shutter speeds. Then I proceeded to load a roll of Fuji Superia 200 that I should finish by this coming weekend. I was educated with film cameras and hand held exposure meters and it is a joy using my Nikon F that way. My camera is already 45 years old and still working like a champ.
The D700 is another great tool and you should be very happy with it.
Thank you for sharing such beautiful pictures.

William Rodriguez
Miami, Florida.
Jul 09, 2009 at 07:56 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #9My D200: a Mini-Essay....
camerapapi wrote:
In the first place, those are absolutely gorgeous pictures. The light and colors are very nice and as you have mentioned, the exposures are right on.
The wonderful neutral colors of the D200 are simply beautiful and it renders skin colors among the most beautiful I have seen from other Nikon cameras.
If a camera in the Nikon lineup is closer to the D2X that is the D200. The AF of the D2X is superior and would be my choice for birds in flight and sports photography. Simply, out of curiosity, I wish you had mentioned what lens you used in
...Show more →
Thank you, William, for your thoughtful comments. Believe it or not, the first and last pics were shot with the 18-55 VR. I think I somehow managed to get a stellar copy of that lens. Its performance amazes me sometimes. The middle pic was shot with the Zeiss 25mm. I did also use the 50mm f/1.8 from time to time. Those images will be posted along with the other shots from this trip sometime in the next two weeks.

I was educated with film cameras as well. I used a Minolta 101 body for many years.

Have fun with your F.

- Steve
Jul 09, 2009 at 08:37 PM
lovinglife
Offline
Details
p.1 #10My D200: a Mini-Essay....
The newer generation of Nikons are awesome (i.e. D700) and your pictures are also very nice, but this is the first time I've heard this about the 5d/1dsMk II - "the Canon IQ is to my eyes rather plastic, false and "fabricated" compared to what I've been getting from my D200."
Jul 09, 2009 at 08:42 PM
ssnap
Offline
Details
p.1 #11My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Wonderful images, thanks for sharing. The only thing I wish my D200 was a dust removal system. Other than that I love it!
Jul 09, 2009 at 08:50 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #12My D200: a Mini-Essay....
epuja wrote:
The newer generation of Nikons are awesome (i.e. D700) and your pictures are also very nice, but this is the first time I've heard this about the 5d/1dsMk II - "the Canon IQ is to my eyes rather plastic, false and "fabricated" compared to what I've been getting from my D200."

Other photographers have made similar comments and made similar observations. Most of them have commented on the colors being "plastic." But from the very beginning of my owning Canons, I've noticed a definite tendency towards a "drawn" or "rendered" look, ie like a fine drawing, as opposed to the more film-like rendering of cameras like the Nikon D200 and D2x.

It's gotten to the point where I can almost always identify when a NY Times Magazine image has been shot with a Canon, most notably when it's a portrait. The faces look more like fine paintings than photographs. This is often very subtle, and one has to look for it. Other times it's quite noticeable. I've also concluded that the higher the resolution, the more this might occur. My old Canon 10D looked more film-like than my more recent 5D or 1Ds II.

- Steve
Jul 09, 2009 at 08:51 PM
timontario
Offline
Details
p.1 #13My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Wow... Anyone wanna buy my Canon stuff?

I love just how crisp the supports for the dock's are in the last photo. I feel like i could zoom to 100% and see the cob-webs under the dock.

Those are beautiful.
Jul 09, 2009 at 09:00 PM
Avi B
Offline
Details
p.1 #14My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Steve, fantastic shots with the baby-D2X

You know it's funny you say that about Canon images after having used them for so long. That was my first impression about Canon cameras, that the images looked "plastic" to my eyes. The Nikon cameras (I started off with a D70s) seemed to produce images that "looked" more like photographs to my eyes. But this is of course all subjective.

Anyway, I find it interesting that you picked up a D2X on a whim a year or so ago and sold it soon thereafter, and grew to miss it. There's something about the D2 bodies that's just so nice isn't there?
Jul 10, 2009 at 01:54 AM
mortyb
Offline
Details
p.1 #15My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Thanks for photos and your write-up on the D200. Very interesting to read, as I kinda moved the opposite way from a D200 to a 5D. Still have both and a D700. I can share my findings but that'd have to be later. Looking forward to more photos from your trip.
Jul 10, 2009 at 03:44 AM
lou f
Offline
Details
p.1 #16My D200: a Mini-Essay....
i shoot with a d200 and d700, the d200 is now scuba only. if you like the exposure off the d200 the d700 will blow your socks off.
Jul 10, 2009 at 04:36 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #17My D200: a Mini-Essay....
mortyb wrote:
Thanks for photos and your write-up on the D200. Very interesting to read, as I kinda moved the opposite way from a D200 to a 5D. Still have both and a D700. I can share my findings but that'd have to be later. Looking forward to more photos from your trip.


It would be interesting to hear your views on the 5D vs. D700. Hope you'll post sometime soon.

- Steve
Jul 10, 2009 at 06:14 AM
Slug69
Offline
Details
p.1 #18My D200: a Mini-Essay....
My jaw dropped when you said the first and third were from the 18 -55. I was confident it was the Zeiss 25mm when you outlined your lens line-up.

My appreciation of Nikons dslr's took a quantum leap after I paid the extra cash to get Capture NX after using my D70 without it for two years. They already had me with the SB-600/800 and the excellent 18-70.

I know where you are coming from when comparing the look of a Canon photo to a Nikon. Good or bad who knows. It didn't stop me from buying prints from Canon shooters here!

It is interesting to see Nikons top level cameras with excellent sensors and "full frame" to boot. But it was their entry level gear which kept them in the game. Your photos using one of their kit lens proves it.
Jul 10, 2009 at 06:24 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.1 #19My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Slug69 wrote:
My jaw dropped when you said the first and third were from the 18 -55. I was confident it was the Zeiss 25mm when you outlined your lens line-up.

My appreciation of Nikons dslr's took a quantum leap after I paid the extra cash to get Capture NX after using my D70 without it for two years. They already had me with the SB-600/800 and the excellent 18-70.

I know where you are coming from when comparing the look of a Canon photo to a Nikon. Good or bad who knows. It didn't stop me from buying prints from Canon shooters
...Show more →

I had to double-check my camera settings via NX (all of my Nikon shots are processed in NX, with a little bit of touch-up in Photoshop) when I first saw the 18-55 shots. I was certain I'd shot them with the 18-55, but when I opened them at home I thought I was mistaken and that they were taken with the Zeiss. Great lens, that 18-55. But the low-quality build means it must be handled with care. I have a feeling a hard knock will pretty much change this lens' performance.

- Steve


Jul 10, 2009 at 07:10 AM
Slug69
Offline
Details
p.1 #20My D200: a Mini-Essay....
Those trees just pop on that first pic. Really interesting photo. I hear you about the build quality of the 18 -55 - getting what you pay for...the image quality is a bonus.
Jul 10, 2009 at 07:25 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister