epuja wrote:
The newer generation of Nikons are awesome (i.e. D700) and your pictures are also very nice, but this is the first time I've heard this about the 5d/1dsMk II - "the Canon IQ is to my eyes rather plastic, false and "fabricated" compared to what I've been getting from my D200."
Other photographers have made similar comments and made similar observations. Most of them have commented on the colors being "plastic." But from the very beginning of my owning Canons, I've noticed a definite tendency towards a "drawn" or "rendered" look, ie like a fine drawing, as opposed to the more film-like rendering of cameras like the Nikon D200 and D2x.
It's gotten to the point where I can almost always identify when a NY Times Magazine image has been shot with a Canon, most notably when it's a portrait. The faces look more like fine paintings than photographs. This is often very subtle, and one has to look for it. Other times it's quite noticeable. I've also concluded that the higher the resolution, the more this might occur. My old Canon 10D looked more film-like than my more recent 5D or 1Ds II.
- Steve